Table 1.
Study | Study Age (year) a | Participants | Design | Arms | Outcomesb |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Dunstan et al. (2012)10 | 53.8 ± 4.9 | 19 overweight/obese adults, 11 males | Randomized crossover trial, ≥6 days washout period |
PS: 420 min LPA-INT: sitting interrupted with 2-min bouts of light-intensity walking every 20 min MPA-INT: sitting interrupted with 2-min bouts of moderate-intensity walking every 20 min |
1, 2 |
Duvivier et al. (2013)11 | 21.0 ± 2.0 | 18 healthy adults, 2 males | Randomized crossover trial, ≥10 days washout period |
PS: 840 min/day LPA-INT: sitting 480 min/day and 360 min activity breaks with 240 min of walking and 120 min of standing VPA-INT: sitting 780 min/day and 60 min of vigorous exercise |
1, 2 |
Newsom et al. (2013)12 | 28.0 ± 2.0 | 11 obese adults, 3 males | Randomized crossover trial, ≥7 days washout period |
PS: 480 min LPA-CON: sitting 390 min and a single bout of exercise (∼70 min, 50%VO2peak) MPA-CON: sitting 375 min and a single bout of exercise (∼55 min, 65%VO2peak) |
1, 2 |
Peddie et al. (2013)13 | 25.9 ± 5.3 | 70 normal-weight adults, 28 males | Randomized crossover trial, ≥6 days (6–13) washout period |
PS: 540 min MPA-CON: sitting 510 min and a single 30-min bout of brisk walking (60%VO2max) MPA-INT: sitting 510 min and 100-s bouts of brisk walking (60%VO2max) every 30 min |
1, 2 |
Holmstrup et al. (2014)20 | 25 (18–35) | 11 young obese participants with impaired glucose tolerance, 8 males | Randomized crossover trial |
PS: 720 min MPA-CON: sitting interrupted with a single 60-min bout of moderate-intensity exercise (60%–65%VO2max) after breakfast MPA-INT: sitting interrupted with 5-min bouts of moderate-intensity exercise every 60 min |
1, 2 |
Thorp et al. (2014)14 | 48.2 ± 7.9 | 23 overweight/obese adults, 17 males | Randomized crossover trial, 7‒35 days washout period |
PS: 480 min STA-INT: sitting interrupted with 30 min of standing every 30 min |
1, 2 |
Bailey et al. (2015)15 | 24.0 ± 3.0 | 10 non-obese adults, 7 males | Randomized crossover trial, ≥6 days washout period |
PS: 300 min STA-INT: sitting interrupted with 2-min bouts of standing every 20 min LPA-INT: sitting interrupted with 2-min bouts of light-intensity walking (3.2 km/h) every 20 min |
1 |
Larsen et al. (2015)16 | 56.7 ± 1.5 | 19 overweight/obese adults, 11 males | Randomized crossover trial ≥12 days washout period |
PS: 420 min LPA-INT: sitting interrupted with 2-min bouts of walking every 20 min (3.2 km/h) |
1, 2 |
Bailey et al. (2016)17 | 26.6 ± 8.5 | 13 healthy adults, 6 males | Randomized crossover trial, ≥7 days washout period |
PS: 300 min LPA-INT: sitting interrupted with 2-min bouts of light-intensity walking (3.2 km/h) every 20 min MPA-INT: sitting interrupted with 2-min bouts of moderate-intensity walking (5.8‒7.9 km/h) every 20 min |
1, 2 |
Hansen et al. (2016)21 | 22 (20–23) | 14 healthy, young, normal-weight adults, 6 males | Randomized crossover trial, ≥4 days washout period |
PS: 150 min LPA-INT: sitting interrupted with 2-min bouts of light-intensity walking (3.5‒4.5 km/h) every 20 min |
1 |
Hawari et al. (2016)22 | 33.0 ± 13.0 | 10 normoglycemic, overweight/obese males | Randomized crossover trial, 7‒14 days washout period |
PS: 480 min STA-CON: sitting interrupted with 15-min bouts of standing every 30 min STA-INT: sitting interrupted with 10 × 1.5-min bouts of standing every 30 min |
1, 2 |
Henson et al. (2016)18 | 66.6 ± 4.7 | 22 overweight/obese, dysglycemic, postmenopausal women | Randomized crossover trial, 7‒22 days washout period |
