Table 2.
Observed means | ESs | Treatment vs. control ESs | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Pre | Post |
Follow-up
(3 months from week 1) |
Pre to post | Pre to follow-up | Pre to post | |
PHQ-9 | ||||||
Treatment | 11.95 (6.03) | 7.63 (6.05) | 6.73 (3.55) | 0.72* | 1.30* | 0.78* |
Control | 12.78 (6.76) | 11.84 (6.30) | NA | 0.14 | NA | NA |
Control (cross-over) | 11.84 (6.30) | 7.83 (7.27) | 6.83 (7.42) | 0.59 | 0.73 | NA |
Treatment response | 12.20 (5.66) | 7.71 (6.47) | NA | 0.74* | 0.95* | 0.51 |
Control response | 10.62 (6.33) | 9.97 (5.94) | NA | 0.11 | NA | NA |
GAD-7 | ||||||
Treatment | 8.50 (5.20) | 5.31 (4.53) | 4.27 (4.05) | 0.65 | 0.91* | 0.27 |
Control Control (cross-over) |
11.47 (6.74) 10.53 (5.76) | 10.53 (5.76) 5.83 (5.02) |
NA 5.78 (4.47) |
0.15 0.87* |
NA 1.05* |
NA NA |
Treatment response Control response |
9.44 (5.49) 8.56 (6.36) | 5.54 (4.66) 8.23 (5.97) |
NA NA |
0.77* 0.05 |
0.97* NA |
0.33 NA |
WSAS | ||||||
Treatment | 15.32 (10.20) | 9.31 (8.75) | 9.00 (8.81) | 0.63 | 0.66 | 0.36 |
Control Control (cross-over) |
17.37 (8.91) 17.15 (10.26) | 17.15 (10.26) 13.42 (10.24) |
NA 12.38 (11.78) |
0.02 0.37 |
NA 0.54 |
NA NA |
Treatment Response Control Response |
16.17 (10.14) 13.69 (9.31) | 11.07 (9.46) 14.17 (10.40) |
NANA | 0.52 −0.05 |
0.59 NA |
0.23 NA |
K10 | ||||||
Treatment | 23.91 (8.04) | 19.44 (8.86) | 18.27 (6.48) | 0.53 | 0.77* | 0.66 |
Control Control (cross-over) |
27.37 (9.96) 25.68 (10.03) |
25.68 (10.03) 20.80 (11.24) |
NA16.80 (11.22) | 0.17 0.46* |
NA0.73* | NA NA |
Treatment Response Control Response |
24.73 (8.95) 24.15 (10.03) |
20.10 (9.93) 23.96 (9.42) |
NA NA |
0.49* 0.02 |
0.74* NA |
0.30 NA |
Standard deviations are shown in parentheses. Pre, Pre-treatment; Post, Post-treatment; Follow-up, Three-month follow-up; PHQ-9, Patient Health Questionnaire 9-item; GAD-7, Generalised Anxiety Disorder 7-item.
indicates statistically significant results.