Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2022 Feb 14.
Published in final edited form as: Nanoscale. 2021 Feb 4;13(6):3374–3411. doi: 10.1039/d0nr08353d

Table 3.

Summary of Studies on Plasmonic Photothermal Pathogen Inactivation.

Ref Pathogen Species Material Illumination Type and Power or Power Density as Reported ΔT in aqueous medium / Illumination time In vitro LRV / Inactivation time Additional Remarks
[179] E. coli (Gram −) rGO-PEG-Au NRs 700–820 nm, 100 fs, 80 MHz, 8 W/cm2 49 °C / 10 min 7 / 10 min
[187] E. coli (Gram −)

S. aureus (Gram +)
Ag nanoclusters / rGO 808 nm CW laser, 2 W/cm2 15 °C / 5 min > 2
[188][182] E. coli (Gram −)

B. Subtilis, Exiguobacterium (Gram +)
Nanoporous Au disks 785 nm CW laser, 0.085 W/mm2 75 °C / 30 s > 1 / 30 s
[119] MRSA (Gram +) Ag NRs / TBO 808 nm CW laser, 3.1 W/cm2 48 °C / 40 min 1 / 25 min Also sustains PDCT inactivation
[87] E. coli (Gram −)

S. aureus (Gram +)
Pd@Ag nanosheets 808 nm CW laser, 0.5 W/cm2 19 °C / 10 min 7 / 10 min
[189] E. coli (Gram −)

S. aureus (Gram +)
Au NRs graphitic nanocapsules 808 nm CW laser, 2 W/cm2 43.3 °C / 10 min 1–2 / 10 min
[184] MRSA (Gram +) DNA aptamer functionalized Au NRs 808 nm CW laser, 1.1 W/cm2 29.2 °C / 30 s 1–2 / 2 min
[185] E. coli (Gram −) Ag / Au Nanoplates 808 nm CW laser, 1 W/cm2 ∼50 °C / 5 min In vivo treatment of E. coli-induced infection in mice
[180] E. coli (Gram −) Ag / ZnO / rGO Xe lamp, 0.45 W/cm2 25 °C / 30 min 7 / 30 min
[181] E. coli (Gram −) Ag / MnO2 Xe lamp, 0.5 W/cm2 36 °C / 30 min 7.11 / 10 min
[139] S. aureus (Gram +)

E. coli (Gram −)
Ag NPs @ AgCl / hydrogel Xe lamp, 0.2 W/cm2 32.8 °C / 10 min 3.5 / 10 min

3.0 / 10 min
In vivo treatment of S. aureus-induced infection in rats; also sustains PDCT inactivation
[186] Acinetobacter baumannii (Gram −) Ag NPs / TiO2 Xe lamp (> 420 nm) 17 °C / 185 s 1–2 / 30 min
[134][183] Bacteriophage MS2 (non-enveloped virus)

Bacteriophage PR772 (non-enveloped virus)

E. coli (Gram −)
Au NRs / carbon black composite Sun light simulator, 100 mW/cm2 18 °C / 30 min 1.3 / 90 min

1.6 / 90 min

5 / 90 min
Ph otothermal disinfection device