Taxonomy |
Unicellular fungi |
Invertebrates, insects |
Invertebrates, roundworms |
Vertebrates, fish |
Vertebrates, mammals |
Vertebrates, mammals |
Vertebrates, mammals |
Life span |
From several days to 2 weeks |
About 2 month |
15–25 days |
Max. 2 years. |
10–15 years |
10–13 years |
5–40 years for different species |
The presence and complexity of the nervous system |
Absent |
The presence of various types of glial and neuronal cells (including dopaminergic), a blood–brain barrier, motor neurons, and interneurons |
The presence of 302 nerve cells, which have been characterized in detail regarding their function and synaptic contacts using dopamine, serotonin, glutamate, acetylcholine, and GABA as neurotransmitters |
The brain consists of three sections (forebrain, midbrain, and hindbrain) and is separated from the remainder of the body by the blood–brain barrier. Dopaminergic neurons were found in the posterior tuberculum, which can be considered as an analog of the substantia nigra in mammals. |
The high similarity of the brain structure between humans and minipigs, as well as the large size of the substantia nigra and striatum in minipigs |
The high similarity of the brain structure between humans and dogs, as well as the large size of the substantia nigra and striatum |
The high similarity of the brain structure between humans and primates, as well as the large size of the substantia nigra and striatum |
Possibility to study motor behavior |
Absent |
Climbing activity, pattern of movement, spontaneous locomotor activity |
The analysis of worm mobility after starvation: “basal slowing response” and “enhanced slowing response”, Chemotaxis, area-restricted search behavior, swim-to-crawl transition, Dauer-dependent behavior, mechanosensory responses, fecundity, and rate of defecation. |
Deficits in evoked swimming response (bradykinesia) Decrease in total distance moved and swimming velocity (bradykinesia) Increase in number and duration of freezing episodes (dyskinesia). |
Analysis of motor behavior: walking test, Hurdle test, open field locomotor activity |
Locomotor activity in open field, walking test. |
Parkinson’s disease rating scale (PRDS) for primates. |
Simplicity and cost |
+ (The most simple and inexpensive) |
+ + |
+ + |
+ + + + |
+ + + + + + |
+ + + + + + |
+ + + + + + + + + + (The most difficult and expensive) |
Genetic models
|
Genome sequencing and annotation |
YES |
YES |
YES |
YES |
YES |
YES |
YES |
Similarity to the human genome |
LOW |
LOW |
LOW |
LIMITED |
HIGH |
HIGH |
HIGH |
Existence of genetic models |
Exists |
Exists |
Exists |
Exists |
Exists, but not widespread |
A natural mutation in ATP13A2 gene |
NO |
The main genes studied, homologous to human |
SNCA, LRRK2, PRKN, PINK1, PARK7, VPS35, EIF4G1, ATP13A2
|
SNCA, LRRK2, PRKN, PINK1, PARK7, VPS35, GBA
|
SNCA, LRRK2, PINK1, PRKN, PARK7, ATP13A2
|
SNCA, LRRK2, PRKN, PINK1, ATP13A2
|
SNCA, PINK1/ PARK7/PRKN
|
ATP13A2
|
NO |
Methods |
knockout, knockdown, and overexpression, transgenic (mutant) animals |
knockout, knockdown, and overexpression, transgenic (mutant) animals |
knockout, knockdown, and overexpression, transgenic (mutant) animals |
knockout, knockdown, and overexpression, transgenic (mutant) animals; the technology based on morpholino antisense oligonucleotides. |
knockout, transgenic (mutant) animals |
A natural mutation |
NO |
Collection of mutant lines of animals |
Yeast Insertional Mutant Collection |
The presence of a large collection of fruit fly lines with various mutations. |
The presence of a large collection of mutant nematode lines |
The presence of collections of D. rerio lines with various mutations |
Absent |
Absent |
Absent |
Application area |
Analysis of selected genes / proteins associated with the development of the disease. Primary screening for new drugs. |
Analysis of selected genes / proteins associated with the development of the disease |
Analysis of molecular mechanisms of neurodegeneration associated with genes of monogenic forms of Parkinson’s disease |
Analysis of molecular mechanisms of neurodegeneration associated with genes of monogenic forms of Parkinson’s disease; search for genes associated with neuroprotection |
Comprehensive molecular biological and biochemical analysis; positron emission tomography analysis of brain structures, to monitor the development of neurodegeneration and changes in the nervous system, to correct neurodegenerative changes |
Comprehensive molecular biological and biochemical analysis; a study of possible microbiome involvement in neurodegeneration |
NO |
Toxicity models
|
Existence |
NO |
Exists, but not widespread |
Exists |
Exists |
Exists |
NO |
Exists |
Toxins |
NO |
The rotenone and MPTP |
6-hydroxydopamine, MPTP, paraquat, and rotenone |
