Table 2.
Authors | Year | No. of patients | No. of readers | Pulse sequences | Sensitivity | Specificity | Inter-observer agreement |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Before neoadjuvant therapy | |||||||
Smith [22] | 2008 | 142 | 1 | T2WI | 0.62 | 0.88 | NA |
Koh [23] | 2008 | 79 | NA | T2WI | 1.00 | 0.89 | NA |
Sohn [24] | 2015 | 447 | NA | T2WI | 0.282 | 0.94 | NA |
Jhaveri [26] | 2016 | 49 | 2 | T2WI, CE-T1WI |
T2WI alone: 0.43–0.50 T2WI + CE-T1WI: 0.57 |
T2WI alone: 0.96–1.00 T2WI + CE-T1WI: 0.96 |
T2WI alone: 0.828 T2WI + CE-T1WI: 0.858 |
Liu [27] | 2016 | 183 | 2 | T2WI | 0.617 | 0.820 | 0.780 |
Yu [28] | 2016 | 86 | 2 | T2WI | 0.583 | 0.920 | 0.803 |
Lee [29] | 2018 | 200 | 2 | T2WI | 0.9048 | 0.4114 | 0.801 |
Liu [30] | 2016 | 59 | 2 | T2WI, CE-T1WI |
T2WI alone: 0.500–0.722 CE-T1WI alone: 0.556 T2WI + CE-T1WI:0.778–0.833 |
T2WI alone: 0.732–0.780 CE-T1WI alone: 0.659–0.683 T2WI + CE-T1WI: 0.732–0.756 |
T2WI alone: 0.603 CE-T1WI alone: 0.216 T2WI + CE-T1WI: 0.413 |
Ahn [32] | 2019 | 79 | 2 | T2WI, DWI | T2WI alone: 0.80–0.85 | T2WI alone: 0.53–0.75 | T2WI alone: 0.704 |
T2WI + DWI: 0.90 | T2WI + DWI: 0.54–0.66 | T2WI + DWI: 0.611 | |||||
Bae [31] | 2019 | 147 | 3 | T2WI, CE-T1WI | T2WI + CE-T1WI: 0.720–0.840 | T2WI + CE-T1WI: 0.454–0.856 | T2WI + CE-T1WI: 0.376–0.693 |
Fornell-Perez [45] | 2020 | 54 | 3 | T2WI, DWI |
T2WI alone: 0.571 T2WI + DWI: 0.476 |
T2WI alone: 0.759 T2WI + DWI: 0.872 |
T2WI alone: 0.483 T2WI + DWI: 0.438 |
After neoadjuvant therapy | |||||||
Jhaveri [26] | 2016 | 20 | 2 | T2WI, CE-T1WI | T2WI alone: 0.29 | T2WI alone: 0.95–1.00 | T2WI alone: 0.781 |
T2WI + CE-T1WI: 0.43–0.57 | T2WI + CE-T1WI: 0.95 | T2WI + CE-T1WI: 0.604 | |||||
Lee [29] | 2018 | 200 | 2 | T2WI | 0.7619 | 0.7975 | 0.736 |
Fornell-Perez [45] | 2020 | 46 | 3 | T2WI, DWI |
T2WI alone: 0.667 T2WI + DWI: 0.778 |
T2WI alone: 0.829 T2WI + DWI: 0.915 |
T2WI alone: 0.372 T2WI + DWI: 0.361 |
Bae [31] | 2019 | 75 | 3 | T2WI, CE-T1WI | T2WI + CE-T1WI: 0.667–0.792 | T2WI + CE-T1WI: 0.490–0.922 | T2WI + CE-T1WI: 0.383–0.693 |
CE-T1WI, contrast enhanced T1-weighted image; DWI, diffusion-weighted image; T2WI, T2-weighted image