Table 2. Summary of the present study and progress made since the Tong, Sainsbury & Craig (2008) review.
Review | Number of studies | Experimental design | Setting | Treatment in focus | Intervention type | Tools and approaches | Content | Limitations | Effectiveness | Suggestions for future interventions |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Tong, Sainsbury & Craig (2008) | 3 | Only non-RCTs found | Spain and India | HD, PD and kidney transplant | Educational | Booklets and oral and written information |
HD and PD: knowledge about the treatment. Kidney Transplant: diet, immunosuppressive medication, secondary effects, protecting the graft, monitoring side-effects and importance of self-care. |
Few studies found, only educational interventions and only non-RCT studies included. | Effective results. But insufficient evidence to confirm the benefit of the interventions and make recommendations. |
Focus on participatory action research, using internet-based information, online support groups, psychological therapy and practical support. |
This review | 6 | Only RCTs included | Iran | HD and PD* | Educational group sessions | CDs, booklets, lectures, group discussions, homework, question and answer time, relaxation techniques and role playing. | HD treatment, caregiver’s self-care, and self-efficacy improvement. | Insufficient evidence for PD patients, few studies found, only educational group sessions as intervention, all studies developed in the same country. | Interventions based on group sessions are effective to improve the well-being of family caregivers of patients on HD. | Multicomponent interventions focusing on both disease-related problems and caregivers’ personal demands, information and communication technologies (ICTs) and coping strategies. |
Note:
None of the studies meeting our inclusion criteria have targeted caregivers of patients undergoing PD.