Skip to main content
. 2021 Jun 6;8(15):2004595. doi: 10.1002/advs.202004595

Table 3.

Summary of key microfluidic intracellular delivery techniques covered in this review

Cargo type
Mechanism Method Delivery principle Cell type (primary cell) Fluorescence probe Functional nanomaterials/macromolecule Throughput (cell processing rate) Comments
Mechanoporation Fluid shear Shear force DU145,[ 45 ] NIE‐115,[ 46 ] rat primary neuron [ 46 ] Calcein,[ 45 ] FITC–dextran,[ 45 ] FITC–BSA[ 45 ] GFP pDNA[ 46 ] N/A
Vortex shedding Human T cell [ 48 ] N/A GFP mDNA[ 48 ] 107 cells min−1[ 48 ] Under commercialization by Indee Labs[ 48 ]
Spiral vortex HEK293,[ 49 ] ES2,[ 49 ] 3T3,[ 49 ] KU812,[ 49 ] HeLa,[ 49 ] HCT116,[ 49 ] MCF7,[ 49 ] HDFa,[ 49 ] K562,[ 35 , 49 ] MDA231[ 35 , 49 ] FITC–dextran[ 35 , 49 ] DNA nanotube,[ 49 ] DNA donut,[ 49 ] GFP mRNA,[ 35 ] GFP pDNA,[ 35 , 49 ] GNP,[ 35 ] DOX‐MSNs[ 35 ] 106 cells min−1[ 35 , 49 ] Clogging‐free operation;[ 35 , 49 ] under commercialization by MxT Biotech[ 35 ]
Constriction Cell squeezing HeLa,[ 53 , 54 , 56 ] murine ESC,[ 53 , 56 ] NuFFs,[ 53 ] murine dendritic cell,[ 53 ] murine macrophage,[ 53 ] murine B cell,[ 53 , 55 ] murine T cell,[ 53 ] human T cell,[ 57 ] Jurkat,[ 62 ] K562,[ 62 ] HEK293t[ 62 ] FL‐dextran,[ 53 , 55 , 56 , 57 , 62 ] FL‐protein[ 53 , 62 ] siRNA,[ 53 ] GFP pDNA,[ 56 ] CNT,[ 53 ] GNP,[ 53 ] Qdot,[ 54 ] antigen,[ 55 ] Cas9‐RNP[ 57 ] 106 cells min−1[ 53 , 54 , 56 , 57 ] Under commercialization by SQZ Biotech (in Phase I trial; NCT04084951)[ 53 ]
Deformation array HEK293t,[ 58 ] MCF7,[ 58 ] SU‐DHL‐1,[ 58 ] ES AB2.2,[ 58 ] PC‐3,[ 58 ] SUM159,[ 58 , 59 ] HeLa,[ 58 ] HL60,[ 59 ] SK‐BR‐3,[ 59 ] human T cell,[ 59 ] MDA231,[ 58 , 60 ] NIH 3T3,[ 61 ] human ASC [ 61 ] FITC–ssDNA,[ 58 ] FL‐dextran,[ 59 , 60 , 61 ] FITC–siRNA[ 59 , 60 ] siRNA,[ 58 , 60 ] GFP pDNA,[ 58 , 61 ] CRISPR pDNA,[ 58 ] Cas9 RNP[ 58 , 59 ] 105 cells min−1[ 61 ]
Volume exchange PC3,[ 33 ] PBMC,[ 33 ] K562,[ 33 , 34 ] HL60,[ 34 ] HEY,[ 34 ] HEK293,[ 34 ] OVCAR‐3[ 34 ] FITC–dextran,[ 33 , 34 ] RNA probe[ 33 ] GFP mRNA,[ 33 ] GFP pDNA,[ 33 ] nanobead[ 33 ] 106 cells min−1[ 34 ] Under commercialization by CellFE[ 33 ]
Poking Cell poking MDA231,[ 75 ] HSC,[ 75 ] NIH3T3,[ 76 ] HEK293,[ 76 ] MDCK,[ 76 ] HeLa,[ 76 ] HCT116[ 76 ] FL‐dextran,[ 75 , 76 ] Alexa488‐protein[ 76 ] RFP pDNA,[ 75 ] Cas9 RNP,[ 75 ] siRNA[ 76 ] 103 cells min−1,[ 75 ] 105 cells min−1[ 76 ]
Static poking Jurkat,[ 77 ] K562,[ 77 ] human T cell [ 77 ] PI dye[ 77 ] GFP pDNA[ 77 ] 104 cells per run[ 77 ] Under commercialization by Basilard Biotech[ 77 ]
