Skip to main content
. 2021 Jul 14;12:664385. doi: 10.3389/fmicb.2021.664385

TABLE 1.

Comprehensive resistance ranking of the 80 alfalfa varieties to Fom and Rs under either single or co-infection based on the membership function value (Dv).

Variety no. Foma
 Rsb
 Fom:Rsc
 Variety no. Foma
 Rsb
 Fom:Rsc
Dv Rank Dv Rank Dv Rank Dv Rank Dv Rank Dv Rank
Mvv1 0.602 44 0.460 21 0.051 75 Msv41 0.582 48 0.493 18 0.067 74
Msv2 0.500 61 0.660 9 0.000 77 Msv42 0.479 63 0.646 10 0.000 78
Mvv3 0.623 38 0.478 20 0.244 48 Msv43 0.742 17 0.174 62 0.198 55
Msv4 0.158 79 0.274 52 0.399 27 Msv44 0.445 65 0.558 13 0.045 76
Msv5 0.390 72 0.525 14 0.299 37 Msv45 0.412 70 0.750 5 0.000 79
Msv6 0.601 45 0.103 71 0.364 32 Msv46 0.508 60 0.404 29 0.170 60
Msv7 0.563 53 0.747 6 0.141 63 Msv47 0.692 27 0.415 26 0.279 42
Msv8 0.436 66 0.761 4 0.393 29 Msv48 0.519 58 0.310 47 0.252 47
Msv9 0.693 26 0.113 68 0.211 53 Msv49 0.774 14 0.212 57 0.000 80
Msv10 0.579 49 0.631 11 0.187 57 Msv50 0.546 57 0.161 65 0.290 40
Msv11 0.389 73 0.075 78 0.275 43 Msv51 0.485 62 0.150 67 0.510 12
Msv12 0.432 67 0.168 64 0.324 35 Msv52 0.559 54 0.499 16 0.138 66
Msv13 0.594 46 0.565 12 0.494 15 Msv53 0.381 74 0.371 37 0.113 69
Msv14 0.574 51 0.315 46 0.291 39 Msv54 0.621 39 0.766 3 0.237 50
Msv15 0.317 76 0.380 35 0.392 30 Msv55 0.638 33 0.686 8 0.427 23
Msv16 0.214 78 0.359 38 0.551 8 Msv56 0.719 21 0.402 30 0.342 33
Mvv17 0.252 77 0.401 31 0.497 14 Msv57 0.636 34 0.352 40 0.258 46
Mvv18 0.621 40 0.324 44 0.692 4 Msv58 0.564 52 0.375 36 0.172 58
Msv19 0.629 37 0.339 42 0.897 1 Msv59 0.736 19 0.169 63 0.136 67
Msv20 0.688 28 0.197 59 0.426 24 Msv60 0.968 1 0.325 43 0.241 49
Msv21 0.721 20 0.416 25 0.481 17 Msv61 0.799 12 0.310 49 0.170 59
Msv22 0.365 75 0.396 32 0.643 5 Msv62 0.871 5 0.515 15 0.473 18
Msv23 0.516 59 0.310 48 0.728 2 Msv63 0.831 9 0.409 28 0.109 71
Msv24 0.632 36 0.089 75 0.550 9 Msv64 0.647 32 0.410 27 0.521 10
Msv25 0.553 56 0.491 19 0.714 3 Msv65 0.609 43 0.322 45 0.403 25
Msv26 0.559 55 0.211 58 0.159 61 Msv66 0.842 7 0.288 51 0.399 26
Msv27 0.125 80 0.294 50 0.299 38 Msv67 0.701 24 0.000 79 0.129 68
Msv28 0.683 29 0.359 39 0.451 20 Msv68 0.822 10 0.236 53 0.217 52
Msv29 0.740 18 0.103 72 0.140 64 Msv69 0.855 6 0.083 77 0.396 28
Msv30 0.633 35 0.344 41 0.626 6 Msv70 0.874 4 0.102 73 0.334 34
Msv31 0.818 11 0.221 55 0.431 22 Msv71 0.951 2 0.224 54 0.091 73
Msv32 0.698 25 0.437 22 0.092 72 Msv72 0.902 3 0.112 69 0.285 41
Mvv33 0.429 68 0.103 70 0.195 56 Msv73 0.784 13 0.394 34 0.144 62
Msv34 0.576 50 0.721 7 0.518 11 Msv74 0.840 8 0.396 33 0.259 45
Msv35 0.611 41 0.773 1 0.211 54 Msv75 0.680 30 0.157 66 0.139 65
Msv36 0.751 15 0.090 74 0.382 31 Msv76 0.610 42 0.215 56 0.112 70
Msv37 0.715 22 0.425 24 0.319 36 Msv77 0.748 16 0.191 61 0.507 13
Msv38 0.714 23 0.497 17 0.458 19 Msv78 0.587 47 0.193 60 0.222 51
Msv39 0.410 71 0.431 23 0.591 7 Msv79 0.453 64 0.088 76 0.272 44
Msv40 0.419 69 0.770 2 0.448 21 Msv80 0.659 31 0.000 80 0.489 16

A larger Dv value indicates that the resistance of the variety is higher while a smaller value indicates that the resistance is lower. The varieties ranked in the top 10 (in bold) were considered as the most resistant varieties under each pathogen treatment. aFom, single infection by Fom. bRs, single infection by Rs. cFom:Rs, co-infection by Fom and Rs.