Skip to main content
. 2021 Jul 22;21(15):4983. doi: 10.3390/s21154983

Table 6.

The comparison of the constructed sensor matrix with commercially available devices.

Producer Model Technology Range Accuracy Response Time Reference
Gdańsk University of Technology Sensor matrix prototype MOS and EC gas sensors CO, CO2, CH4, H2: 0–100%
(using dilution system)
5% Full Scale (FS) <90 s to 90% step range (MOS) -
Cubic Sensor and Instrument Co. Portable Infrared Syngas Analyzer Gasboard-3100P CO, CO2, CH4 (NDIR)
H2 (TCD)
CO: 0–30%
CO2: 0–25%
CH4: 0–10%
H2: 0–30%
2% Full Scale (FS) <15 s to 90% step range (NDIR) [31]
Cubic Sensor and Instrument Co. Syngas Analysis System Gasboard-9021 CO, CO2, CH4 (NDIR)
H2 (TCD)
CO: 0–30%
CO2: 0–25%
CH4: 0–10%
H2: 0–30%
CO, CO2, CH4 < 1% FS
H2 <2% FS
<15 s to 90% step range (NDIR) [32]
Hubei Cubic-Ruiyi Instrument CO. Portable Natural Gas Analyzer Gasboard-3110P CO2, CH4 (NDIR) CO2: 0–5%
CH4: 0–100%
<2% FS <15 s to 90% step range (NDIR) [33]
Nova Analytical Systems (a Unit of Tenova Goodfellow Inc.) 970P Portable Multi-Gas Industrial Analyzers CO, CO2, CH4 (NDIR)
H2 (TCD)
CO: 0–2% or 0–50%
CO2: 0–2% or 0–50%
CH4: 0–2% or 0–50%
H2: 0–2% or 0–50%
0.1% for all gases <1% FS in 8 h 20–30 s to 90% step range [34]
VASTHI Instruments Pvt Ltd Online Syngas Analyzer by Vasthi CO, CO2, CH4 (NDIR)
H2 (TCD)
CO: 0–100%
CO2: 0–100%
CH4: 0–50%
H2: 0–50%
CO, CO2, CH4: 0.5%
from range or ± 3%
H2: ±5 ppm or 5%
45 s to 90% step range [35]
Wuhan Tianyu Intelligent Control Technology Co., Ltd. (TIANYU) Syngas Analyzer Portable SYN-600 CO, CO2, CH4 (NDIR)
H2 (TCD-MEMS)
CO: 0–100%
CO2: 0–100%
CH4: 0–100%
H2: 0–100%
CO, CO2, CH4: ±2% FS
H2: ±3% FS
45 s to 90% step range [36]
MRU GmbH SWG 100 Syngas CO, CO2, CH4 (NDIR)
H2 (TCD)
CO: 0–10/100%
CO2: 0–10/100%
CH4: 0–10/100%
H2: 0–10/100%
no data no data [37]
ETG Risorse e Technologia S.r.l. MCA 100 SYN P – Portable Syngas Analyzer CO, CO2, CH4 (NDIR)
H2 (TCD)
Modified according to the needs of customer CO, CO2, CH4, H2: ±2%
FS
no data [38]