Table 3.
Agricultura (n = 100) |
Art and Architecture (n = 100) |
Exact and Natural Sciences (n = 100) |
Social Sciences (n = 100) |
Law (n = 100) |
Humanities (n = 100) |
Education (n = 100) |
Technology (n = 100) |
Health (n = 100) |
Administration and Commerce (n = 100) |
p-Value | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Awareness of animal welfare, n (%) | 84 (84.0) a,b | 71 (71.0) b | 80 (80.0) a,b | 79 (79.0) a,b | 77 (77.0) a,b | 69 (69.0) b | 76 (76.0) a,b | 67 (67.0) b | 70 (70.0) b | 92 (92.0) a | <0.001 1 |
Total scores of knowledge (0–7), mean (SD) 4 | 4.51 (1.37) a | 3.73 (1.28) b,c | 4.04 (1.18) a,b | 3.64 (1.05) b,c | 3.41 (1.24) c | 3.45 (1.38) c | 3.64 (1.00) b,c | 3.62 (1.10) b,c | 3.63 (1.33) b,c | 3.67 (1.22) b,c | <0.001 2 |
Self-reported level of knowledge | <0.001 3 | ||||||||||
High, n (%) | 36 (36.0) a,b | 62 (62.0) c | 29 (29.0) b | 57 (57.0) a,c | 64 (64.0) c | 49 (49.0) a,b,c | 64 (64.0) c | 51 (51.0) a,b,c | 53 (53.0) a,c | 46 (46.0) a,b,c | |
Medium, n (%) | 46 (46.0) a,b | 36 (36.0) a,b,c | 52 (52.0) b | 22 (22.0) c,d | 12 (12.0) d | 29 (29.0) a,c,d | 27 (27.0) a,c,d | 34 (34.0) a,b,c | 26 (26.0) a,c,d | 23 (23.0) c,d | |
Low/No, n (%) 5 | 18 (18.0) a,b | 2 (2.0) c | 19 (19.0) a,b | 21 (21.0) a,b | 23 (23.0) a,b | 21 (21.0) a,b | 9 (9.0) b,c | 13 (13.0) a,b,c | 21 (21.0) a,b | 31 (31.0) a | |
Not interested, n (%) | 0 (0) a | 0 (0) a | 0 (0) a | 0 (0) a | 1 (1) a | 1 (1) a | 0 (0) a | 2 (2) a | 0 (0) a | 0 (0) a | |
Source of information | <0.001 1 | ||||||||||
Educational institutions, n (%) | 43 (43.0) a | 6 (6.0) b | 36 (36.0) a | 3 (3.0) b | 5 (5.0) b | 10 (10.0) b | 3 (3.0) b | 3 (3.0) b | 8 (8.0) b | 2 (2.0) b | |
Social media channels, n (%) | 26 (26.0) a,b | 35 (35.0) a,b | 19 (19.0) b | 24 (24.0) a,b | 38 (38.0) a,b | 31 (31.0) a,b | 44 (44.0) a | 44 (44.0) a | 38 (38.0) a,b | 35 (35.0) a,b | |
Friends and family, n (%) | 17 (17.0) a | 12 (12.0) a,b | 14 (14.0) a,b | 27 (27.0) b | 16 (16.0) a,b | 7 (7.0) a | 15 (15.0) a,b | 17 (17.0) a,b | 19 (19.0) a,b | 9 (9.0) a | |
Internet (e.g., websites), n (%) | 10 (10.0) a | 42 (42.0) b | 19 (19.0) a,c | 21 (21.0) a,b,c | 21 (21.0) a,b,c | 33 (33.0) b,c | 18 (18.0) a,c | 19 (19.0) a,c | 11 (11.0) a | 14 (14.0) a,c | |
Mass media (e.g., radio, television, cinema), n (%) | 3 (3.0) a | 4 (4.0) a | 4 (4.0) a | 5 (5.0) a | 11 (11.0) a | 3 (3.0) a | 13 (13.0) a | 7 (7.0) a | 6 (6.0) a | 9 (9.0) a | |
