Skip to main content
. 2019 Sep 29;15(3):e1045. doi: 10.1002/cl2.1045
Study Outcome N Nt Nc Unit of analysis TREATeff Effect size Variance Lower bound Upper bound
Xu et al. 2010—China—SLCP Total agricultural income with subsidy 345 264 81 Household ATE 0.3298 0.0163 0.0796 0.5800
Xu et al. 2010—China—SLCP Husbandry income includes both sales income and own consumption, valued at market prices. 345 264 81 Household ATE 0.2932 0.0163 0.0433 0.5431
Xu et al. 2010—China—SLCP Cropping with subsidy (Cropping income consists of total crop production valued at average village market price, net of materials and hired labor costs). 345 264 81 Household ATE 0.6568 0.0168 0.4031 0.9106
Xu et al. 2010—China—SLCP Cropping before subsidy (Cropping income consists of total crop production valued at average village market price, net of materials and hired labor costs). 345 264 81 Household ATE 0.6620 0.0168 0.4082 0.9158
Yao et al. 2010—China—SLCP Animal husbandry income(income from raising livestock, predominantly goats) 600 492 108 Household ATE −0.2834 0.0114 −0.4923 −0.0745
Uchida et al. 2007—China—SLCP Other agricultural income per capita (yuan) 339 253 86 Household ATT 0.4135 0.0158 0.1669 0.6601
Duan et al. 2015—China—SLCP Forest income 375 283 92 Household ATE 0.0659 0.0144 −0.1694 0.3012
Zhang et al. 2013—China—PLDL Agricultural income, % 723 394 329 Household ATT −0.4670 0.0057 −0.6154 −0.3187
Jack & Santos 2017—Malawi—ICRAF Total income from crop sales—auction group 319 205 114 Household ITT 0.2079 0.0137 −0.0217 0.4374
Liu et al. 2014—China—SLCP Land‐based income (RL)—SLCP + NFPP 1,458 729 729 Household ATE −0.0200 0.0030 −0.1200 0.0800
Liang et al. 2012—China—SLCP On‐farm income (income from crops and forests (fruits from trees). 442 221 221 Household ATE −0.1700 0.0090 −0.3600 0.0200
Liang et al. 2012—China—SLCP On‐farm income (income from crops and forests (fruits from trees). 366 183 183 Household ATE −0.2900 0.0110 −0.5000 −0.0900
Liang et al. 2012—China—SLCP On‐farm income (income from crops and forests (fruits from trees). 127 63.5 63.5 Household ATE −0.0900 0.0320 −0.4400 0.2600
Liu et al. 2014—China—DCPT programme Land‐based income (RL) 1458 729 729 Household ATE −0.0400 0.0030 −0.1500 0.0600