Table 3.
First Author, Year | Study Design | Institution and Country | Inclusion Criteria | Intervention | Parallel Treatments | Number of Subjects (M-F) Mean Age |
Duration of the Intervention | Primary Outcomes | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Nielsen FH, 2011 [30] | double-blind, placebo-controlled design. | University of North Dakota | postmenopausal women aged 51–80 y, BMI ≤ 32 kg/m2, BMD not more than 2·5 standard deviations below that for young adults | 600 mg calcium (Ca) supplement plus a 2 mg Cu (copper gluconate) and 12 mg Zn (zinc gluconate) supplement. |
supplement containing 600 mg Ca plus a maize starch placebo | 649 F | 2 years | How Cu and Zn intakes would reduce the risk for bone loss. | Cu supplementation apparently did not have an impact on whole-body bone contents, BMD. |
Strause L, 1994 [31] | double-blind, placebo-controlled trial. | San Diego greater Metropolitan area |
>50 y old and in good general health | (1) placebo Ca + active trace minerals, (2) active Ca + placebo trace minerals, (3) active Ca + active trace mineral: 1000 mg elemental calcium/d in the form of Ca citrate malate and active supplement contained 15.0 mg of Zn as sulfate salt, 2.5 mg of Cu, and 5.0 mg of manganese as gluconate salts. | placebo calcium + placebo trace minerals | 59 F 66 ± 7 y |
2 years | Impact of supplementary Ca with and without the addition of a combination trace elements on spinal bone loss. |
Supplementation with 1000 mg of Ca, 15 mg of Zn, 5 mg of manganese, and 2.5 mg of Cu maintained spinal bone density and differed significantly from a placebo group that lost bone density. |
Eaton-Evans 2003 [32] | random and double-blind study | Royal Victoria Hospital, north Belfast | healthy women, aged 45–56 years | 3 mg Cu as amino acid chelate | placebo | 73 F Cu group: 49.97± 3.1 Placebo group: 50.8 ± 3.5 |
2 years | Effects of Cu supplementation over 2 years on vertebral trabecular bone mineral density (VTBMD). | Cu supplementation appeared to have reduced the loss of VTBMD in these middle-aged women over a 2-year period. |
Baker A 1999 [33] | longitudinal intervention trial | Institute of Food Research, Norwich, UK | Subjects without any history of bone or articular disease, and with no intake of medicine that could affect bone or cartilage metabolism | Medium (1.6 mg/d), low (0.7 mg/d) and high (6.0 mg/d) intakes of Cu, in that order. A 7 d rotating low Cu menu was formulated and analysed for Cu content. This low Cu diet (0.7 mg/d) was fed throughout the three dietary periods and was supplemented to the appropriate level of Cu (as a CuSO4 solution dissolved in de-mineralised water taken with a meal) to achieve the medium (1.6 mg/d) and high (6.0 mg/d) Cu intakes. |
////////// | 11 M 30.9 y |
8-week dietary periods with a minimum of 4-week washout periods. | Effects of changing from a medium (1.6 mg Cu/d) to a low (0.7 mg Cu/d) or a high (6.0 mg/d) Cu intake on biochemical indices of bone turnover in healthy adult males. | Biomarkers of bone resorption were significantly increased when subjects were switched from the medium to the low Cu diet. |