None, I’ve never heard about animal welfare, n (%) | 1 (1.0) a | 1 (1.0) a | 8 (8.0) a,b | 20 (20.0) b,c | 9 (9.0) a,b | 16 (16.0) b,c | 7 (7.0) a,b | 10 (10.0) a,b | 18 (18.0) b,c | 31 (31.0) c | |
Understanding of animal welfare | <0.001 3 | ||||||||||
Mental and physical state, n (%) | 62 (62.0) a,b,c | 46 (46.0) c,d,e | 60 (60.0) a,b,c,d,e | 76 (76.0) b | 52 (52.0) a,c,d,e | 37 (37.0) e | 56 (56.0) a,b,c,d,e | 61 (61.0) a,b,c,d | 67 (67.0) a,b,c | 38 (38.0) d,e | |
Appropriate policies and legislation, n (%) | 34 (34.0) a,b,c,d,e | 43 (43.0) d,e,f,g,h | 40 (40.0) c,e,f,g,h | 17 (17.0) b | 47 (47.0) a,c,d,e,f,g,h | 59 (59.0) g,h | 36 (36.0) a,b,c,d,e,h | 37 (37.0) a,b,c,d,e,f,g,h | 31 (31.0) a,b,c,d,e | 60 (60.0) f,g | |
Avoid use of animals, n (%) | 4 (4.0) a,b | 11 (11.0) b | 0 (0.0) a | 7 (7.0) a,b | 1 (1.0) | 4 (4.0) a,b | 8 (8.0) a,b | 2 (2.0) a,b | 2 (2.0) a,b | 2 (2.0) a,b | |
Dairy cows feel more comfortable when walking on: | 0.003 3 | ||||||||||
Smooth cement, n (%) | 6 (6.0) a | 6 (6.0) a | 3 (3.0) a | 1 (1.0) a | 3 (3.0) a | 0 (0.0) a | 1 (1.0) a | 3 (3.0) a | 0 (0.0) a | 2 (2.0) a | |
Soil, n (%) | 81 (81.0) a | 87 (87.0) a | 83 (83.0) a | 89 (89.0) a | 84 (84.0) a | 82 (82.0) a | 92 (92.0) a | 90 (90.0) a | 80 (80.0) a | 78 (78.0) a | |
I don’t know, n (%) | 13 (13.0) a | 7 (7.0) a | 14 (14.0) a | 10 (10.0) a | 13 (13.0) a | 18 (18.0) a | 7 (7.0) a | 7 (7.0) a | 20 (20.0) a | 20 (20.0) a | |
Interested in animal welfare course, n (%) | 73.0 (73.0) a,b | 55 (55.0) b | 94 (94.0) c | 92 (92.0) c | 93 (93.0) c | 91 (91.0) c | 86 (86.0) a,c | 93 (93.0) c | 88 (88.0) a,c | 82 (82.0) a,c | <0.001 1 |
1 Chi-square test for independence and posthoc test with Bonferroni corrections for multiple comparisons. Different superscript letters indicate a significant difference. 2 One-way ANOVA with Bonferroni corrections for multiple comparisons. Different superscript letters indicate a significant difference. 3 Fisher’s exact test and posthoc test with Bonferroni corrections for multiple comparisons. Different superscript letters indicate a significant difference. 4 Total scores of knowledge are derived from the sum of response of the following variables: awareness of five freedoms (Yes = 1), awareness of Law on protection of animals in Chile (Yes = 1), animals have emotions (Yes = 1), animals have personality types (Yes = 1), anaesthetics is used in castration (Yes = 1), calf separated from mother after birth (Yes = 1), and dehorning is done with ease of handling (Yes = 1). 5 ‘Low/no’ is a combined category consisting of responses to ‘Low knowledge’ and ‘No knowledge’.