Table 3. Combination Therapy for Insomnia.
Scientific name (common name) | Part (extract) | Study design |
Jadud
score |
Intervention | Patients | Duration | Result | Mechanism | Reference |
Valeriana officinalis + Humulus lupulus |
-Dormeasan®: 460 mg of V. officinalis+ 460 mg H. lupulus -1: 12 dissolved in 61% ethanol |
Double-Blind, Randomized, Placebo-Controlled | 3 |
2 ml dissolved in 50 ml of honey flavored water and administrated orally 15 min before EEG(n=20) -placebo(n=22) |
44 patients (30-70y) reporting on having a poor sleep for 2 weeks without neurological complications and any organic disease |
2nights(reference night and medication night). |
-Led to deeper sleep. -↑sleep quantity in the treatment group |
no mechanism of action presented | 30 |
V. officinalis + H. lupulus |
Ze 91019: 500 mg valerian extract siccum + 120 mg hops extract siccum _45% methanol m/m with a drug extract ratio of 5.3:1 (valerian) and 6.6:1 (hops) |
Randomized, Double-Blind, Placebo- Controlled |
2 |
-Valerian Ze 911 (n=10) - Valerian/hops Ze 91019 (n=10) -placebo (n=10) |
30 patients (≥18 years) suffering from non-organic sleep disorders (ICD 10, F 51.0–51.2) |
4weeks |
-No significant differences across groups in NREM -↑significantly sleep latency for Ze91019 -single valerian is not superior to placebo in sleep latency (=plausibility for adding hops extract to the valerian Extract) |
decreasing excitatory neurotransmission in the central nervous system |
31 |
Hypericum perforatun
(St. Johns Wort) + V. officinalis + Passiflora Incarnata (passionflower) |
Neurapas balance: 60mg St. John’s wort+28mg valerian+ 35mg passion flower |
Double-blind randomized cross-over study |
3 tablets twice a day | 20 healthy subjects | 3days |
-↓ wakefulness, REM latency, NREM sleep in the first sleep cycle -↑NREM- sleep in the second cycle -↑subjective mood and subjective sleep evaluation -no difference in cognitive performance |
no mechanism of action presented | 32 | |
Valeriana officinali + Humuluslupulus |
Dormeasan®:460 mg of fresh V. officinalis; radix (root) rec. Tinct. 1:10 and H. lupulus, strobulus (fruit) rec. tinct. 1:12 dissolved in 61% ethanol |
Double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled |
3 |
-2ml of the formulation was dissolved in 50 mL of honey-flavored water and then administered orally(n=20 -placebo (n=22) |
42 healthy (Mean age of female 50.2 and males 48.2) having poor sleep within the previous 2weeks period |
2 consecutive nights (reference nd medication night) |
-↑sleep time and deeper sleep time Significantly |
May: 1.inhibit central catabolism of GABA 2.bind directly to GABA-A receptors and stimulate the release and reuptake of GABA |
33 |
Piper methysticum (kava) / Valeriana officinali |
crossover trial, not double-blind |
0 |
First treated for 6 weeks with kava 120 mg daily(n=24) This was followed by 2 weeks off treatment and then, 5 having dropped out, 19 received valerian 600mg daily for another 6 weeks (n=19) |
24 patients suffering from stress-induced insomnia ( 23-65y) |
6 weeks for each drug with washout period of 2weeks between |
-↓Total stress severity by both -valerian: no sig effect on inducing sleep but good effect on quality -stress problems and the severity of the resulting insomnia were rapidly relieved by kava -improvements achieved with kava were then maintained by valerian |
no mechanism of action presented | 34 |