Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2023 Jan 1.
Published in final edited form as: Soc Networks. 2021 Jun 18;68:148–178. doi: 10.1016/j.socnet.2021.05.002

Table A11.

Percent Decrease in Total Bias under Different Imputation Strategies: Topology Measures for Directed Networks.

Measure Imputation Prison
Sorority
6th Grade
Prosper
RC Elite
HS 13
HS 24
Correlation with Centrality
Correlation with Centrality
Correlation with Centrality
Correlation with Centrality
Correlation with Centrality
Correlation with Centrality
Correlation with Centrality
−.75 0 .75 −.75 0 .75 −.75 0 .75 −.75 0 .75 −.75 0 .75 −.75 0 .75 −.75 0 .75
Component Probabilistic 69 69 68 61 62 59 77 76 77 73 76 76 85 86 91 82 82 86 80 81 84
Symmetric 69 69 68 61 62 59 77 76 77 73 76 76 85 86 91 82 82 86 80 81 84
Asymmetric 69 69 68 61 62 59 77 76 77 73 76 76 85 86 91 82 82 86 80 81 84
Model-based Simple 83 89 93 89 92 91 97 98 98 85 91 93 84 87 92 94 95 97 90 92 94
Model-based Complex 79 86 91 84 88 87 90 89 92 81 88 91 78 81 89 86 88 92 85 88 91
Bicomponent Probabilistic 30 36 39 30 33 33 −101 −36 19 30 39 43 74 73 79 −10 11 38 −1 20 43
Symmetric 30 36 39 30 33 33 −101 −36 19 30 39 43 74 73 79 −10 11 38 −1 20 43
Asymmetric 30 36 39 30 33 33 −101 −36 19 30 39 43 74 73 79 −10 11 38 −1 20 43
Model-based Simple 86 88 89 74 84 87 47 69 84 93 95 95 66 77 84 85 90 94 90 94 96
Model-based Complex 83 86 87 80 87 87 59 78 89 92 93 93 81 88 91 92 95 96 93 96 96
Distance Probabilistic 36 33 27 24 38 33 27 40 36 35 38 33 8 16 19 64 57 52 68 59 51
Symmetric −19 49 63 −35 41 51 −47 47 73 15 74 73 −2616 −2138 −1463 55 75 82 59 81 85
Asymmetric −22 −13 −8 −26 −15 −9 −42 −83 −40 −22 −11 −7 −3 −6 −3 −23 −16 −10 −23 −14 −9
Model-based Simple −35 46 71 −127 2 46 −54 42 78 −40 47 72 −1075 −662 −392 32 58 76 22 56 76
Model-based Complex −10 59 74 −74 32 59 −27 59 76 −7 67 81 −663 −353 −202 60 80 93 50 78 92
Transitivity Probabilistic 16 35 45 12 4 8 −131 −135 −121 −53 −26 −8 48 51 64 −109 −141 −107 −94 −135 −101
Symmetric 8 26 34 4 −2 0 −196 −207 −197 −85 −68 −52 −222 −195 −82 −162 −204 −162 −125 −171 −134
Asymmetric 34 41 45 45 50 53 35 35 39 29 40 44 53 55 71 41 42 47 40 40 44
Model-based Simple −82 −48 −20 −142 −112 −74 −379 −365 −301 −282 −235 −171 −190 −147 −46 −538 −583 −396 −490 −534 −355
Model-based Complex 8 31 41 16 24 32 −154 −149 −115 −49 −22 5 6 25 54 −128 −130 −55 −85 −79 −17
Tau Probabilistic 36 36 36 32 31 28 62 65 67 68 71 71 0 6 21 89 89 87 89 88 85
Symmetric −132 −69 −15 21 24 20 −4 3 6 −27 3 19 −16 −23 −36 6 18 32 9 22 31
Asymmetric 11 15 22 −7 6 12 43 45 45 55 65 70 1 7 22 78 80 81 76 79 80
Model-based Simple 15 20 24 8 10 6 −16 −15 −12 0 7 10 −19 −11 6 −10 −5 4 −15 −8 −3
Model-based Complex 22 27 37 42 42 38 12 14 16 35 39 40 −1 6 23 22 26 32 14 20 25
CONCOR Probabilistic 6 12 19 12 17 21 9 8 7 21 23 29 11 20 39 17 20 25 21 23 26
Reciprocated 7 12 19 10 16 21 8 7 6 22 24 29 4 14 32 17 20 25 22 24 27
Directed 5 11 18 13 17 21 6 5 4 20 22 28 11 20 39 17 20 25 21 23 26
Model-based Simple −13 −3 8 −9 2 11 −7 −6 −3 −4 2 11 −15 −3 21 −5 −1 6 3 7 14
Model-based Complex −10 0 11 −4 6 15 −7 −4 −2 −2 4 14 −14 −3 22 0 4 11 7 10 17