Skip to main content
. 2021 Jul 19;19:4123–4131. doi: 10.1016/j.csbj.2021.07.013

Table 3.

Performance of optimized single-encodings and fusion models on different machine learning classifiers.

GBDT SVM NB AB RF



Descriptor Acc Sp Sn MCC AUC Acc Sp Sn MCC AUC Acc Sp Sn MCC AUC Acc Sp Sn MCC AUC Acc Sp Sn MCC AUC
AAC 76.34 74.70 79.60 0.520 0.827 55.39 55.20 57.50 0.108 0.551 74.55 77.00 70.10 0.493 0.800 76.35 74.70 79.60 0.528 0.811 76.05 74.65 77.68 0.518 0.824
CKSAAP 51.19 52.00 79.60 0.029 0.526 50.29 50.20 60.50 0.006 0.503 52.09 54.00 24.20 0.051 0.523 50.09 50.00 80.20 0.001 0.505 53.22 53.12 79.88 0.032 0.551
C/T/D 82.33 81.40 83.80 0.647 0.896 58.68 55.00 91.00 0.231 0.587 72.45 68.00 83.80 0.461 0.808 75.44 73.50 79.50 0.511 0.820 82.16 81.10 83.24 0.644 0.892
Geary 78.74 77.30 81.40 0.576 0.854 50.39 52.70 47.30 0.048 0.524 74.55 75.90 71.90 0.492 0.816 69.76 70.10 68.90 0.395 0.762 79.71 78.10 81.77 0.582 0.876
NMBroto 81.13 80.60 82.00 0.623 0.890 79.04 80.50 76.60 0.582 0.790 79.94 81.60 77.20 0.600 0.877 68.26 67.00 71.90 0.366 0.765 80.93 79.83 82.00 0.621 0.890
PAAC 76.04 74.90 78.40 0.522 0.825 70.65 67.50 79.60 0.420 0.707 62.87 58.60 88.00 0.298 0.745 69.16 67.00 75.40 0.386 0.754 75.88 74.40 78.32 0.521 0.825
TPC 50.89 80.00 24.00 0.074 0.506 49.40 49.50 59.30 −0.01 0.492 50.59 51.40 21.60 0.015 0.502 49.40 49.30 39.50 −0.01 0.493 50.28 78.90 24.00 0.071 0.498
Fusion All 93.06 94.00 92.00 0.862 0.971 79.34 78.40 80.91 0.574 0.794 87.00 88.90 84.70 0.752 0.936 82.33 76.30 87.50 0.628 0.888 91.08 92.55 91.11 0.837 0.956