Table 1.
Concept 1 | Concept 2 | Concept 3a | Concept 3bi | Concept 3bii | Concept 4 | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Key concepts | Population: children aged 4–11 | Setting: primary school or equivalent | Intervention: Mobile device | Intervention: Subject | Intervention: subject | Study design |
Free text terms/natural language terms |
Age 4, 5… (up to 11) 4 year old… (up to Child Boy Girl AND school class Classroom |
Primary school Elementary school Junior school Kindergarten Grade 1, grade 2, and so forth. 1st grade, 2nd grade, and so forth. First grade, second grade, and so forth |
iPad tablet Tablet computer* touchscreen Handheld device Portable computer e‐book OR ebook e‐reader OR ereader electronic storybook Game* console Digital game Smartphone smart phone Mobile phoneiPhone Cell* phone Portable cell* phone Mobile telephone Cell* telephone Personal Digital Assistant PDA* Transportable Cell* Phone 1:1 computing Online instruction M‐learning |
Literacy Reading Writing Handwriting Transcription Verbal reasoning Critical thinking Comprehension Notetaking Composition Listening skills Phonics Phonemic awareness Alphabet Spell* Vocabulary Punctuation Grammar Reading fluency Speaking skills Spoken language Critical literacy Literacy skills |
numeracy number* math* arithmetic sums calculat* addition adding subtract* multiplication division count* algebra fractions decimal* geometr* statistic* “problem solving” “shape sort*” “mathematical literacy” “quantitative literacy” |
RCT Randomised Control Trial Randomised Controlled Trial Randomized Control Trial Randomized controlled Trial Placebo Random allocation Random assignment single/double/triple blind |
Subject terms/headings and/or controlled vocabulary (from British Education index) |
Elementary education Elementary schools Elementary education research Primary education Primary schools First grade (education) [repeat for all grades] School children Elementary school teaching Primary school teaching Computers in elementary education |
Educational technology Computers in Education Educational innovations Internet in Education Computer Assisted Instruction Digital Technology Education‐Computer applications Computer games Educational games Handheld devices Technology integration |
Reading Achievement Literacy Education Reading comprehension Reading achievement English language education in primary schools Computers and literacy Literacy research Literacy program*Reading (elementary) Reading (primary) Reading enrichment Reading mobile apps |
Mathematics achievement Numerical calculations Mathematics instruction Mathematics education (primary) Mathematics education (elementary) Mathematics education (primary) Mathematics education (preschool) Games in mathematics education Study and teaching of numeracy Mathematical ability |
RCT Randomised Control Trial Randomised Controlled Trial Randomized Control Trial Randomized controlled Trial |
|
Free text search strings (tested through ERIC on EBSCO) | AB (“Age* 4" OR “age* 5" OR “age* 6” OR “age* 7” or “age* 8” OR “age* 9” OR “age* 10” OR “age* 11” OR “4 year* old*” OR “5 year* old*” OR “6 year* old*” OR “7 year* old*” OR “8 year* old*” OR “9 year* old*” OR “10 year* old*” OR “11 year* old*” OR Child* OR boy OR girl) AND (school OR class* OR classroom) | AB “Primary school” OR “Elementary school” OR “Junior school” OR Kindergarten OR “grade 1” OR “grade 2” OR “grade 3” OR “grade 4” OR “grade 5” OR “First Grade” OR “Second Grade” OR “Third Grade” OR “Fourth Grade” OR “Fifth Grade” OR “1st grade” OR “2nd grade” OR “3rd Grade” OR “4th Grade” OR “5th grade“ | AB iPad OR tablet OR “tablet computer*” OR touchscreen OR app OR “handheld device” OR “handheld computer” OR “PDA” OR “personal digital assistant” OR “portable computer” OR '"e‐book” OR ebook OR “e‐reader” OR ereader OR “electronic storybook” OR “game* console” OR “digital game” OR smartphone OR “smart phone” OR “mobile phone” OR iPhone OR “cell* phone” OR “portable cell* phone” OR “mobile telephone” OR “cell* telephone” OR “transportable Cell* Phone” OR “1:1 comput*” OR “online instruction” OR “mobile learn*” OR M‐learning | AB Literacy OR Reading OR Writing OR Handwriting OR Transcription OR “Verbal reasoning” OR “Critical thinking” OR Comprehension OR Notetaking OR Composition OR “Listening skills” OR Phonic* OR “phonemic awareness” OR Alphabet OR Spell* OR Vocabulary OR Punctuation OR Grammar OR “Reading fluency” OR “Speaking skills” OR “Spoken language” OR “Critical literacy” OR “literacy skills" | AB numeracy OR number* OR math* OR arithmetic OR sums OR calculat* OR addition OR adding OR subtract* OR multiplication OR division OR count* OR algebra OR fractions OR decimal* OR geometr* OR statistic* OR “problem solving” OR “shape sort*” OR “mathematical literacy” OR “quantitative literacy” | AB RCT OR “randomised control trial” OR “randomised controlled trial” OR “randomized control trial” OR “randomized controlled trial” OR randomised OR randomized OR placebo* OR (random* AND (allocat* OR assign*)OR (blind* AND (single OR double OR treble OR triple)) |