Hydrodynamic cell stretching A2780cis,[ 78 ] ES2,[ 78 ] HEK293,[ 78 ] MDA231,[ 15 , 78 ] K562,[ 15 , 78 ] HEK293t,[ 15 ] 3T3,[ 15 ] DC 2.4,[ 15 ] HeLa,[ 15 ] human MSC,[ 15 ] human ADSC,[ 15 ] murine BMDC [ 15 ] FITC–dextran[ 15 , 78 ] DNA nanostructure,[ 78 ] CRISPR/Cas9,[ 78 ] siRNA,[ 15 , 78 ] GFP pDNA,[ 15 , 78 ] GFP mRNA,[ 15 ] Qdot,[ 15 ] nanobead[ 15 ] 106 cells min−1[ 15 , 78 ] Demonstrated 300 nm nanoparticle delivery;[ 15 ] under commercialization by MxT Biotech[ 15 ]
Microinjection Microinjection on chip HeLa,[ 84 , 90 ] zebrafish embryo,[ 83 ] Drosophila embryo[ 91 , 93 ] FL‐dextran,[ 84 , 90 ] methylene blue,[ 83 ] rhodamine B,[ 83 , 93 ] fluorescein,[ 91 ] NaN3 [ 93 ] siRNA[ 91 ] 60 cells min−1[ 84 ]
Probe tip injection C2C12,[ 186 ] NG108,[ 186 ] MCF7,[ 187 ] RAW 264.7,[ 187 ] RKO[ 187 ] FITC‐sodium salt,[ 186 ] CellTracker green[ 186 ] FITC‐nanodiamond[ 187 ] N/A Commercialized by Cytosurge AG[ 186 ]
Acoustic cavitation Ultrasonic wave H9C2[ 111 ] FITC‐dextran[ 111 ] Pharmaceutical agents (doxorubicin, apigenin, and luteolin)[ 111 ] N/A No microbubble required[ 111 ]
Bubble oscillation HUVEC,[ 114 ] primary rat aortic‐smooth muscle cell [ 99 ] DOX‐liposome,[ 114 ] calcein[ 99 ] N/A N/A Vessels‐on‐a‐chip cytotoxic drug delivery[ 114 ]
Surface acoustic wave MCF7[ 115 ] PI dye[ 115 ] N/A N/A
Acoustic wave cell manipulation Jurkat,[ 117 ] MEF,[ 117 ] PBMC,[ 117 ] HSPC [ 117 ] Cy3‐labeled DNA[ 117 ] GFP pDNA[ 117 ] 105 cells min−1[ 117 ] Not requiring microbubble[ 117 ]
Laser cavitation Single bubble cavitation HL60,[ 118 ] myeloma cell[ 119 ] Trypan blue[ 118 , 119 ] N/A N/A
Microbubble array cavitation HeLa,[ 120 ] PB‐MDMs,[ 120 ] NHDFs,[ 120 ] RPTECs [ 120 ] FITC–dextran[ 120 ] Antibody,[ 120 ] enzyme,[ 120 ] bacteria,[ 120 ] nanobead[ 120 ] 105 cells min−1[ 120 ] Macromolecule delivery[ 120 ]
Electroporation Cell trapping‐based electroporation Microhole trapping ND‐1[ 149 , 150 ] YOYO‐1 dye[ 150 ] EGFP pDNA[ 150 ] N/A
Channel trapping HeLa,[ 151 , 152 , 153 ] C2C12,[ 155 ] human MSC [ 155 ] Trypan blue,[ 151 ] calcein,[ 151 , 152 , 153 ] FL‐dextran,[ 152 , 153 ] PI dye[ 155 ] EGFP‐ERK1 pDNA[ 155 ] N/A
Membrane sandwich electroporation NIH 3T3,[ 156 ] mouse ES [ 157 , 158 ] N/A GFP pDNA,[ 156 , 157 ] SEAP pDNA[ 156 , 157 , 158 ] 104 cells per run[ 157 ]
Nanochannel electroporation Single‐cell electroporation Jurkat,[ 163 ] K562,[ 163 ] mouse embryonic fibroblasts [ 163 ] PI dye,[ 163 ] Cy3‐ODN[ 163 ] GAPDH molecular beacon,[ 163 ] siRNA,[ 163 ] Qdot,[ 163 ] Cy3‐labeled GFP pDNA[ 163 ] N/A Faster delivery compared with bulk and microelectroporation[ 163 ]
Nanochannel array electroporation NK‐92,[ 166 ] H9C2,[ 166 , 167 ] MEF,[ 165 , 167 ] mouse cardiomyocyte,[ 165 ] MDA231,[ 168 ] CHO,[ 168 ] HT1080[ 168 ] PI dye,[ 166 , 167 , 168 ] FAM‐ODN,[ 167 ] Co2+,[ 168 ] Alexa488‐BSA[ 168 ] CAR/GFP pDNA,[ 166 ] GFP pDNA,[ 165 ] OSKM pDNA,[ 167 ] miRNA,[ 165 ] mCherry pDNA[ 168 ] 104 cells per cm2,[ 167 ] 106 cells per run[ 169 ] mRNA internalization into exosome[ 169 ]
