Skip to main content
. 2021 Aug 20;6:31. doi: 10.1186/s41256-021-00216-0

Table 2.

Table illustrating the results of the critical appraisal process including manuscript information, the number of and occupation of participants and their critical appraisal score, including justification for points lost

Manuscript Interviews Critical appraisal
References First author Main research area and setting Number Participants CASP score CASP points lost/unclear
[21] Charani E Development of stewardship programmes in different countries. (SSA: Burkina Faso) 52 Healthcare professionals (doctors and pharmacists) 7/9

No. 5: No clear description of interview technique

No. 6: Lacking discussion of relationship between researcher and participants

[28] Legenza L Healthcare provider knowledge about Clostridium difficile infection in a South African hospital 26 Healthcare professionals (doctors, nurses and pharmacists) 8/9 No. 6: Lacking discussion of relationship between researchers and participants
[27] Gebretekle GB Implementation of antibiotic stewardship in an Ethiopian tertiary care hospital 35 Healthcare professionals (doctors, pharmacists) 8/9 No. 4: Subjective criteria for recruitment, focussing on prestige of job role
[32] Mula CT Workarounds and their perceived impact on antibiotic stewardship in a referral hospital in Malawi 13 Healthcare professionals (nurses) 7/9

No. 4: No discussion of recruitment criteria for interview

No. 6: Lacking discussion of relationship between researchers and participants

[31] Rout J The role of ICU nurses in antimicrobial stewardship at a South African private hospital 17 Healthcare professionals (doctors, nurses and pharmacists in ICU/surgery) 8/9 No. 6: Lacking discussion of relationship between researchers and participants
[19] Torres NF Patterns of self-medication in Maputo city, Mozambique 49 Healthcare professionals (pharmacists) and pharmacy customers 9/9 No points lost
[24] Agardh C Using pharmacists and drugstore workers as sexual healthcare workers among MSM in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania 15 Drugstore customers (men who have sex with men) 9/9 No points lost
[29] Asante KP Knowledge of antibiotic resistance and prescription practices in the Brong Ahafo Region of Ghana 33 Healthcare professionals (doctors, physician assistants, nurses and community health officers) 8/9 No. 8: Brief description of data analysis technique for qualitative component
[20] Gebretekle GB Exploration of over-the-counter sales in community pharmacies in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia 5 Healthcare professionals (pharmacists) 7/9

No. 4: Recruitment sequential, may not have achieved full geographical coverage

No. 5: Interview technique not discussed

[22] Yantzi R Antibiotic use for viral respiratory infection in rural southwestern Uganda 22 Healthcare professionals (clinical officers, nursing offices, nurses, laboratory staff, non-medical staff, public health professionals, village health team members) 6/9

No. 4: Recruitment strategy for non-host clinic participants unclear

No. 5: Interview technique not discussed

No. 6: Lacking discussion of relationship between researchers and participants

[23] Watkins JA Community perceptions of antibiotic usage in Mpumalanga province, South Africa 17 Community members randomly selected from a Health Demographic Surveillance site 9/9 No points lost
[25] Foster EK Patient knowledge of prescription medications and antibiotics in Blantyre, Malawi 54 Pharmacy customers at 5 randomly selected community pharmacies 8/9 No. 5: Interview technique/questions asked not discussed
[30] Pearson M Awareness of anti-microbial resistance in multiple low-income countries (SSA: Ethiopia, Nigeria and Sierra Leone) 244 Healthcare and veterinary professionals (doctors, dentists, nurses, pharmacists, educator, veterinarian) 9/9 No points lost
[26] Dillip A Factors influencing antibiotic dispensing in Tanzania 84 Healthcare professionals (pharmacy owners and dispensers) 9/9 No points lost