Table 2.
Comparison of annotations in different formats for causal molecular interactions. Data and metadata types, described in the MI2CAST guidelines, that can currently be annotated and stored in each format are listed with the ontologies and controlled vocabularies used. If there is no specification about ontologies and controlled vocabularies to use, the `+' sign is given, meaning that the format stores explicitly this type of data or metadata. Table inspired from [3].
| SIF | SBML qual | PSI-MITAB2.8 | GO-CAM | BEL | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Source entity | + | + | UniProtKB, RefSeq, ChEBI, EMBL/DDBJ/GenBank, Entrez Gene, Ensembl, EnsemblGenome | UniProtKB, Model Organism Database (MOD) gene identifier, Protein Ontology | HGNC, ChEBI, RefSeq, Entrez Gene, etc. |
| Interaction effect | + | + | PSI-MI | RO | BEL term: increases, decreases, etc. |
| Target entity | + | + | UniProtKB, RefSeq, ChEBI, EMBL/DDBJ/GenBank, EntrezGene, Ensembl, EnsemblGenome | UniProtKB, Model Organism Database (MOD) gene identifier, Protein Ontology | HGNC, ChEBI, RefSeq, etc. |
| Reference | PMID | PMID or MOD reference | PMID | ||
| Evidence | PSI-MI | ECO | ECO | ||
| Experimental setup | ECO | ||||
| Biological mechanism | PSI-MI | combination of biological activity and relationship | GO:BP | ||
| Biological activity | GO:MF | GO:MF | BEL term: act((prefix:id), ma(prefix:id)), etc. | ||
| Biological type | PSI-MI | BEL term: g(), r(), etc.See documentation. | |||
| Biological modification | PSI-MOD | Protein Ontology | BEL term: p(prefix:identifier, pmod(prefix:identifier)), etc. | ||
| Taxon entity | NCBI Taxonomy | NCBI Taxonomy | NCBI Taxonomy | ||
| Taxon interaction | NCBI Taxonomy | NCBI Taxonomy | |||
| Tissue type | Uberon (animals), Plant Ontology, Fungal Anatomy Ontology, MOD-specific ontologies | BRENDA Tissue Ontology | |||
| Cell type/Cell line | Cell Ontology, MOD-specific ontologies | BRENDA Tissue Ontology, Cell Ontology, Cell Type Ontology | |||
| Cellular compartment | + | GO:CC | GO:CC |