Nanopore electroporation HeLa,[ 170 ] HEK293,[ 170 ] 3T3,[ 170 ] Jurkat[ 170 ] N/A mCherry mRNA,[ 170 ] GFP pDNA[ 170 ] 104 cells per run[ 170 ]
Nanoinjection Human MSC [ 171 ] RFP[ 171 ] GFP pDNA[ 171 ] N/A Under commercialization by Femtobiomed[ 171 ]
Nanostraw electroporation CHO,[ 174 ] HEK293t,[ 174 ] HEK293,[ 176 ] hiPSC‐CMs,[ 176 ] HSCs,[ 176 ] HFs,[ 176 ] mouse glia,[ 176 ] mouse neuron,[ 176 ] HSPCs [ 142 ] PI dye,[ 174 ] FL‐dextran,[ 142 ] FITC‐OGN[ 142 ] RFP pDNA,[ 174 ] mCherry mRNA,[ 176 ] GFP mRNA,[ 142 , 176 ] STIM1 protein,[ 176 ] Cas9 RNP,[ 176 ] siRNA[ 142 ] 105 cells per run[ 176 ] Under commercialization by NAVAN Technologies[ 174 ]
Nanochannel electroporation Nanofountain electroporation HeLa,[ 181 , 182 ] HT1080,[ 182 ] HEK293[ 183 ] FL‐dextran,[ 181 , 182 ] BSA[ 181 , 182 , 183 ] GAPDH‐molecular beacon,[ 181 , 182 ] GFP pDNA,[ 181 , 183 ] GFP knockdown CRISPR/Cas9[ 183 ] N/A
Flow‐through electroporation Flow‐through DC electroporation CHO,[ 189 , 190 , 191 , 196 ] K562[ 197 ] SYTOX dye,[ 189 , 190 ] PI dye[ 197 ] GFP pDNA,[ 190 , 191 , 197 ] Qdot[ 196 ] 105 cells min−1,[ 197 ] 106 cells min−1,[ 190 ] 107 cells min−1[ 191 ]
Flow‐through AC electroporation Huh‐7,[ 188 ] K562,[ 198 ] CT26.WT,[ 198 ] C3H10T1/2,[ 199 ] HeLa,[ 200 ] CHO,[ 193 ] HEK293a,[ 201 ] Neuro‐2a,[ 201 ] HUVEC,[ 201 ] HSF [ 201 ] PI dye,[ 198 ] FL‐dextran,[ 200 ] phallotoxin[ 200 ] β‐galactosidase pDNA,[ 188 ] GFP pDNA,[ 188 , 193 , 198 , 199 , 201 ] GFP siRNA[ 200 ] 103 cells min−1,[ 199 ] 104 cells min−1,[ 201 ] 106 cells min−1[ 198 ]
Flow electroporation with laminar flow Yeast cell,[ 202 ] HEK293a,[ 203 ] HEK293,[ 203 ] HeLa,[ 203 ] C2C12,[ 203 ] Neuro‐2a,[ 203 ] PC12,[ 203 ] human T cell [ 205 , 206 ] Fluorescein[ 202 ] siRNA,[ 203 ] GFP pDNA,[ 203 ] mCherry mRNA[ 205 , 206 ] 104 cells min−1,[ 202 ] 105 cells min−1,[ 203 , 205 ] 107 cells min−1[ 206 ] Electroporation assisted by acoustophoretic cell manipulation[ 205 ]
Flow electroporation with Dean/vortex flow CHO,[ 204 ] MDA231,[ 207 , 208 , 210 ] HEK293,[ 208 ] MCF7,[ 208 ] HeLa[ 208 ] YOYO‐1 dye,[ 204 ] PI dye,[ 208 , 210 ] FL‐protein[ 208 ] GFP pDNA,[ 204 , 210 ] RFP pDNA,[ 210 ] drug (gemcitabine, bleomycin, topotecan, and quercetin),[ 207 ] siRNA,[ 208 ] miRNA[ 208 ] 105 cells min−1[ 204 ] Cytotoxic drug delivery[ 207 ]
Droplet electroporation Flow‐through droplet electroporation Yeast cell,[ 212 ] CHO,[ 213 ] green microalgae (C. reinhardtii)[ 214 ] Fluorescein,[ 212 ] SYTOX green dye[ 213 ] GFP pDNA,[ 213 ] DNA fragment[ 214 ] 104 cells min−1[ 213 ] Delivery assisted by Dean vortices[ 214 ]
EWOD droplet electroporation E. coli [ 216 ] N/A Antibiotic resistance pDNA[ 216 ] N/A Transfection efficiency assessed using colony forming unit[ 216 ]