Skip to main content
. 2021 Jul 16;9(20):5372–5390. doi: 10.12998/wjcc.v9.i20.5372

Table 1.

Clinical trials and meta-analyses comparing primary antibiotic treatment vs surgery for acute appendicitis

Ref.
Publishing year
Study design
Patients in NOM (n)
Age (yr)
Initially successful
Recurrence rate
Harnoss et al[10] 2017 Meta-analysis 1312 13-75 89.2% 1-yr: 27.4%
Podda et al[11] 2019 Meta-analysis 1743 Unrestricted 91.5% 1-yr: 19.2%
Eriksson et al[13] 1995 RCT 20 ≥ 18 95% 1-yr: 37%
APPAC study[14,15] 2015 Multicentre RCT 257 ≥ 18 94% 1-yr: 27%; 5-yr: 39.1%;
Minneci et al[16] 2016 Prospective cohort 37 7-17 94.6% 30-d: 5.4%; 1-yr: 18.9%
Georgiou et al[72] 2017 Meta-analysis 413 < 18 97% Adjusted: 14%
Joo et al[73] 2017 Prospective observational 20 Pregnant women 85% 10%

The table is not an exhaustive list and the scope has been restricted to references that are discussed in the main text. NOM: Nonoperative management; RCT: Randomised controlled trial.