Table 2.
Summary of literature search results evaluating effects of Medicaid expansion for the three key domains of changes in insurance rates, cancer screening and access to care, and socioeconomic disparities.
Citation, Author, Year | Sample | Cancer Type | Sample Size | More Insurance Coverage | More Screening & Treatment | Reduced Socioeconomic Disparities |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
24. Okoro et al. 2017 | BRFSS. 18–64 years old. 2014. | Breast, cervical, colorectal | 277,734 | Not studied for cancer patients | Yes, greater breast (3ppt), cervical (1.5ppt), and colorectal (2.5ppt) cancer screening | Yes, reduced income gap in breast cancer screening, but not for cervical and colorectal cancer screening |
25. Lyu et al. 2019 | BRFSS. Low-income adults (<138% FPL). 18–64 years old. 2012 vs. 2016. | Breast, cervical, colorectal | 31,890 | Not studied. | Yes, greater breast (11.4ppt), cervical (6.9ppt), and colorectal (8.3ppt) cancer screening | Not studied. |
26. Mahal et al. 2020 | SEER. 18–64 years old. 2010–2014. | Breast, lung, and prostate | 108,864 | Yes, 71% fewer uninsured in Medicaid expansion states. | Not studied. | Yes, elimination of uninsured gap between Blacks (90.5% decrease) and Whites and between low-income (<138% FPL, 7% decrease) and high income people. |
27. Chino et al. 2017 | SEER. Radiation recipients. 18–64 years old. 2011–2014. | All Cancer | 197,290 | Yes, 53% fewer uninsured | Not studied. | Yes, greatest gains among Blacks (50%), high poverty areas (60% fewer uninsured) |
28. Jemal et al. 2017 | NCDB. 18–64 years old. 2011–2014. | All Cancer | 1,718,864 | Yes, 54.7% fewer uninsured | No, similar shift to earlier stage | Yes, reduced income gap in uninsured rate (62.5% fewer uninsured at <138%FPL) |
29. Moss et al. 2017 | SEER. Women. <65 years old. 2008–2014. | Cervical, uterine or ovarian | 90,192 | Yes, 50% fewer uninsured | No, shift toward later stage | Yes, reduced Black (by 50%) and low-income uninsured rate (by 72%) |
30. Cannon et al. 2018 | SEER. 19–64 years old. 2007–2014. | Head and Neck Squamous Cell Carcinoma | 89,038 | Yes, 52% fewer uninsured, 9.5% more via Medicaid | Not studied. | Not studied. |
31. Crocker et al. 2018 | HCUP-SID (Florida, Kentucky, Maryland, New Jersey, North Carolina). Cancer surgery patients. 18–64 years old. 2012–2015. | Colorectal, esophagogastric, hepatobiliary, lung, and urologic | 78,915 | Yes, 13.4% fewer uninsured | Yes, 4.1% increase in non-discretionary cancer surgeries (5.3% decrease in non-expansion states) | Not studied. |
32. Eguia et al. 2018 | HCUP-SID (Florida, Iowa, Maryland, New York). 18–64 years old. 2010–2014. | Pancreas, esophagus, prostate, bladder, colorectal, lung, and gastric | 317,858 | Yes, Medicaid insured increased: 12% for pancreatic, 14% for breast, 11% for colorectal, 34% for prostate, and 23% for gastric cancers (Expansion vs. non-expansion states) | Yes, cancer surgery rates up 30% for lung cancer, 25% for breast cancer, 25% for colorectal cancer in Medicaid Expansion states compared to non-expansion states | Yes, disparities in odds to undergo surgery between Medicaid and privately insured cancer patients of Black race and Hispanic race decreased after Medicaid expansion and increased in non-expansion states |
33. Han et al. 2018 | NAACCR (40 states). First primary malignant cancer. 18–64 years old. 2010–2014. | All Cancer | 2,471,154 | Yes, 50% fewer uninsured | Yes, 2.3% greater early-stage diagnosis: all cancers combined | Yes, reduced insurance disparities based on race (for Blacks and Hispanics), income, and rural residence |
34. Moss et al. 2018 | SEER. 0–64 years old. 2008–2014. | Breast, lung, and colon | 414,085 | Yes, fewer uninsured, more Medicaid insured: Colon (−50%,+38%) lung (−57%,+24%) breast (−33%,+14%) cancer | Yes, increase in early- stage diagnoses by 1.2% for breast, 6.4% for colon, but no change for lung cancer | Yes, uninsured rates decreased for all races except: American Indians/Alaskan Natives for lung & colon cancer, and except Blacks and American Indians/Alaskan Natives for breast cancer |
35. Soni et al. 2018 | SEER. First time cancer diagnosis. 19–64 years old. 2010–2014. | All Cancer | 3,055 | Not studied. | Yes, 6.4% increase in early-stage diagnoses | Not studied. |
36. Agarwal et al. 2019 | SEER. 0–64 years old. 2011–2015. Compared expansion states against non-expansion states. | All Cancer | 716,364 | Yes, 3% greater decrease in uninsured in expansion vs. non-expansion states | Not studied. | Yes, greatest decreases in uninsured among rural (−4.8%) & minorities except Asians and Pacific Islanders: Black (−3.4%), Hispanic (−3.9%) |
37. Crocker et al. 2019 | HCUP-SID (Florida, Kentucky, Maryland, New Jersey, North Carolina). Inpatient cancer surgery patients. 18–64 years old. 2012–2015 | Colorectal, esophagogastric, hepatobiliary, pancreatic, lung, urologic | 81,628 | Yes, 82.6% more insured via Medicaid in expansion states; 10.1% fewer Medicaid-insured in non-expansion states | Yes, 10.8% greater utilization by Medicaid & uninsured patients; 9.5% less in non-expansion states | Mixed Results. Expansion narrowed the income gap but not the race gap (Whites relative to Blacks and Hispanics) in cancer surgery utilization |
