Mechanoporation |
Fluid shear |
Shear force |
DU145,[
45
] NIE‐115,[
46
]
rat primary neuron
[
46
]
|
Calcein,[
45
] FITC–dextran,[
45
] FITC–BSA[
45
]
|
GFP pDNA[
46
]
|
N/A |
– |
|
|
Vortex shedding |
Human T cell
[
48
]
|
N/A |
GFP mDNA[
48
]
|
107 cells min−1[
48
]
|
Under commercialization by Indee Labs[
48
]
|
|
|
Spiral vortex |
HEK293,[
49
] ES2,[
49
] 3T3,[
49
] KU812,[
49
] HeLa,[
49
] HCT116,[
49
] MCF7,[
49
] HDFa,[
49
] K562,[
35
,
49
] MDA231[
35
,
49
]
|
FITC–dextran[
35
,
49
]
|
DNA nanotube,[
49
] DNA donut,[
49
] GFP mRNA,[
35
] GFP pDNA,[
35
,
49
] GNP,[
35
] DOX‐MSNs[
35
]
|
106 cells min−1[
35
,
49
]
|
Clogging‐free operation;[
35
,
49
] under commercialization by MxT Biotech[
35
]
|
|
Constriction |
Cell squeezing |
HeLa,[
53
,
54
,
56
]
murine ESC,[
53
,
56
] NuFFs,[
53
]
murine dendritic cell,[
53
]
murine macrophage,[
53
]
murine B cell,[
53
,
55
]
murine T cell,[
53
]
human T cell,[
57
] Jurkat,[
62
] K562,[
62
] HEK293t[
62
]
|
FL‐dextran,[
53
,
55
,
56
,
57
,
62
] FL‐protein[
53
,
62
]
|
siRNA,[
53
] GFP pDNA,[
56
] CNT,[
53
] GNP,[
53
] Qdot,[
54
] antigen,[
55
] Cas9‐RNP[
57
]
|
106 cells min−1[
53
,
54
,
56
,
57
]
|
Under commercialization by SQZ Biotech (in Phase I trial; NCT04084951)[
53
]
|
|
|
Deformation array |
HEK293t,[
58
] MCF7,[
58
] SU‐DHL‐1,[
58
] ES AB2.2,[
58
] PC‐3,[
58
] SUM159,[
58
,
59
] HeLa,[
58
] HL60,[
59
] SK‐BR‐3,[
59
]
human T cell,[
59
] MDA231,[
58
,
60
] NIH 3T3,[
61
]
human ASC
[
61
]
|
FITC–ssDNA,[
58
] FL‐dextran,[
59
,
60
,
61
] FITC–siRNA[
59
,
60
]
|
siRNA,[
58
,
60
] GFP pDNA,[
58
,
61
] CRISPR pDNA,[
58
] Cas9 RNP[
58
,
59
]
|
105 cells min−1[
61
]
|
– |
|
|
Volume exchange |
PC3,[
33
]
PBMC,[
33
] K562,[
33
,
34
] HL60,[
34
] HEY,[
34
] HEK293,[
34
] OVCAR‐3[
34
]
|
FITC–dextran,[
33
,
34
] RNA probe[
33
]
|
GFP mRNA,[
33
] GFP pDNA,[
33
] nanobead[
33
]
|
106 cells min−1[
34
]
|
Under commercialization by CellFE[
33
]
|
|
Poking |
Cell poking |
MDA231,[
75
]
HSC,[
75
] NIH3T3,[
76
] HEK293,[
76
] MDCK,[
76
] HeLa,[
76
] HCT116[
76
]
|
FL‐dextran,[
75
,
76
] Alexa488‐protein[
76
]
|
RFP pDNA,[
75
] Cas9 RNP,[
75
] siRNA[
76
]
|
103 cells min−1,[
75
] 105 cells min−1[
76
]
|
– |
|
|
Static poking |
Jurkat,[
77
] K562,[
77
]
human T cell
[
77
]
|
PI dye[
77
]
|
GFP pDNA[
77
]
|
104 cells per run[
77
]
|
Under commercialization by Basilard Biotech[
77
]
|
|
|
Hydrodynamic cell stretching |
A2780cis,[
78
] ES2,[
78
] HEK293,[
78
] MDA231,[
15
,
78
] K562,[
15
,
78
] HEK293t,[
15
] 3T3,[
15
] DC 2.4,[
15
] HeLa,[
15
]
human MSC,[
15
]
human ADSC,[
15
]
murine BMDC
[
15
]
|
FITC–dextran[
15
,
78
]
|
DNA nanostructure,[
78
] CRISPR/Cas9,[
78
] siRNA,[
15
,
78
] GFP pDNA,[
15
,
78
] GFP mRNA,[
15
] Qdot,[
15
] nanobead[
15
]
|
106 cells min−1[
15
,
78
]
|
Demonstrated 300 nm nanoparticle delivery;[
15
] under commercialization by MxT Biotech[
