Skip to main content
. 2021 Aug 3;38(Suppl 5):4387–4413. doi: 10.1007/s00366-021-01442-3

Table 7.

Optimization results for TRB design

Bearing number Rank Optimization method Optimum parameters Cost
Dm
(mm)
Dr
(mm)
le Z KDmin KDmax ε e β Cd
(N)
30207 1 EHHO 53.8069 9.1539 13.0691 18 0.356722 0.5213 0.4974 0.0514 0.9142 62,084.4
2 HHO 53.3063 9.6201 12.5616 17 0.361756 0.5476 0.4572 0.0101 0.8666 60,868.1
4 WOA 56.1596 6.9678 11.9946 24 0.300363 0.5006 0.4860 0.0339 0.8010 53,606.8
3 SCA 53.3906 9.5264 12.2235 17 0.36438 0.5359 0.4689 0.0188 0.8322 58,961.8
5 GA [2] 56.117 6.89 13.0 23 0.3305 0.5027 0.4666 0.0699 0.9417 54,510
30306 1 EHHO 51.5299 10.4971 14.3968 15 0.371458 0.5983 0.4822 0.0393 0.9432 68,439.6
2 HHO 52.2482 9.8508 14.0246 16 0.325396 0.6 0.5 0.0697 0.9076 65,748
4 WOA 52.1721 10.0208 13.2669 15 0.378517 0.6 0.5 0.0256 0.95 61,105.3
3 SCA 51.8496 10.3815 13.2908 15 0.330331 0.5463 0.4084 0.0605 0.9085 63,557.4
5 GA [2] 54.221 7.74 14.0 20 0.3451 0.5597 0.4999 0.0699 0.9498 59,350
32207 1 EHHO 53.2245 9.0549 17.5122 18 0.397334 0.5969 0.4998 0.0556 0.9463 77,162.2
4 HHO 55.4309 6.9632 16.9182 24 0.300001 0.5000 0.4630 0.0687 0.8663 70,135.9
2 WOA 53.0241 9.5731 16.2293 17 0.315465 0.5536 0.4555 0.0548 0.8974 73,982.6
3 SCA 53.2925 9.1628 16.7300 17 0.311826 0.5757 0.4844 0.0666 0.95 72,252
5 GA [2] 54.381 7.99 16.0 20 0.3516 0.5968 0.4678 0.678 0.9204 69,810
30307 1 EHHO 58.0431 11.8241 16.0144 15 0.309913 0.5864 0.4378 0.07 0.95 84,483.3
5 HHO 60.1575 10.1419 13.8516 18 0.367968 0.5022 0.4115 0.0574 0.9387 73,329.2
3 WOA 60.4662 9.6153 14.6739 20 0.371041 0.5549 0.4623 0.0438 0.8433 75,411.3
2 SCA 56.9436 12.8484 15.2605 13 0.3776 0.6 0.4 0.0688 0.95 79,927.4
4 GA [2] 60.875 8.77 15.0 20 0.3545 0.5823 0.4853 0.0643 0.9043 74,940
32208 1 EHHO 59.7637 10.1674 17.5122 18 0.399854 0.5965 0.4987 0.0303 0.95 87,259.1
4 HHO 60.2563 9.6762 15.6860 20 0.30076 0.5012 0.4891 0.0693 0.8020 79,052.7
2 WOA 60.4622 9.7165 16.4699 19 0.4 0.6 0.5 0.0607 0.9498 82,458.4
3 SCA 59.5876 10.4600 16.1836 17 0.308451 0.6 0.4 0.0479 0.9116 81,068.9
5 GA [2] 60.800 9.06 15.0 20 0.3847 0.5988 0.4517 0.0390 0.8626 75,420

Bold values indicate the best results