Table A31:
Author, Year, Country of Publication | Is the study population similar to the question?a | Are the interventions similar to the question?a | Is the health care system studied sufficiently similar to Ontario?a | Were the perspectives clearly stated? If yes, what were they?a | Are all direct effects included? Are all other effects included where they are material?a | Are all future costs and outcomes discounted? If yes, at what rate?a | Is the value of health effects expressed in terms of quality-adjusted life-years?a | Are costs and outcomes from other sectors fully and appropriately measured and valued?a | Overall Judgmentb |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Tanner et al, 2020, Canada78 | Partially | Partially | Yes | Unclear | Unclear | Yes, 3% | Yes | Partially | Partially applicable |
Groessl et al, 2018, United States79 | Partially | Partially | No | Yes, societal | No | Yes, 3% | Yes | Partially | Partially applicable |
Najafzadeh et al, 2017, United States81 | Partially | Partially | No | Yes, societal | Yes | Yes, 3% | Yes | Partially | Partially applicable |
Hornberger et al, 2015, United States80 | Partially | Partially | No | Partially | No | Yes, 3% | Yes | Partially | Partially applicable |
Response options were “yes,” “partially,” “no,” “unclear,” and “NA” (not applicable).
Response options for overall judgment were “directly applicable,” “partially applicable,” or “not applicable.”