Table 1.
Author | Study location | Study period | Study type | Key findings | Themesa |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
VASCC [15] | Global | Ongoing | Global registry | Elucidate the effect of the deferment of vascular cases Global registry of thrombotic complications of COVID-19 |
2 |
Ng [7] | Global | March 2020 | Survey | 90.9% deferred of elective VS cases 92.2% still performing emergency surgery |
3 |
COVER Tier 1 study [8] | Global | March to May 2020 | Survey, global registry | Stricter case selection for carotid intervention Increased threshold for aortic aneurysm repair |
2, 3, 6 |
COVER Tier 2 study [40] | Global | March to May 2020 | Global observational study | Elevated in-hospital mortality across aortic, carotid and lower extremity interventions despite low COVID-19 infection rate | 8 |
Aziz [16] | US | April 2020 | Survey | Deferment of elective cases Reduced emergency department consults for VS conditions |
4, 7 |
Latz [17] | US | April 2020 | Survey | 80.5% performing urgent and emergent cases only 15.3% performing emergent cases only |
4 |
Mouawad [18] | US | April 2020 | Survey | 91.7% cancelled elective cases | 4 |
Mahentiran [19] | US | May 2020 | Survey | 74% performing urgent and emergent cases only Venous registry volumes reduced fivefold |
4 |
Natarajan [20] | US | May 2020 | Survey | Arterial registry volumes reduced sevenfold | 4 |
Mirza [21] | US | March to April 2020 | Institutional review | 93% of electives deferred Performed urgent and emergent cases |
5 |
Sarfati [22] | US | March to April 2020 | Institutional review | Adhered to ACS guidelines Performed tier 2b and tier 3 cases Deferred tier 1, tier 2a, and some tier 2b cases |
5 |
Boschetti [23] | Italy | March to April 2020 | Institutional review | 37.1% reduction on operative case volume Reduction in emergency room visits Increased presentation of patients with decompensated CLTI |
5, 7, 8 |
Chisci [24] | Italy | March to April 2020 | Institutional review | Deferment of nonurgent elective cases Endovascular treatment of CLTI preferred |
5, 6 |
Chiesa [25] | Italy | March to April 2020 | Institutional review | Deferment of varicose vein surgery Only symptomatic, urgent or emergent cases performed |
5 |
Piazza [26] | Italy | March to April 2020 | Institutional review | Deferment of nonurgent elective cases Performed urgent and emergent cases Higher major amputation rate for CLTI patients |
5, 8 |
Mascia [27] | Italy | March to April 2020 | Institutional review | Increased urgent and emergent cases due to referral system Higher proportion of late presentation of limb ischemia 50% reduction in ruptured or symptomatic AAA |
5, 7, 8 |
Pini [28] | Italy | March to April 2020 | Institutional review | Priority criteria for elective cases adopted Performed urgent and emergency cases |
5 |
Duarte [29] | Portugal | February to June 2020 | Institutional review | 17.8% reduction in operative case volume 54% reduction in patients admitted from the ED Significant increase in endovascular procedures Significant increase in use of locoregional anesthesia |
5, 6, 7 |
Gouveia E Melo [30] | Portugal | March 2020 | Institutional review | Performed urgent and emergent cases only Decrease in urgent and emergent cases Endovascular approach and locoregional anesthesia preferred |
5, 6 |
Correia [35] | Portugal | March to June 2020 | Institutional review | Fewer patients presented to ED compared to 2019 Patients required more urgent surgery compared to 2019 |
7 |
Ben Abdallah [31] | France | March to April 2020 | Institutional review | Performed only urgent or emergent cases only Endovascular approach favored over open repair Increased number of patients with acute arterial events Significant decrease in overall vascular referrals |
5, 6, 7 |
Connolly [32] | Ireland | March to April 2020 | Institutional review | Deferment of nonurgent elective cases Endovascular approach preferred |
5, 6 |
Metelmann [33] | Germany | March to April 2020 | Institutional review | Deferment of nonurgent elective cases Performed urgent or emergent cases, ie, high-risk AAA |
5 |
Ünal [34] | Turkey | April 2020 | Institutional review | Triaged vascular cases according to “level of priority” Deferred nonurgent elective cases Endovascular approach preferred |
5, 6 |
Leong Tan [36] | Singapore | March to April 2020 | Institutional review | Deferred nonurgent elective cases Performed urgent or emergent cases only |
5 |
Ng [37] | Singapore | February to March 2020 | Institutional review | Deferred nonurgent elective cases Performed urgent or emergent cases only Increase in major amputation rate |
5, 8 |
Wang [39] | China | April 2020 | Institutional review | Deferred nonurgent elective cases Performed urgent or emergent cases only Endovascular approach preferred |
5, 6 |
Bashar [38] | Bangladesh | March to June 2020 | Institutional review | Deferred nonurgent elective cases Performed urgent or emergent cases only Higher rates of limb loss in CLTI patients |
5, 8 |
Abbreviations: AAA, abdominal aortic aneurysm; ACS, American College of Surgeons; CLTI, chronic limb threatening ischemia; COVER, COVID-19 Vascular Service Study; COVID-19, coronavirus disease 2019; ED, emergency department; US, United States; VASCC Vascular Surgery COVID-19 Collaborative; VS, vascular surgery.
Themes: (1) VS case triage system; (2) emergence of global collaborative VS research groups; (3) global surveys on VS practice; (4) regional surveys on VS practice; (5) institutional changes in VS practice; (6) use of endovascular techniques and locoregional anesthesia; (7) delayed presentation of VS conditions; and (8) outcomes in patients with VS conditions.