Table 3.
Reference and year | Country | Study design | Participants | Tumor category | Auricular acupoints | Materials | Interventions | Antiemetics | Outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Lou et al., 2011 [20] | China | Parallel RCT | 50 | Various cancers | Shenmen, stomach, subcortex, spleen, sympathesis, ear center | Cowherb seeds | AA + antiemetics | Granisetron | (i); (iii); (vi) |
Liu et al., 2011 [19] | China | Parallel RCT | 127 | Lung cancer | Lung, stomach, Shenmen, spleen, diazoma, subcortex, large intestine | Cowherb seeds | AA + antiemetics | Granisetron/ondansetron | (v); (Vi) |
Chao et al., 2012 [13] | Taiwan, China | Crossover placebo RCT | 10 | Na | Shenmen, stomach, cardia, sympathesis, subcortex, | Seeds | AA + antiemetics | Granisetron/ondansetron | (ii); (iv) |
Jiang et al., 2012 [21] | China | Parallel RCT | 85 | Na | Stomach, Shenmen, spleen, sympathesis, large intestine | Cowherb seeds | AA + antiemetics | Granisetron | (iii); (vi) |
Hong et al., 2014 [22] | China | Parallel RCT | 120 | Breast cancer | Stomach, Shenmen, spleen, sympathesis, subcortex | Cowherb seeds | AA | Ondansetron | (i); (iii); (vi) |
Li et al., 2014 [24] | China | Parallel RCT | 91 | Lung cancer | Stomach, Shenmen, sympathesis | Cowherb seeds | AA + antiemetics | Ondansetron + DXM | (v) |
Hu et al. 2014 [23] | China | Parallel RCT | 70 | Various cancers | M: stomach, Shenmen, sympathesis; A: spleen, liver | Cowherb seeds | AA + antiemetics | Tropisetron | (v) |
Eghbali et al., 2016 [33] | Iran | Crossover RCT | 96 | Breast cancer | Point zero, stomach, brainstem, Shenmen, cardia | Seeds | AA + standard medications | Standard medications | (ii); (iv) |
Peng et al., 2016 [16] | China | Parallel RCT | 52 | Cervical/endometrial/ovarian cancer | M: Shenmen, diazoma, stomach, cardia, occiput, subcortex, esophagus; A: sympathesis, spleen, liver | Cowherb seeds | AA + antiemetics | Ondansetron + DXM | (i); (iii); (iv); (vi) |
Wei et al., 2016 [25] | China | Parallel RCT | 90 | Na | M: stomach, Shenmen, spleen; A: liver | Cowherb seeds | AA + antiemetics | Azasetron | (v) |
Guo et al., 2017 [26] | China | Parallel RCT | 64 | Gastric cancer | Shenmen, sympathesis, stomach, large intestine, small intestine, Ashi point | Cowherb seeds | AA + antiemetics | Granisetron | (v) |
Liu, 2017 [17] | China | Parallel RCT | 70 | Cervical/endometrial/ovarian cancer | Stomach, liver, small intestine, Shenmen, endocrine | Cowherb seeds | AA | Ondansetron | (i); (iii); (iv); (vi) |
Wang et al., 2017 [27] | China | Parallel RCT | 52 | Bone cancer | Stomach, subcortex, ear center, Shenmen, spleen, sympathesis | Cowherb seeds | AA + antiemetics | Ondansetron | (ii); (iii); (iv) |
Wu et al., 2018 [28] | China | Parallel RCT | 86 | Lung cancer | M: stomach, cardia, subcortex A: liver, sympathesis | Cowherb seeds | AA + antiemetics | Ondansetron | (Iii) |
Yang, 2018 [18] | China | Parallel RCT | 67 | Breast cancer | M: stomach, Shenmen, subcortex, sympathesis; A: liver, spleen | Cowherb seeds | AA + antiemetics | Ondansetron | (i) (iii) (v) |
Chen et al., 2019 [29] | China | Parallel RCT | 89 | Colorectal cancer | Sympathesis, Shenmen, spleen, stomach | Cowherb seeds | AA + antiemetics | Azasetron + DXM | (v) |
Nan et al., 2019 [30] | China | Parallel RCT | 60 | Bone cancer | Stomach, ear center, sympathesis, spleen, Shenmen, subcortex | Cowherb seeds | AA + antiemetics | Ondansetron | (iii); (v) |
Wen et al., 2019 [31] | China | Parallel RCT | 100 | Various cancers | Shenmen, stomach, spleen | Cowherb seeds | AA + antiemetics | Azasetron | (v) |
Wang et al., 2020 [32] | China | Parallel RCT | 80 | Cervical cancer | Shenmen, sympathesis, stomach, subcortex, spleen | Cowherb seeds | AA + antiemetics | Ondansetron | (v) |
RCT: randomized controlled trial; Na: not available; M: main points; A: adjunct points; AA: auricular Acupressure; DXM: dexamethasone. Outcomes: (i) nausea relief efficiency; (ii) nausea frequency; (iii) vomiting relief efficiency; (iv) vomiting frequency; (v) overall efficiency of CINV; and (vi) incidence of adverse reactions.