Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2022 Aug 1.
Published in final edited form as: Obesity (Silver Spring). 2021 Jul 5;29(8):1259–1271. doi: 10.1002/oby.23185

Table 2:

Main Findings regarding BE/LOC and Weight Loss Outcomes (WLO) for all 29 studies

Study Intervention Type Duration(s) measured Change in weight from baseline1 (↑,↓,=) Relationship between WLO and baseline BE/LOC1 (↑,↓,,=, or N/A)* Relationship b/w WLO & change in BE/LOC1 (↑,↓,,=, or N/A)** Change in BE/LOC from baseline1 (↑,↓,=, or N/A)
Bishop-Gilyard et al. 2011 (61) Pharmacotherapy + behavioral 6 month F/U = =
12 month F/U = =
Goldschmidt et al. 2018 (33) Bariatric Surgery 6-month F/U = =
1-year F/U =
2-year F/U =
3-year F/U =
Jarvholm et al. 2020 (26) Bariatric Surgery 5-year F/U = BE: ↓
LOC: =
Jarvholm et al. 2018 (53) Bariatric Surgery 1-year F/U N/A N/A
2-year F/U =
Mackey et al. 2018 (44) Bariatric Surgery 12-month F/U N/A N/A
Sysko et al. 2014 (49) Bariatric Surgery 12-month F/U N/A N/A
Hunsaker et al. 2018 (39) Bariatric Surgery 24-month F/U N/A N/A N/A
Jones et al. 2008 (40) Online CBT for obesity EOT N/A = ↓OBEs; ↓ SBEs; = OOEs
5-month F/U N/A = ↓OBEs; ↓ SBEs; = OOEs
Goossens et al. 2011 (47) Inpatient behavioral 6 year F/U = N/A N/A ↓SBE; = OBE
Goossens et al. 2009 (43) Inpatient behavioral 1 month of Tx = N/A N/A
4 months of Tx = N/A N/A
End of Tx (EOT) =3 N/A N/A
Braet et al. 2004 (46) Inpatient behavioral EOT = N/A
14-month F/U = N/A
Braet et al. 2006 (75) Inpatient behavioral EOT N/A N/A
2-year F/U N/A N/A
Braet et al. 2009 (22) Inpatient behavioral EOT N/A N/A N/A
1-year F/U N/A N/A N/A
2-year F/U N/A N/A N/A
Van Vlierberghe et al. 2009 (48) Inpatient behavioral EOT N/A N/A
Balantekin et al. 2017 (76) Behavioral therapy EOT N/A N/A =
Teder et al. 2013 (34) Behavioral therapy EOT N/A2 N/A =
1-year F/U N/A2 N/A N/A N/A
Wildes et al. 2010 (51) Behavioral therapy EOT N/A N/A
6-month F/U (not sig) N/A N/A
12-month F/U (not sig) N/A N/A
Levine et al. 2006 (35) Behavioral therapy 8-month F/U N/A2 =3 N/A N/A
Albayrak et al. 2019 (36) Behavioral therapy EOT (not sig) N/A N/A
Tanofsky-Kraff et al. 2014 (45) Behavioral therapy EOT z-BMI: ↓
Adj-BMI: ↓
BMI: =
N/A = LOC: ↓
OBE: ↓
6-month F/U z-BMI: ↓
Adj-BMI: ↓
BMI: =
N/A = LOC: ↓
OBE: ↓ (IPT); ↓ (control)
12-month F/U z-BMI: ↓
Adj-BMI: ↓
BMI: =
N/A = LOC: ↓
OBE: ↓
Tanofsky-Kraff et al. 2017 (41) Behavioral therapy 3-year F/U = =
Antunes et al. 2009 (50) Behavioral therapy EOT
Carnier et al. 2010 (77) Behavioral therapy EOT N/A N/A
Carnier et al. 2008 (32) Behavioral therapy EOT N/A N/A
Damaso et al. 2013 (42) Behavioral therapy EOT N/A N/A
Eichen et al. 2019 (78) Behavioral therapy EOT N/A N/A
6-month F/U N/A N/A N/A
18-month F/U N/A N/A
Shomaker et al. 2017 (37) Behavioral therapy EOT = N/A N/A
6-month F/U = N/A N/A
1-year F/U = N/A N/A
Tanofsky-Kraff et al. 2010 (31) Behavioral therapy 1-year F/U N/A N/A
Germann et al. 2006 (38) Behavioral therapy 11-month F/U = = N/A N/A
*

↑ = higher baseline BE associated with more weight loss and ↓ = higher baseline BE associated with less weight loss

**

where ↑ = greater increase in BE associated with more weight loss and ↓ = greater decrease in BE associated with more weight loss

1

: ↑ and ↓ each denote statistical significance in this association

2

: Although authors reported successful weight loss outcomes at these time points, they did not directly provide this data or state if it was statistically significant

3

: No significant association was found, but there notably was a significant negative correlation between baseline SBE and program completion