Skip to main content
. 2021 Apr 13;30(8):2171–2185. doi: 10.1007/s11136-021-02813-5

Table 1.

Assumed relationships between covariables of mental well-being when developing the DAG

Directed edges Potential bidirectionality* References
From To
Sex All variables except age and country of origin No [61, 66, 67]
Age All variables except sex and country of origin No
Country of origin Education No
Social class No
Social support No
Education Employment status Yes ( +) [68, 69]
Social class Yes (+ +)
BMI No
Smoking status No
Hours of sleep No
Mental disorder Yes ( +)
Social class Employment status Yes (+ +) [7072]
Social support No
BMI No
Smoking status No
Hours of sleep No
Physical disorder No
Mental disorder No
Employment status Economic difficulties Yes (+ +)
Social support Yes ( +)
BMI Yes ( +)
Smoking status Yes ( +)
Hours of sleep Yes ( +)
Mental disorder Yes ( +)
Economic difficulties Social support No
BMI No
Smoking status No
Hours of sleep No
Physical disorder Yes ( +)
Mental disorder Yes ( +)
Social support Mental disorder Yes (+ +) [14, 55, 73]
Perceived health Yes ( +)
Body mass index (BMI) Physical disorder Yes (+ + +) [61, 66]
Mental disorder Yes (+ + +)
Smoking status Physical disorder Yes (+ +)
Mental disorder Yes ( +)
Physical disorder Hours of sleep Yes ( +) [19, 60, 74, 75]
Mental disorder Yes (+ + +)
Lack of autonomy Yes ( +)
Perceived health Yes (+ +)
Mental disorder Hours of sleep Yes (+ +)
Lack of autonomy Yes ( +)
Perceived health Yes (+ +)
Lack of autonomy Perceived health Yes (+ +)

*Threatens to the face-validity (plausibility of the posited relationship) are assessed according to evidence, and “Yes” is given in the cases where reverse directionality is plausible. In such cases, the chance of reverse causality is qualitatively evaluated with (+ , +  + , +  + +), indicating less or more probability of bidirectionality, respectively