Skip to main content
. 2021 Jul 14;4(7):e2117052. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2021.17052

Table 1. Negative Language Categoriesa.

Categories Definitions Examplesb
Questioning credibility Implication of physician disbelief of patient reports of their own experience or behaviors
  • He insists the pain is behind his knee.

  • He claims that nicotine patches don’t work for him.

  • I listed several fictitious medication names and she reported she was taking them, and that she takes “whatever is written there”

  • Disapproval

  • Highlights poor reasoning, decision-making, or self-care, usually in a way that conveys the patient is unreasonable

  • Reports that if she were to fall, she would just “lay there” until someone found her

  • He was adamant that he does not have prostate cancer because his “bowels are working fine.”

  • Counseled that there is no evidence for this, but patient has strong beliefs.

  • She is adamant that she cannot perform any kind of exercise due to pain and will not change her diet.

  • Stereotyping

  • Quoting African American Vernacular English

  • Chief complaint - “I stay tired”

  • Reports that the bandage got “a li’l wet”

  • Quoting incorrect grammar or unsophisticated terms

  • States that the lesion “busted open”

  • Reports she was unable to fill prescription for the “sugar pill”

  • Difficult patient

  • Inclusion of details with questionable clinical significance that depict the patient as belligerent or otherwise suggests that the physician is annoyed

  • She persevered on the fact that “a lot of stuff is going on at home with my family” but that “you wouldn't understand.”

  • I informed her that this is unlikely to be helped by antibiotics and talked about smoking cessation with her. She said she will ask her ‘sinus doctor’ for antibiotics.

  • Unilateral Decisions

  • Language that emphasizes physician authority over patient

  • She was told to discontinue…

  • I have instructed him to…

a

Note categories are not mutually exclusive and often overlapping.

b

Examples in tables are from actual encounter notes in the study.