Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2022 Feb 14.
Published in final edited form as: Nanoscale. 2021 Feb 4;13(6):3374–3411. doi: 10.1039/d0nr08353d

Table 2.

Summary of PC Pathogen Inactivation Studies.

Ref Pathogen Species (Type) Materials Composition Illumination Type and Power or Power Density as Reported In vitro LRV / Inactivation time Additional Remarks
[151] E. coli (Gram −) Ag NPs Unspecified visible light source 1–2 / 2 hours Inhibition of biofilm formation
[152] P. aeruginosa (Gram −) Au NPs Unspecified visible light source - Inhibition of biofilm formation
[131] E. coli (Gram −)

S. aureus (Gram +)
Ag NPs / CuO AM 1.5G light, 100 mW/cm2 7 / 10 min Light-induced Ag+ release
[165] MRSA (Gram +)

P. aeruginosa, E. coli (Gram −)
Ag/TiO2/polymer 405 nm LED, 7 W 5 / 2 hours
[160] Vibrio cholerae (Gram −) Ag/ZnO Sun light > 6 / 50 min
[132] E. coli (Gram −) Ag/AgBr/TiO2 Visible light (> 420 nm), 25.3 mW/cm2 7 / 110 min
[157] E. coli (Gram −) Ag/TiO2 Fluorescent lamp with visible light (> 400 nm), 40 W 6 / 2 hours
[162] E. coli (Gram −) Ag/Bi2S3/SnIn4S8 Xe lamp (> 420 nm) > 7 / 4 hours
[161] E. coli (Gram −) Ag/graphitic C3N4 Xe lamp, 300 W > 7 / 90 min
[156] Bacteriophage MS2 (non-enveloped virus) Ag/TiO2 UV lamp (350 nm), 2.5 mW/cm2 > 6 / 2 min
[158] E. coli (Gram −) Ag/ZnO Sun light, 0.753 kW/m2 5.7 / 60 min
[25] E. coli (Gram −) Ag/BiVO4 Xe lamp (> 420 nm), 300 W 7 / 3 hours
[166] E. coli (Gram −)

Pichia Pastoris (yeast)
Ag/TiO2 Mercury vapor lamp (315–400 nm), 64 W/m2 7–8 / 45 min

8 / 60 min
[90][91] E. coli (Gram −)

Bacteriophage f2 (non-enveloped virus)
Cu/TiO2 nanofibers Xe lamp, 100 mW/cm2 > 6 / 240 min

> 5 / 240 min
[163] E. coli (Gram −) Ag/AgBr/reduced graphene oxide Xe lamp, 0.383 W/cm2 6–7 / 20 min
[164] E. coli (Gram −) Ag/AgX/CNTs Xe lamp, 60 mW/cm2 7–8 / 40 min