Table 1.
Reference | mHealth | Condition | Participants type | Participants # | Study design | Outcome measure | Finding |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Yigezu et al.48 | Mobile-based VCT | HIV VCT | VCT attendants | 144,267 | Cross-sectional - cost-effectiveness | Effectiveness—cost-effectiveness | Mobile-based VCT costs less than both facility-based and stand-alone VCTs |
Gebremariam et al.49 | SMS | Infant feeding | Parents of child-bearing age | 41 | Cross-sectional | Feasibility, acceptability | Feasible and acceptable option for knowledge sharing and awareness |
Starr et al.50 | mHealth | Post-surgery follow-up | Patients on post-surgery follow-up | 701 | Cohort, prospective | Feasibility | Telephone follow-up after surgery is feasible and valuable |
Jadhav et al.51 | Own mobile phone | Contraceptive | Women of reproductive age | 15,683 | Cross-sectional, retrospective | Effectiveness— Contraceptive uptake | No association between mobile phone ownership and contraceptive uptake |
Bradley et al.52 | Smartphone | Post-surgery follow-up | Patients on post-surgery follow-up | 24 | Cohort | Feasibility | smartphones were low-cost, reliable method to follow-up patient after surgery |
Nesemann et al.53 | Smartphone-CellScope device for conjunctival photograph | Trachomatous inflammation - follicular | Children aged 1–9 yrs | 412 | Cross-sectional | Effectiveness | 84.1% sensitive 97.6% specific |
Tadesse et al.54 | mHealth- based e-Partograph | Obstetric care | Healthcare professionals | 466 | Cross-sectional | Willingness | 46% willing to use mobile-phone for e-Partograph |
Kassa et al.55 | Own mobile phone | Postnatal care | Women in postnatal care | 370 | Cross-sectional | Knowledge, attitude | 3x higher odds of positive attitude to preconception in women who own phone |
Kebede et al.56 | SMS or voice call reminder | Postnatal appointment | Women in postnatal care | 700 | RCT | Effectiveness— Postnatal compliance | 3x higher odds of postnatal compliance in women who received a reminder |
Thomsen et al.57 | mHealth-based Safe Delivery App | Delivery | Healthcare professionals | 56 | Cross-sectional | Usability—user experience | The App improved providers’ delivery knowledge and skills |
Jemere et al.58 | mHealth-based health services | Diabetes | Patients with diabetes | 423 | Cross-sectional | Willingness, access, | 78% had a phone; 71% willing to receive mHealth-based diabetes services |
Habtamu et al.59 |
Smartphone-based Contrast Sensitivity Test ((PeekCS) |
Contrast Sensitivity (CS) | Adults with trachomatous trichiasis | 147 | RCT | Effectiveness | It is repeatable, rapid, accessible and easy to perform CS testing. |
Endebu et al.60 | SMS to support medication adherence | HIV/AIDS |
people living with HIV/AIDS receiving antiretroviral treatment |
420 | Cross-sectional | Feasibility, acceptability | High (90.9%) acceptability of SMS on adherence to antiretroviral therapy |
Quinonez et al.61 | MiGene Family History App | Medical genetics services | Healthcare professionals | 47 | Cross-sectional | Feasibility | The App was useful for the collection and analysis of genetics data. |
Endehabtu et al.62 | SMS-based intervention | Antenatal care | Women in antenatal care | 416 | Cross-sectional | Willingness access, | 36% had smartphones; 71% willing to receive SMS-based antenatal care intervention |
Mengesha et al.63 | mHealth-based HMIS | Data use | Health extension workers | 62 | Cross-sectional | Data quality, user experience | mHealth-based HMIS improved data quality, data flow, patient follow-up. |
Steege et al.64 | mHealth-based data and reminder | TB | Health extension workers | 19 | Cross-sectional | Quality—healthcare delivery | Improved community TB and maternal health service delivery |
Martindale et al.65 | MeasureSMS- morbidity reporting tool | lymphatic filariasis, podoconiosis | Healthcare professionals | 59 | Cross-sectional, comparative | Effectiveness, cost, time | MeasureSMS tool was more effective, 13.7% less costly than paper-based reporting |
Abate et al.66 |
Telepathology Acquiring microscopic images using a smartphone camera |
blood cell count, malaria lab diagnosis | Healthcare professionals | 2 | Cross-sectional | Usability, accuracy | It was fast, cost-effective, and accurate in low resource setting. |
Shiferaw et al.67 | mHealth-based data collection | Maternal health service | Healthcare professionals | 15 | Experimental/ Implementation | Effectiveness | Timely and complete maternal health data |
Atnafu et al.68 | SMS-based data exchange Ap. | Antenatal care | Women on antenatal care | 3240 | RCT | Effectiveness—MCH outcomes | 9% increased deliveries attended by skilled health workers |
Mableson et al.69 | MeasureSMS-Morbidity reporting tool | Lymphatic filariasis (LF) case estimate | People with LF clinical manifestations | 400,000 | Cross-sectional | Usability as a reporting tool | The tool improved survey and reporting of clinical burden of LF |
Medhanyie et al.70 | Smartphones for collecting patient data | Maternal health records | Healthcare professional | 25 | Cross-sectional | Usability | 8% improved data completeness compered with paper records |
Shiferaw et al.71 | Locally customized mHealth App. | Delivery and postnatal care | Women on ANC | 2261 | Cohort | Quality—ANC services utilization | The App improved delivery in health centers, but not ANC visits |
Lund et al.72 |
mHealth safe delivery App (SDA) |
Perinatal and neonatal survival |
Women in active labor, provider |
3777 | RCT | Quality—Perinatal mortality | The SDA nonsignificantly lowered perinatal mortality compared with standard |
Kebede et al.73 | SMS medication reminders | HIV | HIV patients on ART | 415 | Cross-sectional | Willingness, access |
76% owned cellphone 50.9% willing to receive SMS medication reminder |
Medhanyie et al.74 | Smartphone-based data records | Maternal health | Healthcare professionals | 24 | Cross-sectional | Usability | The records were useful for day-to-day maternal healthcare services delivery |
Desta et al.75 | mVedio for behavior change | Maternal and newborn health | Community members | 540 | Cross-sectional. | Effectiveness— Community behavior change | mViedo changed community behavior change on maternal and newborn health in rural Ethiopia |
Little et al.76 | Smartphone open-source health App. | maternal health | Healthcare professionals | 37 | Cohort | Feasibility—Technical needs | Ownership and empowerment are prerequisites for a successful mHealth program |
ANC antenatal care, HMIS health management information systems, LF lymphatic filariasis, MCH maternal and child health, RCT randomized controlled trial, SDA safe delivery app., SMS short message service, VCT voluntary counseling and testing.