Table 4.
MATERNAL CONSIDERATIONS | ||
---|---|---|
Domain | Exposures | Timing |
Demographics | Age at study entry; Ethnicity; Socioeconomic status; Parity; Health conditions (especially allergic or immune disease) | At recruitment |
Antibiotic use | Indication; Type; Duration of use; Number of Courses | Within 6 months of conception, during pregnancy and/or during delivery |
Probiotic use | Type/Strain; Frequency of use; Duration of use | Within 6 months of conception and during pregnancy |
Anthropometry | Weight; Height; BMI; GWG. Ideal: Waist-To-Hip Ratio; Body Composition (Fat Mass; Fat-Free Mass) |
At conception and across pregnancy Ideal: at least thrice in pregnancy |
Dietary intake | Dietary patterns; Nutrient intake; Dietary Diversity; Fiber intake; Dietary Supplement Intake (type, frequency and duration of use) | Within 6 months of conception and during pregnancy Ideal: at least twice in pregnancy |
Diabetes status | Diagnosis of type I or type II diabetes mellitus prior to conception; Diagnosis of GDM; Diagnosis of Insulin Resistance; Metformin use; Insulin use | At conception and across pregnancy |
Mental health | Stress; Self-Efficacy; Mental Illness (Depression; Anxiety; Others) | At conception and during pregnancy Ideal: at least twice in pregnancy |
Medications (e.g. PPIs, steroids) | Indication; Type; Duration; Number of Courses | Within 6 months of conception, during pregnancy and/or during delivery |
Others as specific/pertinent to research questions, e.g. sleep, household size, social support, health literacy, air pollution, pet ownership, etc. |
As relevant to outcomes of interest |
|
INFANT CONSIDERATIONS | ||
Domain |
Exposures |
Timing |
Demographics | Gender; Gestational Age; Siblings (Number; Ages) | At birth |
Birth mode | Vaginal delivery; Surgically assisted delivery; Spontaneous or Induced; Indication for cesarean delivery, if applicable) | At birth |
Antibiotic use | Indication; Type; Duration of use; Number of Courses | At birth and any exposure across the first 1,000 days |
Probiotic use | Type/Strain; Frequency of use; Duration of use; Indication (if applicable) | Any exposure across the first 1,000 days |
Anthropometry | Weight; Length; Weight-for-Length Ideal: Body Composition (Fat Mass; Fat-Free Mass) |
At birth, 6 months, 12 months and 24 months Ideal: whenever dietary intake is assessed |
Breastmilk or Formula feeding | Breastfeeding; Formula-feeding; Mixed-feeding; Duration of Exclusive Breastfeeding; Total Duration of Any Breastfeeding; Total Duration of Formula-Feeding; Type of Formula (Standard; Hydrolyzed; Prebiotic-Containing) | From birth and across the first 1,000 days, at least four times (e.g. 0–3 months, 4–6 months, 8–12 months and 12–24 months) |
Solid food intake | Age at Introduction to Solids; Dietary patterns; Nutrient intake; Dietary Diversity; Fiber intake; Texture | From 4 to 24 months, at least three times (e.g. 4–6 months, 8–12 months and 12–24 months) |
Medications | Indication; Type; Duration; Number of Courses | At birth and any exposure across the first 1,000 days |
Others as specific/pertinent to research questions, e.g. neurocognitive development, sleep, household size, air pollution, pet ownership, etc. |
As relevant to outcomes of interest |
|
METHODOLOGICAL CONSIDERATIONS | ||
Domain |
Outcomes/considerations |
|
Overall design | Recruitment methods and dropout rates clearly described; Comparisons made between participants and those lost to follow up, by exposure status; Main potential confounders are identified and accounted for in study design and analysis; Randomization and concealment occur where possible. | |
Terminology | Concepts or terms used to describe the gut microbiome should be consistent across studies. | |
Microbiome analysis | Use of culture independent methodology (e.g. 16S rRNA gene sequencing, metagenomic sequencing); Measures of composition (e.g. total bacterial counts, relative abundance); Measure of diversity (e.g. Shannon and Simpson indices) and richness (e.g. Chao1); Appropriate OTU classification (to amplicon sequence variants, or metagenomic strains); Use of compositional data analytical approaches; Clear reporting of methodologies used and limitations of same. | |
Sampling frequency | Longitudinal measurement across the first 1,000 days, with most infant samples after 2 weeks, e.g., Mothers in early pregnancy (0–12 weeks); Mothers in late pregnancy (32–40 weeks); Infants at 1–3 months (prior to introduction of solids); Infants at 4–6 months (when solids have been introduced); Infants at 9–12 months (increasing dietary diversity and complexity, possible weaning formula and/or breastfeeding, introduction of other milks). |
BMI = Body Mass Index; GWG = Gestational Weight Gain; GDM = Gestational Diabetes Mellitus; PPI = Proton Pump Inhibitor; OTU = Operational Taxonomic Unit.