Skip to main content
. 2021 Aug 2;16(8):e0254894. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0254894

Table 3. Additional performance metrics based on a 30% validation dataset for TIMI risk score and ML models with and without feature selection.

PPV NPV Sensitivity Specificity Accuracy (Cl 95%) Mcnemar’s test (p-value)
In-hospital
Classifier
RF 0.380 0.963 0.347 0.968 0.935 (0.923,0.946) <0.0001
RFvarImp-SBE-RF 0.447 0.963 0.337 0.977 0.942 (0.931,0.952) <0.0001
RFE-RF 0.350 0.963 0.347 0.964 0.931 (0.918,0.942) <0.0001
SVM 0.242 0.976 0.614 0.892 0.877 (0.861, 0.891) <0.0001
SVMvarImp-SBE-SVM 0.219 0.980 0.693 0.861 0.852 (0.835,0.868) <0.0001
RFE-SVM 0.202 0.982 0.723 0.838 0.832 (0.815, 0.849) <0.0001
LR 0.211 0.981 0.713 0.850 0.842 (0.825,0.858) <0.0001
LRstepwise—SBE-LR 0.211 0.984 0.752 0.841 0.836 (0.814,0.852) <0.0001
RFE- LR 0.185 0.978 0.663 0.834 0.825 (0.807,0.842) <0.0001
TIMI 0.180 0.976 0.644 0.834 0.824 (0.806, 0.841) <0.0001
30 days
Classifier
RF 0.389 0.946 0.373 0.949 0.903 (0.882,0.921) <0.0001
RFvarImp-SBE-RF 0.341 0.948 0.413 0.930 0.889 (0.867,0.909) <0.0001
RFE-RF 0.414 0.947 0.387 0.952 0.907 (0.887,0.925) <0.0001
SVM 0.258 0.972 0.733 0.817 0.810 (0.784,0.835) <0.0001
SVMvarImp-SBE-SVM 0.258 0.983 0.840 0.790 0.794 (0.767,0.820) <0.0001
RFE-SVM 0.261 0.980 0.813 0.800 0.801 (0.774,0.829) <0.0001
LR 0.248 0.973 0.747 0.803 0.799 (0.771,0.824) <0.0001
LRstepwise—SBE-LR 0.281 0.974 0.747 0.834 0.827 (0.802,0.851) <0.0001
RFE- LR 0.248 0.971 0.720 0.810 0.803 (0.776,0.828) <0.0001
TIMI 0.245 0.962 0.627 0.832 0.816 (0.789, 0.840) <0.0001
1-year
Classifier
RF 0.410 0.909 0.373 0.949 0.827 (0.801,0.852) <0.0001
RFvarImp-SBE-RF 0.436 0.909 0.460 0.901 0.838 (0.811,0.861) <0.0001
RFE-RF 0.425 0.913 0.492 0.889 0.8318 (0.805,0.856) <0.0001
SVM 0.382 0.950 0.746 0.798 0.7909 (0.763,0.817) <0.0001
SVMvarImp-SBE-SVM 0.357 0.950 0.754 0.773 0.771 (0.741,0.798) <0.0001
RFE-SVM 0.387 0.953 0.762 0.798 0.793 (0.765,0.820) <0.0001
LR 0.329 0.924 0.611 0.792 0.766 (0.737,0.794) <0.0001
LRstepwise—SBE-LR 0.372 0.935 0.659 0.814 0.792 (0.764,0.818) <0.0001
RFE- LR 0.344 0.926 0.619 0.802 0.776 (0.747,0.803) <0.0001
TIMI 0.332 0.907 0.484 0.837 0.786 (0.758, 0.813) <0.0001