Instrument-based methods of transfection |
Microinjection |
Any in vitro cell |
Close to 100%; dependant on injected material |
>$1,000 Grows with process automatization level |
Any (DNA, RNA, spermatozoids, proteins, peptides, drugs.) |
High efficiency; Precise dosing of injected material; selective delivery; low cytotoxicity |
Maximum of 100–200 cells transfected in single treatment; Laborious process |
Biolistic transfection |
In vitro and in vivo; e.g., primary leukocytes–lymphocytes, macrophages, and splenocytes |
High |
High cost of necessary equipment; low cost of utilization |
DNA RNA |
Possible transfection through physical barriers like epidermidis; possible cotransfection of more than one DNAs in a single use; time efficient |
High cost of gene gun; Tissue damage when transfecting small cells |
Electroporation |
In vitro and in vivo; See above |
Low to moderate |
>$1,000 |
Plasmids; Oligonucleotides; mRNA; siRNA |
High efficiency; Proven efficiency for use on tissues in vivo
|
High toxicity |
Optical transfection |
In vitro cells |
Comparable to other physical methods |
High cost of necessary equipment |
DNA, RNA and larger objects |
Ability to transfect single cells; Possible transfection with large objects |
Diverse efficiency depending on technique |
Virus-based methods of transfection |
Adenoviruses |
Dividing and non-dividing cells |
Expression levels are very high at the beginning, but they quickly weaken in a matter of weeks |
$500–$1,000 |
DNA |
No integration with the host cell chromosome; Easy viruses’ amplification; vectors stability in prolonged storage |
Cannot induce prolonged expression; tendency to inducing a strong host immune response; Use possible only in laboratories with Biosafety Level 2 or higher |
Adeno-associated virus |
See above |
See above |
$500–$1,000 |
DNA |
No integration with host genome; weaker immunogenicity than adenoviruses |
Cannot induce prolonged expression |
Retroviruses |
Dividing and non-dividing cells |
Stable expression |
≈$1,000 |
RNA |
Stable transfected gene expression |
Possible retroviral genotoxicity |
Chemical transfection methods |
Calcium phosphate |
In vitro cells |
High |
<1,000$ |
DNA |
Inexpensive; high efficiency; applicable to wide range of cell types; allow to transient and stable transfection |
transfection efficiency is influenced by small changes of pH; consistency of precipitate |
Cationic lipids |
In vitro and in vivo
|
High |
<1,000$ |
DNA, RNA, siRNA, and proteins |
high efficiency; easy procedure; DNA, RNA and proteins may be introduced; allow to transient and stable transfection |
does not work with certain cell types |
DEAE-Dextran |
In vitro cells |
Moderate |
<1,000$ |
DNA and RNA |
Inexpensive; quick and easy method; wide range of cell types may be transfected; DNA and RNA may be introduced |
toxicity of DEAE-dextran high concentrations; only for transient transfection; proteins may not be introduced |
Magnetic beads |
In vitro cells |
High |
<1,000$ |
DNA and RNA |
simple method; high efficiency; DNA and RNA may be introduced |
only adherent cells may be transfected; cells in suspension must be immobilized |