Table 1.
Plant species, response variables extracted, subgroup of the response variable extracted and references used in the meta-analysis.
Species | Response variable extracted | Subgroup of the response variable extracted | References | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Shoot %N | Root %N | Root N-uptake rate | Protein concentration | Growth form | Functional group | Treatment technique | ||
Abutilon theophrasti | * | * | NWD | NL | GC | Coleman and Bazzaz (1992) | ||
Acer rubrum | * | W | NL | OTC | Norby et al. (2000) | |||
Acer rubrum | * | W | NL | OTC | Wan et al. (2004) | |||
Acer rubrum | * | W | NL | OTC | Williams et al. (2003) | |||
Acer rubrum | * | W | NL | OTC | Williams et al. (2000) | |||
Acer saccharum | * | W | NL | OTC | Norby et al. (2000) | |||
Acer saccharum | * | W | NL | OTC | Wan et al. (2004) | |||
Acer saccharum | * | W | NL | OTC | Williams et al. (2000) | |||
Alliaria petiolata | * | NWD | NL | GC | Anderson and Cipollini (2013) | |||
Amaranthus retroflexus | * | * | NWD | NL | GC | Coleman and Bazzaz (1992) | ||
Betula pendula | * | W | NL | GC | Kellomaki and Wang (2001) | |||
Betula pendula | * | W | NL | CTC | Kuokanen et al. (2001) | |||
Betula pendula | * | W | NL | CTC | Kuokanen et al. (2003) | |||
Betula pendula | * | W | NL | CTC | Lavola et al. (2013) | |||
Brassica juncea | * | NWD | NL | GC | Seth and Misra (2014) | |||
Calluna vulgaris | * | * | W | NL | FACE | Andresen et al. (2009) | ||
Calluna vulgaris | * | * | W | NL | FACE | Andresen et al. (2010) | ||
Calluna vulgaris | * | W | NL | FACE | Arndal et al. (2014) | |||
Coffea arabica | * | G | NL | GC | Ramalho et al. (2018) | |||
Deschampsia flexuosa | * | * | W | NL | FACE | Andresen et al. (2009) | ||
Deschampsia flexuosa | * | * | G | NL | FACE | Andresen et al. (2010) | ||
Deschampsia flexuosa | * | G | NL | FACE | Arndal et al. (2014) | |||
Echinium plantagineum | * | NWD | NL | GC | Johns and Hughes (2002) | |||
Eucalyptus globulus | * | W | NL | CTC | Crous et al. (2013) | |||
Eucalyptus globulus | * | W | NL | OTC | Sharwood et al. (2017) | |||
Eucalyptus robusta | * | W | NL | GH | Gherlenda et al. (2015) | |||
Eucalyptus saligna | * | W | NL | GH | Ayub et al. (2011) | |||
Eucalyptus saligna | * | W | NL | GH | Ghannoum et al. (2010a) | |||
Eucalyptus saligna | * | * | W | NL | GH | Ghannoum et al. (2010b) | ||
Eucalyptus sideroxylon | * | W | NL | GH | Ghannoum et al. (2010a) | |||
Eucalyptus sideroxylon | * | * | W | NL | GH | Ghannoum et al. (2010b) | ||
Eucalyptus tereticornis | * | W | NL | GH | Gherlenda et al. (2015) | |||
Eucalyptus tereticornis | * | W | NL | GH | Gherlenda et al. (2016) | |||
Eucalyptus tereticornis | * | W | NL | GH | Murray et al. (2013) | |||
Geum vernum | * | NWD | NL | GC | Anderson and Cipollini (2013) | |||
Glycine max | * | NWD | L | OTC | Palacios et al. (2019) | |||
Glycine max | * | NWD | L | OTC | Qiao et al. (2019) | |||
Glycine max | * | NWD | L | FACE | Rosenthal et al. (2014) | |||
Gossypium hirsutum | * | W | NL | GC | Zhang et al. (2017) | |||
Grasses | * | G | NL | GC | Johnson and Hartley (2018) | |||