6-hydroxydopamine, MPTP, paraquat, and rotenone |
6-hydroxydopamine, MPTP |
NO |
MPTPSNCA
|
Methods |
NO |
Addition of a toxin into the food |
Addition of a toxin into the food |
Intraperitoneal administration or addition of a toxin into the water |
Unilateral injection of the toxin into the nigrostriatal pathway, a micropump-based chronic continuous MPTP administration |
NO |
Acute and chronic MPTP administration. SNCA as pure fibrillar protein or AV-based expression cassette |
Application area |
NO |
Toxic models in the future can be used to search for new antiparkinsonian drugs |
Search for new toxins that damage dopaminergic neurons; Analysis of biologically active substances; Study of microbiome |
Screening for compounds with neuroprotective activity; Assessment of the potential neurotoxicity of normal metabolites, new pesticides, and other newly synthesized chemical compounds |
Positron emission tomography analysis of brain structures for monitoring of the development of neurodegeneration, changes in the nervous system, and correction of neurodegenerative changes; the analysis of new therapeutic approaches for PD |
NO |
Development of new treatments for Parkinson’s disease associated with the use of deep brain stimulation, transplantation of neuronal cells into the substantia nigra and striatum, and for testing newly developed drugs in the last stages of preclinical studies |
Advantages and disadvantages
|
Advantages |
Simple system. The ability to obtain various mutations in genes associated with the development of the disease. Possibility of studying protein-protein interactions, searching for new candidate disease genes. Rapid initial screening of new potential neuroprotective drugs |
A relatively simple and well-established system. The presence of large collections of mutant lines. Possibility of using both genetic and toxic models. The presence of a well-studied nervous system. There are dopaminergic neurons. Short lifespan. Possibility to study the relationship between aging and neurodegeneration |
Ability to use a wide range of genetic and toxic models. Well-characterized nervous system, presence of neurons of different energies. Possibility of analyzing motor behavior. Short lifespan and the ability to analyze neurodegenerative changes in animals of different ages. Ease of maintenance and reproduction, low cost. |
Ability to use a wide range of genetic and toxic models. Sufficiently high homology with the human genome, there are orthologs for most of the genes associated with the development of PD. A detailed description of the nervous system, the presence of neurons of different energies. Possibility to analyze motor behavior. |
The high similarity of metabolism in general and organization of the nervous system to human analogs. Possibility of visualization of substantia nigra during PET scanning. Possibility of using toxic and genetic models. Possibility of testing antiparkinsonian drugs and other therapies. |
Natural mutations in the genes of familial forms of PD, which make it possible to study manifestations in ontogenesis. |
Possibility to analyze the clinical phenotype as close as possible to the clinical phenotype of PD in humans. Development of protocols for new methods of therapy on animals as close to humans as possible. |
Disadvantages |
Unicellular organism. The nervous system is completely absent. There are no orthologs for a number of genes that are fundamentally important for PD, primarily, orthologs of the synuclein gene. |
Lack of orthologs for a number of genes that are fundamentally important for PD, primarily orthologs of synuclein genes. A fundamentally different organization of the nervous system in comparison with vertebrates and humans. |
Lack of orthologs for a number of genes important for the development of PD. The ortholog of the synuclein genes is absent. There are significant differences in the organization of the nervous system from higher vertebrates. |
More difficult conditions for keeping in comparison with nematodes and fruit flies. Longer lifespan, which complicates the study of the effects of aging on neurodegeneration processes. |
Very limited range of genetic models. Relative complexity and high cost of keeping the animals. Limited opportunities to study the role of aging in the development of PD. |
A very limited range of natural mutations. Lack of genetic models with targeted modification of candidate disease genes and toxic models. Limited opportunities to study the role of aging in the development of Parkinson’s disease. |
Toxic models only. Long duration of the experiment. Very high cost of modeling. Problems with using large samples. Limited opportunities to study the role of aging in the development of Parkinson’s disease. |