Skip to main content
. 2021 Jul 30;13(7):e16763. doi: 10.7759/cureus.16763

Table 4. Data Table illustrating the study characteristics and findings for final articles included in this systematic review .

VERA - weaRable hAptic devices; RCT- randomized controlled trial; VR - virtual reality, GR - gesture recognition; BBS - Berg Balance Scale; FGA - Functional Gait Assessment; TUG - Timed Up and Go Test; FRT - Functional Reach Test; ERSP - event-related spectral perturbations; RAGT - robotic-assisted gait therapy; VRRT - virtual reality reflection therapy; RIMT - Reinforcement-Induced Movement Therapy.

Author & year of publication    Rehabilitation outcome target   Intervention  Number of patients  Type of study  Result  Conclusion  
Bortone et al. (2020) [25 Upper extremity function in Cerebral Palsy   weaRable hAptic devices (VERA), cross over with manual therapy    Pilot cross over RCT   Improvement in upper extremity function in both control and experimental group  No statistically significant difference between both groups
Ögün et al. (2019) [26 Post-stroke upper extremity function  Leap Motion-based 3D immersion VR  65  RCT  Improvement in upper extremity function  Statistically significant upper extremity motor improvement in the experimental group (p<0.05) assessed with the Fugl-Meyer Upper Extremity Scale
Choi et al. (2019) [27 Post-stroke upper extremity function  Gesture recognition (GR) device mirror therapy   36  RCT  Improvement in upper extremity function  Statistically significant motor improvement in the GR group as compared to conventional mirror therapy group (p<0.05)
Oh et al. (2019) [28 Post-stroke upper extremity function and cognitive function  VR + real instrument training  31  RCT  Improvement in upper extremity function   Statistically significant motor improvement in the experimental group for wrist extension (p< 0.04) and elbow flexion (p<0.022)
Feng et al. (2019) [29 Parkinson’s disease balance and gait   VR training rehabilitation  28  RCT  Improved balance and gait   Statistically significant motor improvement in the experimental group (p < 0.05) across many scales: Berg Balance Scale (BBS), Functional Gait Assessment (FGA), and Timed Up and Go Test (TUG)
Park et al. (2019) [30 Post-stroke upper extremity function  VR based planar motion exercise apparatus  26  Pilot RCT  Improvement in upper extremity function  Significant difference in motor function in both groups (p<0.05). Increased range of motion in the experimental group versus control for should abduction and internal rotation (non-statistically significant)
Lee et al. (2018) [31 Post-stroke postural balance and upper extremity function  Game-based VR canoe paddling  30  RCT  Improvement in both balance and upper extremity function  Statistically significant motor improvement in upper extremity function and postural balance (p<0.05)
Karasu et al. (2018) [32 Post-stroke static and dynamic balance  Nintendo Wii + conventional therapy  23  RCT  Improved in many categories  Motor improvement in both groups (non-statistically significant primary outcome), however group-time secondary outcome shows significant difference in the experimental group (p<0.001) for BBS and Functional Reach Test (FRT)
Bergmann et al. (2018) [33]    Post-stroke gait      VR augmented robotic-assisted gait therapy (RAGT)    20  Pilot RCT  Improved gait and motivation    Increased motivation in the experimental group, this group spent more time walking on the robot compared to the control group (<0.03). Statistically significant difference on the Functional Ambulation Classification (p<0.01) after intervention in both control and experimental group
Gandolfi et al. (2017) [34]    Parkinson’s disease balance and gait    Virtual Telerehabilitation using Nintendo Wii    76  RCT  Reduced postural instability    Statistically significant motor improvement in VR Telerehabilitation group compared to in-clinic rehabilitation group (p=0.04) on Berg Balance Scale
Calabrò et al. (2017) [35]    Post-stroke gait and balance  RAGT + VR (2D animated avatar) interaction using EEG oscillations    24  Pilot RCT  Improvement in gait and balance    RAGT + VR (experimental group) showed higher event-related spectral perturbations (ERSP) in specific fronto-central cortical affected brain areas as compared to the control group
In et al. (2016) [16]    Post-stroke postural balance and gait    Virtual reality reflection therapy (VRRT)    25  RCT  Improvement in many categories    Statistically significant improvement (p<0.05) in VRRT group across various scales such as postural sway, Functional Reach Test, BBS, and TUG
Ballester et al. (2016) [36]    Post-stroke upper extremity function    Reinforcement-Induced Movement Therapy (RIMT)      18  RCT  Motor improvement with RIMT    Statistically significant motor improvement 12 weeks post-trial (p<0.05)