Skip to main content
. 2021 Aug 6;11:16054. doi: 10.1038/s41598-021-95649-5

Table 5.

CCD design of variables and their corresponding experimental and predicted removal of MG and AO.

Run No Variables Responses
%RMG %RAO
A B C D E Actual Predicted Actual Predicted
1 350 6 8 4 12 63.56 63.75 73.44 73.28
2 350 10 8 4 6 92.97 93.56 87.73 87.81
3 300 8 2 6 9 84.50 83.88 90.62 90.89
4 300 8 6 2 9 77.76 76.28 87.08 87.68
5 300 4 6 6 9 29.18 29.49 38.37 38.97
6 300 8 6 6 9 82.15 82.00 92.25 92.43
7 250 6 4 4 12 57.62 57.92 61.59 61.28
8 400 8 6 6 9 87.39 86.99 87.85 87.81
9 300 12 6 6 9 62.91 61.99 79.23 78.35
10 350 10 8 8 12 57.86 57.77 96.40 96.98
11 250 6 8 4 6 34.29 34.53 43.91 43.67
12 300 8 6 10 9 43.47 44.35 62.48 61.61
13 300 8 6 6 15 84.06 83.95 89.73 89.33
14 300 8 6 6 9 84.44 82.00 94.26 92.43
15 350 10 4 4 12 98.68 99.33 99.03 99.04
16 300 8 10 6 9 56.85 56.86 74.86 74.31
17 200 8 6 6 9 54.17 53.96 48.06 47.82
18 250 10 8 8 6 37.94 37.90 48.54 49.04
19 300 8 6 6 9 80.94 82.00 90.69 92.43
20 300 8 6 6 9 79.75 82.00 91.37 92.43
21 350 6 4 8 12 85.39 85.15 62.29
22 350 6 4 4 6 52.46 52.90 84.43
23 300 8 6 6 9 82.73 82.00 92.43
24 350 6 8 8 6 27.69 27.39 43.91
25 250 6 8 8 12 46.09 45.65 46.25
26 300 8 6 6 9 81.38 82.00 92.43
27 350 10 4 8 6 58.07 58.23 78.71
28 250 10 4 4 6 75.73 76.43 76.74
29 300 8 6 6 3 58.76 58.27 74.55
30 250 10 8 4 12 56.98 57.43 72.34
31 250 10 4 8 12 56.35 56.37 64.56
32 250 6 4 8 6 39.90 39.71 52.59

A: adsorbent dosage (mg), B: pH of the solution, C: MG concentration (mg L−1), D: AO concentration (mg L−1) and E: sonication time (min).