Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2021 Jul 15.
Published in final edited form as: Advers Resil Sci. 2020 Mar 13;1(1):5–28. doi: 10.1007/s42844-020-00001-x

Table 1.

Summary of randomized controlled trials on interventions for maltreatment exposed youth

Citation Age group Special populations Intervention Condition Outcomes
Ahmad et al., (2007) 6–16 years Norway, Sweden EMDR Waitlist control ↓ Scores PTSS-C: PTSD symptom subscale, re-experiencing and avoidance subscales
Ahrens & Rexford (2002) Adolescents Incarcerated and/or conduct disorders CPT Waitlist control ↓ Anxiety, depression, intrusions, avoidance, numbing
Auslander et al., (2017) 12–18 years Girls in child welfare GAIN-CBITS Treatment as usual ↓ Number of girls with PTSD and depression
↑ Social problem-solving skills
Cohen & Mannarino, (1998b) 3–7 years Sexually abuse SAS-CBT Non-directive supportive therapy ↓ Sexually inappropriate and externalizing behavior, PTSD symptoms
Cohen et al., (2004) 8–14 years Sexual abuse TF-CBT Child-centered therapy ↓ Behavioral problems, shame-related attributions
↑ PTSD and depression symptom reduction
Crooks et al., (2011) 14–15 years Violent delinquency Fourth R Health class ↓ Delinquency
Damra et al., (2014) Not specified; children Jordan: children with abuse histories TF-CBT Waitlist control ↓ PTSD, depression symptoms
Deblinger et al., (2011) 4–11 years Sexual abuse TF-CBT ± trauma narrative 8 or 16 weeks of TF-CBT; with or without trauma narrative component ↓ Abuse-related fear and anxiety
↑ Personal safety skills; effective regardless of trauma narrative
Deblinger et al., (2001) 2–8 years Sexually abused children + non-offending mother CBT Supportive therapy ↑ Knowledge of body safety
Fantuzzo et al., (1996) 3–5 years Project Head Start; socially withdrawn children with physical abuse and neglect histories RPT Waitlist control ↓ Solitary play
↑ Positive peer interactions
Farkas et al., (2010) Not specified; adolescents EMDR Treatment as usual ↓ PTSD symptoms, behavioral problems
Foa et al., (2013) Not specified; adolescents Sexual abuse PE Supportive counseling ↓ PTSD symptom severity, depression
↑ Global functioning
Ford et al., (2012) 13–17 years Girls involved in delinquency TARGET Enhanced treatment as usual ↓ Re-experiencing, avoidance, anxiety, posttraumatic cognitions
↑ Emotion regulation
Jee et al., (2015) 14–21 years Mindfulness Treatment as usual ↑ Stress management skills, self-awareness
Jensen et al., (2014) 10–18 years TF-CBT Treatment as usual ↓ Posttraumatic stress, functional impairment
↑ General mental health
Kim & Leve (2011) 12–17 years Substance use and delinquency in girls in foster care Middle school success Treatment as usual ↓ Substance use, internalizing and externalizing behaviors
↑ Prosocial skills
King et al.,(2000) 5–17 years Sexual abuse CBT (individual or family) Waitlist control ↓ PTSD, anxiety, fear
↑ Global functioning = Parent or individual CBT
McMullen et al., (2013) 13–17 years Democratic Republic of Congo: child soldiers and other war-affected youth TF-CBT Waitlist control ↓ Posttraumatic stress symptoms, overall distress, depression, anxiety, conduct problems
↑ Prosocial behavior
Murray et al., (2015) 5–18 years Zambia: orphans TF-CBT Treatment as usual ↓ Trauma symptom score, overall functioning
O’Callaghan et al., (2015) 13–17 years Democratic Republic of Congo: child soldiers and other war-affected youth TF-CBT Child friendly spaces (non-trauma-focused intervention) or waitlist control Both:
↓ Posttraumatic stress, internalizing symptoms, conduct problems, prosocial behavior
O’Callaghan et al., (2013) 12–17 years Democratic Republic of Congo: sexually exploited girls TF-CBT Waitlist control ↓ Posttraumatic stress symptoms, psychosocial difficulties
Poulton et al.,(2014) 13–17 years Delinquent girls in foster care TFCO Group care ↓ Symptoms of psychosis
Rahman et al., (2018) 11–12 years Pakistan Forgiveness therapy Treatment as usual ↓ Anger
↑ Levels of hope and forgiveness
Scheeringa et al., (2011) 3–6 years Heterogeneous maltreatment histories TF-CBT Waitlist Control ↓ PTSD, depression, social anxiety disorder symptoms
Smith et al., (2010) 12–17 years Chronic delinquency TFCO Group care ↓ Drug and substance use
Swart & Apsche, (2014) 14–17 years Conduct and personality disorders MDT CBT ↓ Anger, internalizing and externalizing behaviors
Swenson et al., (2010) 10–17 years MST-CAN Enhanced outpatient treatment ↓ Psychopathology (anxiety, depression, anger, dissociation, posttraumatic stress), parent emotional distress, negative parenting behavior, changes in youth placement
↑ Social support for parents
Taussig & Culhane, (2010) 9–11 years Foster care Fostering healthy futures Treatment as usual ↓ Dissociative symptoms
↑ Quality of life, positive coping skills, social acceptance, self-worth
Thomas & Zimmer-Gembeck, (2012) 3–9 years PCIT Waitlist control ↓ Internalizing and externalizing behaviors, stress
↑ Positive parenting verbalizations

CBT, cognitive behavioral therapy; CPT, cognitive processing therapy; EMDR, eyemovement desensitization and reprocessing; GAINCBITS, Girls Aspiring towards independence–Cognitive Behavioral Intervention for Trauma in Schools; MDT, mode deactivation therapy; MST-CAN, multisystemic therapy for child abuse and neglect; PCIT, parent–child interaction therapy; PE, prolonged exposure therapy; RPT, resilient peer treatment; SAS-CBT, sexual-abuse-specific cognitive behavioral therapy; STAIR, Skills Training in Affective and Interpersonal Regulation; TARGET, Trauma Affective Regulation: Guide for Education and Therapy; TF-CBT, trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy; TFCO, Treatment Foster Care Oregon