Skip to main content
. 2021 Jul 20;9:e11713. doi: 10.7717/peerj.11713

Table 2. Summary of the present study and progress made since the Tong, Sainsbury & Craig (2008) review.

Review Number of studies Experimental design Setting Treatment in focus Intervention type Tools and approaches Content Limitations Effectiveness Suggestions for future interventions
Tong, Sainsbury & Craig (2008) 3 Only non-RCTs found Spain and India HD, PD and kidney transplant Educational Booklets and oral and written
information
HD and PD: knowledge about the treatment.
Kidney Transplant: diet, immunosuppressive medication, secondary effects, protecting the graft, monitoring side-effects and importance of self-care.
Few studies found, only educational interventions and only non-RCT studies included. Effective results. But insufficient evidence to confirm the benefit
of the interventions and make recommendations.
Focus on participatory action research, using internet-based information, online
support groups, psychological therapy and practical support.
This review 6 Only RCTs included Iran HD and PD* Educational group sessions CDs, booklets, lectures, group discussions, homework, question and answer time, relaxation techniques and role playing. HD treatment, caregiver’s self-care, and self-efficacy improvement. Insufficient evidence for PD patients, few studies found, only educational group sessions as intervention, all studies developed in the same country. Interventions based on group sessions are effective to improve the well-being of family caregivers of patients on HD. Multicomponent interventions focusing on both disease-related problems and caregivers’ personal demands, information and communication technologies (ICTs) and coping strategies.

Note:

*

None of the studies meeting our inclusion criteria have targeted caregivers of patients undergoing PD.