Table 1.
Animal study characteristics.
First author publication year | Animals | Treatment | Control | Admin. route | Dose | Dosing | Pain model | Outcome measure | Measurement delay since injection* | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Species | Sex | Age (wk) | Weight (g) | |||||||||
Studies on single ketamine administration (n = 21) | ||||||||||||
Chaplan et al., 19972 | Rat (Sprague-Dawley) | Male | Ketamine | Saline | i.t. | 100 µg | Single | SNL | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 60 min | ||
Christoph et al., 20063 | Rats (Sprague-Dawley) | Male | 170-310 | Ketamine | Saline | i.v. | 4.64 mg/kg | Single | CCI | Paw withdrawal to a cold stimulus | 15 min, 24 h | |
Claudino et al., 20184 | Rat (Wistar) | Male | 200-220 | S-ketamine | Vehicle | i.n. | 1 mg/kg | Single | CION | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 30 min | |
De Vry et al., 20048 | Rat (Wistar) | Male | 180-200 | Ketamine | Vehicle | i.p. | 20 mg/kg | Single | CCI | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 30 min | |
Doncheva et al., 201910 | Rat (Wistar) | Male | 200-220 | Ketamine | Saline | i.p. | 50 mg/kg | Single | CCI | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 60 min | |
Fang 201811 | Rat (Sprague-Dawley) | Male | 180-230 | Ketamine | Saline | i.p. | 10 mg/kg | Single | SNI | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 72 h | |
Hama and Sagen, 201212 | Rat (Sprague-Dawley) | Male | 100-150 | Ketamine | Vehicle | i.t. | 100 µg | Single | SCI | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 90 min | |
Humo et al., 202019 | Mouse (C75BL/6) | Male | 8 | Ketamine | Saline | i.p. | 15 mg/kg | Single | CCI | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 120 min, 24 h | |
Kroin et al., 201922 | Mouse (D1) | Female | 20 | Ketamine | Saline | i.p. | 10 mg/kg | Single | SNI | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 60 min, 72 h | |
Lim et al., 201325 | Mouse (ICR) | Male | 25-30 | Ketamine | Vehicle | i.t. | 100 µg | Single | CCI | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 90 min | |
Mao† et al., 199327 | Rat (Sprague-Dawley) | Male | 400-500 | Ketamine | Saline | i.t. | 23.7 µg | Single | CCI | Paw withdrawal to radiant heat | 30 min | |
M'Dahoma 201428 | Rat (Sprague-Dawley) | Male | 7-8 | 225-250 | Ketamine | Vehicle | i.p. | 50 mg/kg | Single | SCI | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 30 min |
M'Dahoma et al., 201529 | Rat (Sprague-Dawley) | Male | 175-200 | Ketamine | Saline | i.p. | 50 mg/kg | Single | CCI | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 60 min | |
Mehta et al., 201230 | Rat (Wistar) | Male | 180-250 | Ketamine | Control | i.p. | 25 mg/kg | Single | CCI | Paw licking or jump latency on hot plate | 45 min | |
Mei et al., 201032 | Rat (Sprague-Dawley) | Male | 180-200 | S-ketamine | Saline | i.t. | 1000 µg/kg | Single | CCI | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 30 min, 72 h | |
Pan et al., 201840 | Rat (Sprague-Dawley) | Male | 6-7 | 200-250 | Ketamine | Saline | i.p. | 10 mg/kg | Single | SNI | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 72 h |
Qian et al., 199643 | Rat (Sprague-Dawley) | Male | 125-150 | Ketamine | Saline | i.p. | 50 mg/kg | Single | SNL | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 15 min | |
Rodrigues-Filho et al., 200445 | Rat (Wistar) | Male | 250-300 | Ketamine | Saline | i.p. | 25 mg/kg | Single | BPA | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 30 min | |
Sasaki et al., 200847 | Mouse (C57BL/6J) | Female | 6 | Ketamine | Vehicle | i.p. | 50 mg/kg | Single | PHN | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 60 min | |
