Table 3.
Study | Target | Dosage or time in VRa and VR hardware | Task details | Outcome measures | Results | Adverse effects and potential issues | Eligibility criteria |
Banville and Nolin [111] | Prospective memory and executive functions | Time in VR not reported; HMDb (eMagin Z800) with head tracker | Non-VR task: prospective memory assessment based on Rivermead Behavioral Memory Test; VR task: virtual prospective memory tasks completed in a virtual city (included visiting apartments and selecting an apartment to live in) | Non-VR: correct actions, time to complete, and whether prompting was required; VR: prospective memory score, precision score, time to complete, success in task, and IPQc | Participants could be classified as having a TBId by performance on each task. TBI participants were significantly less precise with prospective memory VR tasks (P=.02) and took more time to perform VR tasks (P=.008) than controls | SSQe completed; no reported cybersickness; SSQ scores did not differ between groups | Inclusion criteria: confirmed TBI |
Cikajlo et al [101] | Stress and anxiety | 8 sessions (25 minutes per session, once weekly); Samsung Galaxy X7 mobile phone mounted to HMD (Samsung Gear VR) | Mindfulness stress reduction program conducted by an instructor (eg, self-meditation and group discussions in various VEsf such as a mountain view or a room with a fireplace) | MAAS,g SWLS,h MMSEi (TBI only), session and task ratings, and head motion | Slight improvement in MAAS and SWLS scores (TBI group>non-TBI group); one participant increased MMSE (not reported for others); task ratings: simple to use and interesting; varying head motions | Potential for overheating of mobile phones (sessions were, therefore, limited to 30 minutes) | Inclusion criteria: mild or no cognitive impairment and able to understand instructions; exclusion criteria: high diopters, astigmatism, and wore glasses |
Gamito et al [102] | Working memory and attention | 10 sessions (5 minutes each session); HMD (eMagin Z800) | Activities included performing ADLsj in the VE (eg, breakfast, navigating to and from a supermarket, and buying items) | PASATk and completion time of each task | Significant increase in correct responses between initial and final PASAT scores (P<.05) | Not reported | Inclusion criteria: diagnosed with a TBI 3-12 months prior, clinical deficit in memory and attention, and aged 18-60 years; exclusion criteria: a previous psychiatric disorder that may impact memory and attention and neurological diseases |
Ma et al [103] | Balance and functional mobility | 5 sessions (12 trials, with a 1- to 2-minute break in between); breaks were decided by the participant. Samsung Galaxy X7 mobile phone mounted to HMD (Samsung Gear VR) | Standing balance exercises in a VE with traffic lights, street crossing and traffic island, night and day versions, moving cars, and static buildings | DGI,l mini-BEST,m DHI,n ABC,o GROC,p and patient-specific functional scale (self-scoring street crossing and multitasking abilities) | Improvements in DGI, mini-BEST, DHI, GROC, and patient-specific functional scale | Not reported | Not reported |
Robitaille et al [112] | Executive functions | Time in VR not reported; HMD (piSight 166-43) with head tracking and body tracking (MoCap) | Exploration of a simulated military patrol scene in a village with different conditions and obstacles to navigate (eg, fences, wires, beams, and avatars) | PQ,q SUS,r errors, walking speed and fluidity, and obstacle clearance | TBI group walked faster and had slightly greater obstacle clearances. Significant difference in walking fluidity between groups for two hostile blocks (P=.046). Moderate to high presence scores on SUS and PQ | SSQ completed: 1 participant with TBI and 1 control participant reported slight headaches | Inclusion criteria (TBI): mild TBI; inclusion criteria (controls): no known TBI or other neurological or musculoskeletal issues |
aVR: virtual reality.
bHMD: head-mounted display.
cIPQ: Igroup Presence Questionnaire.
dTBI: traumatic brain injury.
eSSQ: Simulator Sickness Questionnaire.
fVE: virtual environment.
gMAAS: Mindfulness Attention Awareness Scale.
hSWLS: Satisfaction With Life Scale.
iMMSE: Mini-Mental State Examination.
jADL: activities of daily living.
kPASAT: Paced Auditory Serial Addition Task.
lDGI: Dynamic Gait Index.
mmini-BEST: Mini-Balance Evaluation System Test.
nDHI: Dizziness Handicap Index.
oABC: Activities Balance Confidence Scale.
pGROC: Global Rating of Change.
qPQ: Presence Questionnaire.
rSUS: Slater-Usoh-Steed Questionnaire.