Skip to main content
. 2021 Jul;46(4):237–255. doi: 10.30476/ijms.2021.87555.1793

Table 2.

Quality assessment scores for the included cross-sectional studies

Author Representativeness of the sample Sample size Non-respondents Ascertainment of the exposure Comparability Assessment of the outcome Statistical test Total
Huang et al.2 + + - ++ ++ + + 8
Guan et al.23 + + - ++ ++ + + 8
Fu et al.24 - + - ++ ++ + + 7
Zhou et al.25 + + - ++ ++ + + 8
Chen et al.26 + + - ++ N/A + + 6
Chen et al.27 + + - ++ ++ + + 8
Chen et al.28 + + - ++ ++ + + 8
Chen et al.29 + + - ++ ++ + + 8
Ai et al.30 + + - ++ ++ + + 8
Xu et al.31 + + - ++ ++ + + 8
Zhang et al.32 + + - ++ ++ + + 8
Zhao et al.5 - + - ++ ++ + + 7
Zhao et al.33 + + - ++ ++ + + 8
Tian et al.34 - + - ++ ++ + + 7
Wang et al.35 - + + ++ ++ + + 8
Wang et al.36 - + + ++ N/A + + 6
Huang et al.37 - + - ++ N/A + + 5
Zhang et al.38 - + + ++ N/A + + 6
Zhang et al.39 + + - ++ ++ + + 8
Zhang et al.40 + + - ++ N/A + + 6
Zhao et al.41 + + + ++ ++ + + 7
Tang et al.42 - + - ++ ++ + + 7
Tang et al.43 - + + ++ N/A + + 6
Liao et al.44 + + - ++ ++ + + 8
Qian et al.45 + + + ++ ++ + + 9
Qiu et al.46 + + + ++ ++ + + 9
Shi et al.47 - + - ++ ++ + + 7
Wan et al.48 - + + ++ ++ + + 8
Xu et al.49 - + - ++ N/A + + 5
Wu et al.50 + + - ++ ++ + + 8
Xie et al.51 + + - ++ ++ + + 8
Xu et al.52 + + - ++ ++ + + 8
Zhou et al.25 - + - ++ ++ + + 7
Zhou et al.53 - + - ++ ++ + + 7
Cai et al.54 + + - ++ ++ + + 8
Feng et al.17 + + - ++ ++ + + 8
Feng et al.55 + + - ++ ++ + + 8
Fu et al.18 + + - ++ ++ + + 8
Ji et al.56 + + - ++ ++ + + 8
Han et al.57 - + - ++ ++ + + 7
Jiang et al.58 - + - ++ ++ + + 7
Yang et al.59 - + - ++ ++ ++ + 8

N/A: Not applicable