Lantana camara | * | W | NL | GC | Johns et al. (2003) | |||
Lolium perenne | * | * | G | NL | CTC | Soussana et al. (1996) | ||
Lolium perenne | * | G | NL | CTC | Zavalloni et al. (2012) | |||
Lotus corniculatus | * | NWD | L | CTC | Zavalloni et al. (2012) | |||
Medicago lupulina | * | NWD | L | CTC | Zavalloni et al. (2012) | |||
Medicago sativa | * | NWD | L | TGT | Aranjuelo et al. (2005) | |||
Medicago sativa | * | NWD | L | TGT | Aranjuelo et al. (2008) | |||
Medicago sativa | * | NWD | L | GH | Ariz et al. (2015) | |||
Oryza sativa | * | G | NL | FACE | Jing et al. (2016) | |||
Oryza sativa | * | G | NL | TGT | Kim et al. (2011) | |||
Oryza sativa | * | * | G | NL | FACE | Li et al. (2017) | ||
Oryza sativa | * | G | NL | OTC | Liu et al. (2019) | |||
Panicum maximum | * | G | NL | FACE | de Assis Prado et al. (2016) | |||
Phalaris aquatica | * | G | NL | TGT | Lilley et al. (2001) | |||
Phalaris aquatica | * | G | NL | TGT | Volder et al. (2015) | |||
Phaseolus vulgaris | * | NWD | L | CTC | Prasad et al. (2004) | |||
Pinus ponderosa | * | W | NL | GH | King et al. (1997) | |||
Pinus sylvestris | * | W | NL | CTC | Luomala et al. (2003) | |||
Pinus taeda | * | W | NL | GH | King et al. (1997) | |||
Plantago lanceolata | * | G | NL | CTC | Zavalloni et al. (2012) | |||
Poa pratensis | * | G | NL | CTC | Zavalloni et al. (2012) | |||
Pseudotsuga menziesii | * | W | NL | CTC | Chen et al. (2008) | |||
Pseudotsuga menziesii | * | W | NL | CTC | Hobbie et al. (2001) | |||
Quercus robur | * | W | NL | GH | Dury et al. (1998) | |||
Rumex acetosa | * | NWD | NL | CTC | Zavalloni et al. (2012) | |||
Salix myrsinifolia | * | W | NL | CTC | Veteli et al. (2002) | |||
Semiarid grasses | * | * | G | NL | FACE | Dijkstra et al. (2010) | ||
Solanum lycopersicum | * | * | * | * | NWD | NL | GC | Jayawardena et al. (2017) |
Solanum lycopersicum | * | * | * | * | NWD | NL | GC | Jayawardena et al. (2021) |
Species mix | * | N/A | NL | CTC | Kandeler et al. (1998) | |||
Species mix | * | N/A | NL | FACE | Mueller et al. (2016) | |||
Species mix | * | G | NL | CTC | Zavalloni et al. (2012) | |||
Trifolium subterraneum | * | NWD | L | TGT | Lilley et al. (2001) | |||
Triticum aestivum | * | * | * | * | G | NL | GC | Jayawardena et al. (2020) |
Triticum durum | * | NWD | NL | TGT | Jauregui et al. (2015) | |||
Vitis vinifera | * | * | W | NL | GH | Salazar-Parra et al. (2015) | ||
Zea mays | * | G | NL | OTC | Abebe et al. (2016) | |||
Zea mays | * | G | NL | CTC | Kim et al. (2007) | |||
Zea mays | * | G | NL | OTC | Qiao et al. (2019) |
References included in the meta-analysis are available in Supporting Information—Appendix S2.
* denotes the response variable extracted from each reference. Different growth forms are denoted as woody, W; grassy, G; and non-woody dicot, NWD. Different functional groups are denoted as legume, L; and non-legume, NL. Different treatment techniques are denoted as open-top chambers, OTC; closed-top chambers, CTC; greenhouses, GH; free-air CO2 enrichment, FACE; temperature-gradient tunnels, TGT; and growth chambers, GC.