PS: 450 min STA-INT: sitting interrupted with 5-min bouts of standing every 30 min LPA-INT: sitting interrupted with 5-min bouts of light-intensity walking every 30 min |
1, 2 |
Miyashita et al. (2016)19 | 68.8 ± 3.2 | 15 postmenopausal women | Randomized crossover trial, ≥7 days washout period |
PS: 480 min LPA-CON: sitting interrupted with a single 30-min bout of light-intensity walking after breakfast LPA-INT: sitting interrupted with 1.5-min bouts of light-intensity walking every 15 min after 2 meals (20 breaks) |
1, 2 |
Wennberg et al. (2016)23 | 59.7 ± 8.1 | 19 overweight/obese adults, 10 males | Randomized crossover trial, 6 days washout period |
PS: 420 min LPA-INT: sitting interrupted with 3-min bouts of light-intensity walking (3.2km/h) every 30 min |
2 |
Benatti et al. (2017)39 | 30.1 ± 8.8 | 14 physically inactive, healthy adult males | Randomized crossover trial, 5‒15 days washout period |
PS: 540 min STA-INT: sitting interrupted by 15 min of standing every 30 min during the 9-h sitting period MPA-CON: sitting interrupted with a single 30-min bout of moderate-intensity exercise (50%–55%VO2max) on treadmill |
1, 2 |
Bhammar et al. (2017)24 | 32.0 ± 5.0 | 10 overweight/obese adults, 5 males | Randomized crossover trial, 6‒14 days washout period |
PS: 540 min MPA-CON: sitting interrupted with a single 60-min bout of moderate-intensity walking (71% ± 4% HRmax) MPA-INT: sitting interrupted with 2-min bouts of moderate-intensity walking (53% ± 5% HRmax) every 20 min; a total of 21 breaks VPA-INT: sitting interrupted with 2-min bouts of vigorous-intensity walking (79% ± 4% HRmax) every 60 min; a total of 8 breaks |
1 |
Brocklebank et al. (2017)25 | 52.4 ± 5.1 | 17 middle-aged office workers, 8 males | Randomized crossover trial, 24-h washout period |
PS: 300 min STA-INT: sitting interrupted by 2 min of standing every 20 min LPA-INT: sitting interrupted by 2 min of light-intensity walking every 20 min |
1 |
Kerr et al. (2017)26 | 66.0 ± 9.0 | 10 sedentary, overweight or obese postmenopausal women | Randomized crossover trial, ≥7 days washout period |
Prolonged sitting: 300 min STA-INT: sitting interrupted with 2 min of standing every 20 min, or sitting interrupted with 10 min of standing every hour LPA-INT: sitting interrupted by 2 min of light-intensity walking every 60 min |
1, 2 |
McCarthy et al. (2017)27 | 66.0 ± 6.0 | 13 obese adults, 6 males | Randomized crossover trial, ≥7 days washout period |
PS: 450 min LPA-INT: sitting interrupted with 5 min of seated arm ergometry (∼3 km/h light-intensity walking) every 30 min |
1, 2 |
Pulsford et al. (2017)38 | 40.2 ± 12.2 | 25 inactive males | Randomized crossover trial, ≥6 days washout period |
PS: 420 min STA-INT: sitting interrupted with 2-min bouts of standing every 20 min LPA-INT: sitting interrupted with 2-min bouts of light-intensity walking (3.2 km/h) every 20 min |
1, 2 |
Champion et al. (2018)28 | 35.8 ± 10.9 | 24 inactive adults, 12 males |
Randomized crossover trial, ≥6 days washout period |
PS: 390 min LPA-INT: sitting interrupted with 20 min of light-intensity walking every 60 min |
1, 2 |
Maylor et al. (2018)31 | 29.0 ± 9.0 | 14 sedentary and inactive adults, 7 males | Randomized crossover trial, 6–35 days washout period |
PS: 480 min MPA-CON: sitting interrupted with 30 min of continuous moderate-intensity PA (60%VO2reserve) followed by PS for the remainder of the condition VPA-INT: sitting interrupted with 2 min 32 s bouts of high-intensity PA (85%VO2reserve) every 60 min |
1, 2 |
