TABLE 3.
Testing protocol.
| Step 1 | Interview of the participants covering: Demographic information (age, nationality, profession), preferred mail user agent, and previous knowledge about cryptography and e-mail encryption | |
| Step 2 (if needed) | Installation of mail user agent and configuration of mail access through IMAP with supervisor help | |
| Step 3 | Participants are asked to send an encrypted and signed e-mail to the supervisor using one of the following encryption technologies. The instructions were adapted according idiosyncrasies of the tools employed by the user as shown below | |
| PGP | ||
| Instructions | For FlowCrypt: no further information | |
| For Thunderbird: install Enigmail plugin, activate setting “enforce PGP and S/MIME” | ||
| For Outlook: install gp4o plugin | ||
| For Android: install Maildroid (mail reader) and CryptoPlugin (key administration) | ||
| Goal | To send encrypted and signed e-mail + compare key fingerprints | |
| S/MIME | ||
| Instructions | For all: Obtain a certificate from: https://extrassl.actalis.it/portal/uapub/free-mail?lang=en | |
| For Thunderbird: no further information | ||
| For Outlook: go to “trust center settings” for importing the certificate | ||
| For Android: install Maildroid (mail reader) and CryptoPlugin (certificate administration) | ||
| For Apple-mail: no specific recommendation | ||
| Goal | To send encrypted and signed e-mail | |
| pEp | ||
| Instructions | For Thunderbird: active “enforce pretty easy privacy” setting | |
| For Android: install pEp official Android app | ||
| Goal | To send secure e-mail + execute handshake | |
The bold values to distinguish the names of the different mail user agent (MUA).