15
]
|
|
Microinjection |
Microinjection on chip |
HeLa,[
84
,
90
] zebrafish embryo,[
83
]
Drosophila embryo[
91
,
93
]
|
FL‐dextran,[
84
,
90
] methylene blue,[
83
] rhodamine B,[
83
,
93
] fluorescein,[
91
] NaN3
[
93
]
|
siRNA[
91
]
|
60 cells min−1[
84
]
|
– |
|
|
Probe tip injection |
C2C12,[
186
] NG108,[
186
] MCF7,[
187
] RAW 264.7,[
187
] RKO[
187
]
|
FITC‐sodium salt,[
186
] CellTracker green[
186
]
|
FITC‐nanodiamond[
187
]
|
N/A |
Commercialized by Cytosurge AG[
186
]
|
|
Acoustic cavitation |
Ultrasonic wave |
H9C2[
111
]
|
FITC‐dextran[
111
]
|
Pharmaceutical agents (doxorubicin, apigenin, and luteolin)[
111
]
|
N/A |
No microbubble required[
111
]
|
|
|
Bubble oscillation |
HUVEC,[
114
]
primary rat aortic‐smooth muscle cell
[
99
]
|
DOX‐liposome,[
114
] calcein[
99
]
|
N/A |
N/A |
Vessels‐on‐a‐chip cytotoxic drug delivery[
114
]
|
|
|
Surface acoustic wave |
MCF7[
115
]
|
PI dye[
115
]
|
N/A |
N/A |
– |
|
|
Acoustic wave cell manipulation |
Jurkat,[
117
] MEF,[
117
]
PBMC,[
117
]
HSPC
[
117
]
|
Cy3‐labeled DNA[
117
]
|
GFP pDNA[
117
]
|
105 cells min−1[
117
]
|
Not requiring microbubble[
117
]
|
|
Laser cavitation |
Single bubble cavitation |
HL60,[
118
] myeloma cell[
119
]
|
Trypan blue[
118
,
119
]
|
N/A |
N/A |
– |
|
|
Microbubble array cavitation |
HeLa,[
120
]
PB‐MDMs,[
120
]
NHDFs,[
120
]
RPTECs
[
120
]
|
FITC–dextran[
120
]
|
Antibody,[
120
] enzyme,[
120
] bacteria,[
120
] nanobead[
120
]
|
105 cells min−1[
120
]
|
Macromolecule delivery[
120
]
|
Electroporation |
Cell trapping‐based electroporation |
Microhole trapping |
ND‐1[
149
,
150
]
|
YOYO‐1 dye[
150
]
|
EGFP pDNA[
150
]
|
N/A |
– |
|
Channel trapping |
HeLa,[
151
,
152
,
153
] C2C12,[
155
]
human MSC
[
155
]
|
Trypan blue,[
151
] calcein,[
151
,
152
,
153
] FL‐dextran,[
152
,
153
] PI dye[
155
]
|
EGFP‐ERK1 pDNA[
155
]
|
N/A |
– |
|
Membrane sandwich electroporation |
NIH 3T3,[
156
]
mouse ES
[
157
,
158
]
|
N/A |
GFP pDNA,[
156
,
157
] SEAP pDNA[
156
,
157
,
158
]
|
104 cells per run[
157
]
|
– |
|
Nanochannel electroporation |
Single‐cell electroporation |
Jurkat,[
163
] K562,[
163
]
mouse embryonic fibroblasts
[
163
]
|
PI dye,[
163
] Cy3‐ODN[
163
]
|
GAPDH molecular beacon,[
163
] siRNA,[
163
] Qdot,[
163
] Cy3‐labeled GFP pDNA[
163
]
|
N/A |
Faster delivery compared with bulk and microelectroporation[
163
]
|
|
|
Nanochannel array electroporation |
NK‐92,[
166
] H9C2,[
166
,
167
]
MEF,[
165
,
167
]
mouse cardiomyocyte,[
165
] MDA231,[
168
] CHO,[
168
] HT1080[
168
]
|
PI dye,[
166
,
167
,
168
] FAM‐ODN,[
167
] Co2+,[
168
] Alexa488‐BSA[
168
]
|
CAR/GFP pDNA,[
166
] GFP pDNA,[
165
] OSKM pDNA,[
167
] miRNA,[
165
] mCherry pDNA[
168
]
|
104 cells per cm2,[
167
] 106 cells per run[
169
]
|
mRNA internalization into exosome[
169
]
|
|
|
Nanopore electroporation |
HeLa,[
170
] HEK293,[
170
] 3T3,[