Truin et al., 201152 | Rat (Sprague-Dawley) | Male | 300-350 | Ketamine | Saline | i.t. | 200 µg | Single | CCI | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 45 min | |
Wang et al., 201153 | Rat (Sprague-Dawley) | Male | 250-300 | Ketamine | Saline | i.p. | 10 mg/kg (1 h), 50 mg/kg (24 h) | Single | SNI | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 1 h, 24 h | |
Multiple ketamine administrations or continuous ketamine infusion (n = 11) | ||||||||||||
Hota et al., 200717 | Rat (Wistar) | Male | 200-250 | Ketamine | Control | Gavage | 2.5 mg/kg | 1 daily dose for 25 days | SNI | Paw licking latency on hot plate | 0 d | |
Huang et al., 200418 | Rat (Sprague-Dawley) | Female | 200-250 | Ketamine | Saline | i.p. | 10 mg/kg | 6 days for 4 weeks | SNL | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 1 d | |
Kwon et al., 201423 | Rat (Sprague-Dawley) | Male | 180-200 | Ketamine | Saline | s.c. | 40 mg/kg per day | 7-day infusion | SNL | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 0 d | |
Mak et al., 201526 | Rat (Wistar) | Male | Ketamine | Control | s.c. | 20 mg/kg per day | 5-day infusion | STZ DN | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 14 d | ||
Mao† et al., 199327 | Rat (Sprague-Dawley) | Male | 400-500 | Ketamine | Saline | i.t. | 23.7 µg | 4 daily doses for 3 days | SNL | Paw withdrawal to radiant heat | 7 days after last dose | |
Mei‡ 2009a,c31 Mei 2009b,d |
Rat (Sprague-Dawley) | Male | 180-200 | S-ketamine | Saline | i.t. i.p. | 100 µg/kg 20 mg/kg | 1 dose/day for 3 or 7 days | SNL | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 0 d | |
Mei et al., 2011a33 | Rat (Sprague-Dawley) | Male | 180-200 | S-ketamine | Saline | i.t. | 300 µg/kg | 1 dose/day for 3 days | SNL | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 0 d | |
Mei et al., 2011b34 | Rat (Sprague-Dawley) | Male | 180-200 | S-ketamine | Saline | i.t. | 300 µg/kg | 1 dose/day for 3 days | SNL | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 0 d | |
Salvat§ et al., 2018a46 Salvat 2018b |
Mouse (6J) | Male | 6 | Ketamine | Saline | i.p. | 15 mg/kg | 2 doses/day for 10 days (0-10 after CCI); 2 doses/day (25-35 days after CCI) | CCI | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 15 d and 34 d | |
Swartjes 201150 | Rat (Sprague-Dawley) | Female | 9 | 230 | Ketamine | Saline | i.v. | 9 mg/kg per day | 5-day infusion | SNI | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 28 d |
Swartjes 201351 | Mouse (C57BL/6) | Female | Ketamine | Vehicle | i.p. | 50 mg/kg | In week 1, every other day 1 dose, followed by weekly dosing in week 2-6 | SNI | Paw withdrawal to a mechanical stimulus | 0 d |
Ketamine is the racemic mixture, S-ketamine is the S-enantiomer of ketamine.
Time points included in the meta-analysis.
Mao et al.27 performed 2 independent comparisons: one comparing a single ketamine administration vs saline and one comparing single multiple administrations vs multiple saline administrations.
Mei et al.33 performed 4 independent comparisons: S-ketamine vs saline administered through the intrathecal route and S-ketamine vs saline administered intraperitoneally with 1 dose per day for 3 and for 7 days.
Salvat et al.46 performed 2 independent comparisons: one comparing ketamine administration on days 0 to 10 after surgery for CCI and one comparing ketamine administered on days 25 to 35 after surgery for CCI.
Neuropathic pain models: BPA, brachial plexus avulsion; CCI, chronic constriction injury; CION, constriction of infraorbital nerve; PHN, postherpetic neuralgia; Route of administration: i.p., intraperitoneal; i.t, intrathecal; i.v, intravenous; i.n, intranasal; s.c, subcutaneous; SNI, spared nerve injury; SNL, spinal nerve ligation; STZ DN, streptozotocin-induced diabetic neuropathy.