Table 1.
Author, Year | Recruitment Country | Sample (n)* | Objective PA Outcomes Effect Size (d), Significance (p) | Self Report PA Outcomes Effect Size (d), Significance (p) |
---|---|---|---|---|
RCT | ||||
Bombardier et al., 2013; Kratz et al., 2014 | USA | 92 | N/A | 7-day PAR (0.45, 0.02) |
Canning & Hicks, 2020 | Canada | 91 | Adherence (1.15, <0.05) | N/A |
Carter et al., 2013 | UK | 28 | Adherence (NR) | GLTEQ (0.11, 0.59) |
Carter et al., 2014; Saxton et al., 2013 | UK | 120 | Accelerometry (0.28, ≤0.01), Adherence (NR) | GLTEQ (0.51, ≤0.01) |
Dlugonski et al., 2012 | USA | 45 | N/A | GLTEQ (0.87, 0.001) |
Donkers et al., 2020 | Canada | 48 | Adherence (0.13, 0.21) | N/A |
Geddes et al., 2009 | USA | 12 | Adherence (NR) | N/A |
Geertz et al., 2015 | Germany | 47 | N/A | Self-Reported Physical Activity Outside the Study (NR) |
Hayes et al., 2017; Coote et al., 2017; Coote et al., 2014 | Ireland | 65 | Accelerometry (−0.52, 0.81), Adherence (NR), | GLTEQ (−0.13, <0.01) |
Learmonth et al., 2011 | UK | 32 | N/A | PhoneFITT (0.55, <0.001) |
Learmonth et al., 2017; Adamson et al., 2016 | USA | 57 | Accelerometry (0.21, NS) | GLTEQ (0.64, <0.01) |
Lithopoulos et al., 2017 | Canada | 206 | N/A | LTPAQ-SCI (0.34, <0.05) |
McAuley et al., 2007 | USA | 26 | Adherence (0.48, 0.50) | N/A |
McAuley et al., 2015; Wojcicki et al., 2014 | USA | 48 | N/A | GLTEQ Leisure (0.61, 0.05), GLTEQ MVPA (0.71, 0.02) |
McCullagh et al., 2008 | Ireland | 30 | Adherence (NR) | N/A |
Motl et al., 2011 | USA | 54 | N/A | GLTEQ (0.74, 0.01) |
Motl et al., 2017 | USA | 47 | Accelerometry (0.36, 0.24) | GLTEQ (0.61, 0.05) |
Pilutti et al., 2014; Motl et al., 2015; Klaren et al., 2014; Pilutti et al., 2014; Sandroff et al., 2014 | USA | 82 | Accelerometry (0.41, 0.07), Adherence (NR) | GLTEQ (0.77, 0.001), IPAQ (0.55, NR) |
Plow et al., 2014; Plow et al., 2014 | USA | 30 | N/A | GLTEQ (0.61, 0.002), PADS (0.86, 0.004) |
Plow et al., 2019; Plow et al., 2019; Plow et al., 2012 | USA | 208 | Accelerometry PA vs FM (0.41, 0.29), PA vs Control (0.69, 0.02) | GLTEQ PA vs FM (−0.05, 0.68), PA vs Control (0.36, 0.04) |
Rice et al., 2015 | USA | 14 | Accelerometry (0.23, 0.65) | N/A |
Romberg et al., 2004 | Finland | 114 | Adherence (NR) | N/A |
Ryan et al., 2019; Ryan et al., 2017 | Ireland | 60 | Accelerometry (0.04, NS), Adherence (NR) | IPAQ (−0.54, NS) |
Sandroff et al., 2016 | USA | 10 | Adherence (NR) | N/A |
Sebastião et al., 2018; Sebastião et al., 2017 | USA | 26 | Adherence (NR), Pedometry (NR, <0.001) | N/A |
Smith et al., 2012 | USA | 13 | Adherence (−0.50, NS) | N/A |
Suh et al., 2015 | USA | 68 | N/A | GLTEQ (0.33, 0.02) |
Tallner et al., 2016 | Germany | 126 | Adherence (NR) | BQ (0.56, S) |
Thomas et al., 2017; Thomas et al., 2014 | UK | 30 | Accelerometry (NR), Adherence (NR) | GLTEQ (0.85, NR) |
Turner et al., 2016 | USA | 64 | N/A | GLTEQ (0.45, 0.049) |
Pre Post | ||||
Dixon-Ibarra et al., 2017 | USA | 13 | Adherence (NR) | N/A |
Dlugonski et al., 2011 | USA | 21 | Accelerometry (0.68, 0.006) | GLTEQ (0.34, 0.07), IPAQ (0.43, 0.03) |
Feys et al., 2013 | Belgium | 57 | N/A | PASIPD (0.17, 0.08) |
Hale et al., 2013 | New Zealand | 28 | N/A | Self-Reported Physical Activity Diary (−0.17, NR) |
Kinnett-Hopkins & Motl, 2018 | USA | 32 | N/A | GLTEQ (1.49, <0.001) |
Mandelbaum et al., 2015 | USA | 8 | Adherence (NR) | GLTEQ (NR, 0.01) |
Motl & Dlugonski, 2011 | USA | 18 | Accelerometry (0.92, <0.001), Pedometry (1.04, <0.001) | GLTEQ (0.83, 0.0015), IPAQ (1.12, <0.001) |
Plow & Finlayson, 2011 | USA | 30 | N/A | PADS (0.65, 0.001) |
Note: RCT= Randomized Controlled Trial; USA= United States of America; UK= United Kingdom; PAR= Physical Activity Recall; GLTEQ= Godin Leisure Time Exercise Questionnaire; IPAQ= International Physical Activity Questionnaire; LTPAQ-SCI= Leisure Time Physical Activity Questionnaire for People with Spinal Cord Injury; PADS= Physical Activity and Disability Survey; PASIPD= Physical Activity Scale for Individuals with Physical Disabilities; MVPA= Moderate-Vigorous Physical Activity; BQ= Baecke Questionnaire; NR= Not Reported; N/A= Not Applicable; NS= Not Significant; S= Significant No Value Provided; PA= PA Group; FM= Fatigue Management Group
RCTs= Sample Size Randomized