170
] Jurkat[
170
]
|
N/A |
mCherry mRNA,[
170
] GFP pDNA[
170
]
|
104 cells per run[
170
]
|
– |
|
|
Nanoinjection |
Human MSC
[
171
]
|
RFP[
171
]
|
GFP pDNA[
171
]
|
N/A |
Under commercialization by Femtobiomed[
171
]
|
|
|
Nanostraw electroporation |
CHO,[
174
] HEK293t,[
174
] HEK293,[
176
]
hiPSC‐CMs,[
176
]
HSCs,[
176
]
HFs,[
176
]
mouse glia,[
176
]
mouse neuron,[
176
]
HSPCs
[
142
]
|
PI dye,[
174
] FL‐dextran,[
142
] FITC‐OGN[
142
]
|
RFP pDNA,[
174
] mCherry mRNA,[
176
] GFP mRNA,[
142
,
176
] STIM1 protein,[
176
] Cas9 RNP,[
176
] siRNA[
142
]
|
105 cells per run[
176
]
|
Under commercialization by NAVAN Technologies[
174
]
|
|
Nanochannel electroporation |
Nanofountain electroporation |
HeLa,[
181
,
182
] HT1080,[
182
] HEK293[
183
]
|
FL‐dextran,[
181
,
182
] BSA[
181
,
182
,
183
]
|
GAPDH‐molecular beacon,[
181
,
182
] GFP pDNA,[
181
,
183
] GFP knockdown CRISPR/Cas9[
183
]
|
N/A |
– |
|
Flow‐through electroporation |
Flow‐through DC electroporation |
CHO,[
189
,
190
,
191
,
196
] K562[
197
]
|
SYTOX dye,[
189
,
190
] PI dye[
197
]
|
GFP pDNA,[
190
,
191
,
197
] Qdot[
196
]
|
105 cells min−1,[
197
] 106 cells min−1,[
190
] 107 cells min−1[
191
]
|
– |
|
|
Flow‐through AC electroporation |
Huh‐7,[
188
] K562,[
198
] CT26.WT,[
198
] C3H10T1/2,[
199
] HeLa,[
200
] CHO,[
193
] HEK293a,[
201
] Neuro‐2a,[
201
]
HUVEC,[
201
]
HSF
[
201
]
|
PI dye,[
198
] FL‐dextran,[
200
] phallotoxin[
200
]
|
β‐galactosidase pDNA,[
188
] GFP pDNA,[
188
,
193
,
198
,
199
,
201
] GFP siRNA[
200
]
|
103 cells min−1,[
199
] 104 cells min−1,[
201
] 106 cells min−1[
198
]
|
– |
|
|
Flow electroporation with laminar flow |
Yeast cell,[
202
] HEK293a,[
203
] HEK293,[
203
] HeLa,[
203
] C2C12,[
203
] Neuro‐2a,[
203
] PC12,[
203
]
human T cell
[
205
,
206
]
|
Fluorescein[
202
]
|
siRNA,[
203
] GFP pDNA,[
203
] mCherry mRNA[
205
,
206
]
|
104 cells min−1,[
202
] 105 cells min−1,[
203
,
205
] 107 cells min−1[
206
]
|
Electroporation assisted by acoustophoretic cell manipulation[
205
]
|
|
|
Flow electroporation with Dean/vortex flow |
CHO,[
204
] MDA231,[
207
,
208
,
210
] HEK293,[
208
] MCF7,[
208
] HeLa[
208
]
|
YOYO‐1 dye,[
204
] PI dye,[
208
,
210
] FL‐protein[
208
]
|
GFP pDNA,[
204
,
210
] RFP pDNA,[
210
] drug (gemcitabine, bleomycin, topotecan, and quercetin),[
207
] siRNA,[
208
] miRNA[
208
]
|
105 cells min−1[
204
]
|
Cytotoxic drug delivery[
207
]
|
|
Droplet electroporation |
Flow‐through droplet electroporation |
Yeast cell,[
212
] CHO,[
213
] green microalgae (C. reinhardtii)[
214
]
|
Fluorescein,[
212
] SYTOX green dye[
213
]
|
GFP pDNA,[
213
] DNA fragment[
214
]
|
104 cells min−1[
213
]
|
Delivery assisted by Dean vortices[
214
]
|
|
|
EWOD droplet electroporation |
E. coli
[
216
]
|
N/A |
Antibiotic resistance pDNA[
216
]
|
N/A |
Transfection efficiency assessed using colony forming unit[
216
]
|