Skip to main content
. 2021 Jul 31;21(15):5207. doi: 10.3390/s21155207

Table 22.

Multi-class (CO (Class 0) vs. PD Stage 2 (Class 2) vs. PD Stage 2.5 (Class 2.5), and PD Stage 3 (Class 3)) and two-class classification (CO vs. PD (Class 2, Class 2.5, and Class 3)) summary using several CNN classifiers (AlexNet, ResNet-50, ResNet-101, and GoogLeNet) with 10-fold cross-validation for Si dataset.

Dataset vGRF Signal CNN
Classifier
Time Window Frequency Range Classification Task Evaluation Parameters
Sen (%) Spec (%) Acc (%) AUC
Si LF AlexNet 10 s 1.95–50 Hz Multi-Class Class 0 98.56 * 99.05 * 98.83 * 0.9881 *
AlexNet 10 s 1.95–50 Hz Class 2 95.83 * 98.84 * 97.53 * 0.9734 *
AlexNet 10 s 1.95–50 Hz Class 2.5 98.81 * 98.39 * 98.44 * 0.9860 *
ResNet-50 10 s 0.83–1.95 Hz Two-Class 98.85 * 98.41 * 98.56 * 0.9964 *
RF ResNet-101 10 s 0.83–1.95 Hz Multi-Class Class 0 99.43 97.86 98.57 0.9864
ResNet-101 10 s 0.83–1.95 Hz Class 2 95.83 97.22 96.61 0.9653
ResNet-50 15 s 1.95–50 Hz Class 2.5 94.64 98.03 97.66 0.9633
ResNet-50 10 s 0.83–1.95 Hz Two-Class 98.62 98.63 98.57 0.9994
CF AlexNet 10 s 1.95–50 Hz Multi-Class Class 0 97.41 99.52 98.57 0.9847
AlexNet 10 s 1.95–50 Hz Class 2 94.94 97.69 96.48 0.9631
AlexNet 15 s 1.95–50 Hz Class 2.5 98.21 97.37 97.46 0.9779
ResNet-101 10 s 0.83–1.95 Hz Two-Class 98.88 97.35 97.92 0.9984

Note: * denotes the best classification result and was selected using Youden’s index criteria.