Skip to main content
. 2021 Apr 16;50(9):1681–1697. doi: 10.1007/s13280-021-01529-7

Table 2.

Characteristics of studies included in the review on the conservation and management of useful wild plant species in the Andean Community

Reference Year published Reference type Study countriesa Biomesb Useful plant categoriesc Sustainabilityd
Rodríguez-Calderón et al. 2019 Article Colombia F All n/a
Balslev et al. 2010 Article Peru F HF; MA Unsustainable
Fadiman 2008 Article Ecuador F MA n/a
Coomes 2004 Article Peru F MA Unsustainable
O’Neill et al. 2001 Article Peru F All n/a
Gray et al. 2015 Article Ecuador F All Variable
García et al. 2013 Article Colombia F; M MA Sustainable
García et al. 2016 Article Colombia F MA Unsustainable
Kalliola and Flores 2011 Article Peru F HF Sustainable
de la Torre et al. 2011 Article Colombia, Ecuador, Peru, Bolivia n/a All n/a
Phillips et al. 1994 Article Peru F All n/a
Prance et al. 1987 Article Bolivia F All n/a
Rodríguez and Maldonado 2009 Article Colombia F All n/a
Gavin and Anderson 2007 Article Peru F All n/a
Willem et al. 2019 Article Peru F HF Variable
Quaedvlieg et al. 2014 Article Peru F HF n/a
Pyhälä, et al. 2006 Article Peru F All n/a
Bussmann and Sharon 2014 Article Peru; Ecuador F ME n/a
Bussmann et al. 2008 Article Peru S ME n/a
Duchelle 2007 Article Ecuador F All n/a
Thomas et al. 2017 Article Peru F HF n/a
Ramirez 2005 Article Colombia F ME n/a
Álvarez Salas et al. 2016 Article Colombia F HF n/a
Cronkleton et al. 2012 Article Bolivia F HF; MA Unsustainable
Coomes and Burt 2001 Article Peru F FU Variable
Duchelle et al. 2011 Article Bolivia F HF n/a
Guariguata et al. 2008 Article Bolivia F HF; MA n/a
Kvist et al. 2001 Article Peru F All Variable
Pacheco and Cronkleton 2008 Technical report Bolivia F HF n/a
Nebel 2001 Article Peru F All n/a
Duchelle et al. 2012 Article Peru; Bolivia F HF; MA Variable
Vennetier et al. 2012 Technical report Bolivia D HF n/a
De Jong et al. 2000 Article Bolivia; Peru n/a All n/a
Vallejo et al. 2016 Article Colombia F HF Unsustainable
Hoch et al. 2009 Article Peru; Ecuador; Bolivia F MA; All Variable
Vallejo et al. 2014 Article Colombia F HF Unsustainable
Gavin 2009 Article Peru F All n/a
Herrero-Jáuregui et al. 2013 Article Colombia, Ecuador, Peru, Bolivia F HF; ME; MA; EU n/a
Isaza et al. 2017 Article Colombia F HF Unsustainable
Rodríguez et al. 2018 Article Colombia S All Unsustainable
Svenning and Macía 2002 Article Ecuador F MA Variable
Fadiman 2019 Article Ecuador F MA Unsustainable
Weigend and Dostert 2005 Bulletin Peru X ME Sustainable
Kiehn 2004 Article Ecuador F All Variable
Argüello and Aguilar 2006 Bulletin Ecuador G ME Sustainable
Horn et al. 2012 Article Peru F HF Unsustainable
Bennett 2002 Article Ecuador F All n/a
Sælemyr 2004 Article Ecuador S All Sustainable
Manzi and Coomes 2009 Article Peru F HF Sustainable
Horn et al. 2018 Article Peru F HF n/a
Bruiton 1999 Technical report Ecuador n/a ME n/a
Hofstede et al. 2011 Book chapter Ecuador S; F All Sustainable
Cuoco and Cronan 2009 Article Ecuador F SU Unsustainable
Mesa-C and Galeano 2013 Article Colombia F All Unsustainable
Laureto and Cianciaruso 2017 Article Colombia n/a All n/a
Janni and Bastien 2000 Article Bolivia F ME n/a
Marshall et al. 2006 Technical report Bolivia F All Variable
Morsello et al. 2012 Article Bolivia F; G MA Variable
Newton et al. 2006 Article Bolivia F All Variable
Nuzzo and Aubertin 2007 Article Bolivia D MA n/a
Pedersen and Skov 2001 Article Ecuador n/a All Sustainable
Paneque-Gálvez et al. 2018 Article Bolivia F; G All n/a
Reyes-García et al. 2011 Article Bolivia F; G All Variable
Reyes-Garcia et al. 2007 Article Bolivia F; G All Variable
Sosnowska et al. 2015 Article Peru F All Sustainable
Thomas et al. 2011 Article Bolivia D FU Unsustainable
Camara-Leret et al. 2014 Article Colombia, Ecuador, Peru, Bolivia F; S All n/a
Stoian 2004 Book chapter Bolivia F HF Unsustainable

aWhere studies were undertaken in multiple countries, only those in the Andean Community are listed

bDefined as per Olson et al. (2001). Abbreviations: F, Tropical and subtropical moist broadleaf forests; D, Tropical and subtropical dry broadleaf forests; G, Tropical and subtropical grasslands, savannas, and shrublands; S, Montane grasslands and shrubland; X, Deserts and xeric shrublands; M, Mangroves; n/a biome type was not relevant

cSee Table 1. ‘All’ indicates that all plant uses were characterized rather than focusing on particular categories

dSustainability of harvesting regime or conservation intervention, based on results and conclusions of the study. ‘Variable’ if sustainable harvesting occurred only under certain contexts; ‘n/a’ if no relevant assessment was undertaken