Sperlich et al. (2018)29 | 22.0 ± 2.0 | 12 normal-weight students, 5 males | Randomized crossover trial, ≥3 days washout period |
PS: 180 min VPA-CON: sitting interrupted with a single 6-min bout of high-intensity exercise (e.g., squats, lunge, and running) |
1 |
Altenburg et al. (2019)33 | 19.2 ± 0.6 | 20 healthy-weight males | Randomized crossover trial, ≥6 days washout period |
PS: 300 min STA-INT: sitting with hourly 10-min standing interruptions SitActive: sitting on a stability ball |
1, 2 |
Chrismas et al. (2019)34 | 27 (21‒44) | 11 sedentary obese females | Randomized crossover trial, 6‒8 days washout period |
PS: 300 min MPA-INT: sitting interrupted with 3 min of moderate-intensity walking every 30 min at a speed corresponding to a rating of perceived exertion (RPE) of 12‒14 identified during the familiarization session |
1, 2 |
Freire et al. (2019)35 | 24.4 ± 3.8 | 25 excess body fat adults, 10 males | Randomized crossover trial, 7 days washout period |
PS: 600 min MPA-INT: sitting interrupted with 5 min of moderate-intensity walking at habitual gait speed (reaching 10,000 steps) every 20 min VPA-CON: sitting interrupted with a single 10-min bout of high-intensity exercise (running) |
1 |
Hawari et al. (2019)30 | 37.0 ± 16.0 | 14 overweight/obese adults, 11 males | Randomized crossover trial, 1‒2 weeks washout period |
PS: 390 min LPA-INT: sitting interrupted with 30 s of 10 chair squats every 20 min |
1, 2 |
Maylor et al. (2019)37 | 33.8 ± 13.4 | 14 sedentary and inactive females | Randomized crossover trial, ≥7 days washout period |
PS: 450 min MPA-INT: sitting interrupted with 2 min of moderate-intensity treadmill physical activity every 30 min |
1, 2 |
Ma et al. (2020)36 | 24.0 ± 3.0 | 16 non-obese, inactive, healthy adults, 7 males | Randomized crossover trial, ≥7 days washout period |
PS: 540 min MPA-INT - Group 1: sitting interrupted with 3-min bouts of moderate-intensity walking (60%VO2max) every 30 min, a total of 36-min breaks MPA-INT - Group 2: sitting interrupted with 5-min bouts of moderate-intensity walking (60%VO2max) every 45 min, a total of 45-min breaks MPA-INT - Group 3: sitting interrupted with 8-min bouts of moderate-intensity walking (60%VO2max) every 60 min, a total of 56-min breaks |
1 |
Yates et al. (2020)32 | 70 (67‒75) | 60 overweight adults (30 South Asian and 30 white European), 31 males | Randomized crossover trial, ≥7 days washout period |
PS: 450 min STA-INT: sitting interrupted with 5-min standing breaks every 30 min LPA-INT: sitting interrupted with 5-min self-paced walking breaks every 30 min |
1, 2 |
Abbreviations: HR = heart rate; HRmax = maximal heart rate; LPA-CON = light-intensity physical activity one bout of continuous interrupting; LPA-INT = light-intensity physical activity intermittent interrupting; MPA-CON = moderate-intensity physical activity one bout of continuous interrupting; MPA-INT = moderate-intensity physical activity intermittent interrupting; PS = prolonged sitting; SitActive = active sitting interrupting (e.g., sitting on a stability ball); STA-CON = standing one bout of continuous interrupting; STA-INT = standing intermittent interrupting; VO2max = maximal oxygen uptake; VO2peak = peak oxygen uptake; VO2reserve = reserve oxygen uptake; VPA-CON = vigorous-intensity physical activity one bout of continuous interrupting; VPA-INT = vigorous-intensity physical activity intermittent interrupting.
The mean ± SD or the mean with range of age in years was reported.
Outcome 1 stands for postprandial glycemia; Outcome 2 stands for postprandial insulin response.