Table 2.
Comparisons between CAR-T cells and CAR-NK cells.
CAR-T cells | CAR-NK cells | |
---|---|---|
Sources | mostly autologous T cells; using allogenic T cells may cause GVHD | various sources: PBMCs, UCB, NK cell line, iPSCs, hESCs, HPCs |
Transduction efficiency | higher | lower |
In-vivo persistence | better | worse |
Safety | using allogeneic T cells may cause GVHD; | rarely cause GVHD, may even protect against GVHD; |
CRS and neurotoxicity are two acute side effects observed in CAR-T cell immunotherapy | no CRS and neurotoxicity observed in CAR-NK cell immunotherapy | |
Efficacy | high: recognize tumor cells through the CAR-dependent manner | higher: recognize tumor cells through both CAR-dependent |
and CAR-independent manners | ||
Convenience | less convenience: necessities of matching HLA; | more convenience: the possibilities to be an off-to-shelf |
the consuming manufacturing time and expensive price | products because of no HLA-restriction and various sources | |
Current status | two CD19 CAR-T cells have been approved by the FDA; | preclinical and clinical trials have been conducted; |
new types of CAR-T cells have been conducted in clinical trial | several published data are available now |