38. Spiegel et al. 2019 | SEER. New diagnosis. 19–64 years old. 2011–2014. | Breast, cervical, uterine, or prostate with brachytherapy | 15,497 | Yes, 38% fewer uninsured | Not studied. | Mixed Results. Expansion narrowed insurance income gap but not the race gap (Whites relative to Blacks and Hispanics) |
39. Huguet et al. 2019 | ADVANCE clinical data. Age-based screening cohorts from 21–64 years old. 2012–2015. | Cervical and colorectal | 329,126 | Yes, Medicaid visit rate up 56%, uninsured visit rate decreased 52% after Medicaid expansion | No, similar screening rates since increased in both states | Yes, narrowed race gap (Whites relative to Blacks and Hispanics) for cervical and colorectal cancer screening |
40. Mesquita-Neto et al. 2019 | SEER. All patients. 2007–2009 vs. 2014–2015. | Breast, colorectal, ovarian, lung, uterine, pancreatic, prostate, and liver | 293,028 | Yes, 50% fewer uninsured in Medicaid expansion states | Yes, 12.8% increase in early-stage diagnoses | Yes, 54.5% fewer uninsured & 3.8% greater access to surgery for people of low socioeconomic standing |
41. Sineshaw et al. 2020 | NCDB. 18–64 years old. 2010–2016. | Head and Neck Squamous Cell Carcinoma | 90,789 | Yes, 63% decrease in uninsured, 18% increase in Medicaid insured in Medicaid expansion states | Yes, 3.8% increase in early-stage diagnoses. Time to treatment initiation down 5.5 days for nonoropharyngeal head & neck squamous cell carcinoma, no difference for overall head & neck squamous cell carcinoma | Not studied. |
42. Takvorian et al. 2020 | NCDB. 40-64 years old. 2011–2016 | Breast, colon, non-small cell lung | 848,329 | Yes, 24% more Medicaid-insured and 55% fewer uninsured in Medicaid expansion states | Yes, 4.4% increase in early-stage diagnoses, 2.2% fewer late-stage diagnoses in expansion states. No time to treatment initiation difference between expansion and non-expansion states | Not studied. |
43. Ajkay et al. 2018 | Kentucky Cancer Registry. Women. 20-64 years old. 2011–2016. | Breast | 1,315,965 | Yes, 73% fewer uninsured, 54% more via Medicaid | Yes, earlier stage (up 3.4%; 2.2ppt), earlier treatment (5.1% sooner) | Not studied. |
44. Cawley et al. 2018 | BRFSS. Low-income childless adults. 19–64 years old. 2010–2016 | Breast and cervical | 80,200 | Yes, 16.7% more insured | No screening change, but better access to care overall | Not studied. |
45. Nikpay et al. 2018 | BRFSS. All-Cancer survivors. 18–64 years old. 2011–2015 | All Cancer | 17,381 | Yes, 52.6% fewer uninsured | Yes, care (9ppt) & meds (14ppt) both more affordable | Not studied. |
46. Alharbi et al. 2019 | MEPS. Women. Low-income. <65 years old. 2012–2016. | Breast and cervical | 13,078 | Yes, 100% more insured via Medicaid | No, mammograms at the same rate and Papanicolaou tests at a lower rate | Not studied. |
47. Gan et al. 2019 | Kentucky Cancer Registry and Kentucky Hospital Discharge Database. 20+ years old. 2011–2016 | Colorectal | 930,176 | Yes, 230% increase in screened Medicaid insured | Yes, more diagnosed, earlier stage, better survival (Hazard Ratio = 0.73) | Yes, patients from Appalachian parts of Kentucky (rural) saw 199% increase in Medicaid and 77.7% decrease in uninsured. Early stage diagnosis increased 9.3% for Appalachians post-expansion |
48. Hendryx et al. 2018 | BRFSS. Low-income childless adults. 18–64 years old. 2012 vs. 2016. | Breast, cervical, and colorectal | 56,959 | Not studied. | Yes, greater screening rates: cervical (2ppt) and colorectal (3.2ppt) (Expansion vs. Non-expansion states) | Yes, helped reduced gap in screening between low and high income folks. |
49. Zerhouni et al. 2019 | BRFSS. White, Black, and Hispanic respondents with complete demographic answers. Age 50–64 years old. 2012–2016 | Colorectal | 341,350 | Not studied. | No, 8% more likely to get colorectal cancer screening in expansion states than non-expansion states, but no increase after 2014 Medicaid expansion | No, no statistically significant changes in disparities after 2014 Medicaid expansion. Statistically significant changes in race (Whites relative to Blacks and Hispanics) and income disparity reduction only seen in states that expanded Medicaid prior to 2014. |
Summary | 17 from national/multi-state databases, 7 from national surveys, 2 from Kentucky databases | All Cancer (6), Breast (11), Gastrointestinal (11), Gynecologic (9), Lung (7), Squamous Cell Carcinoma (2), Urologic (6) | 10,928,809 | 21 out of 21 articles | 15 out of 21 articles | 16 out of 17 articles |
Abbreviations: ADVANCE (Accelerating Data Value Across a National Community Health Center Network), BRFSS (Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System), HCUP-SID (Healthcare Cost and Utilization Project - State Inpatient Databases), MEPS (Medical Expenditure Panel Survey), NAACR (North American Association of Cancer Registries), NCDB (National Cancer Database), SEER (Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results Program); ppt (Percentage Point); FPL (Federal Poverty Level).