Table 1.
Author, year; rheumatic condition; percentage female | Intervention and control group, n | Dropout, na (%) | Country | Intervention duration; mode, frequency, and duration of therapist contact | Type of therapist | Follow-up period |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Shigaki et al., 2013 Rheumatoid arthritis Percentage female: 92% |
Internet-based cognitive-behavioral therapy, 55 Waiting list, 53 |
Intervention 11 (20%) Measurement 15 (14%) Intervention follow-up 12 (22%) Measurement follow-up 20 (19%) |
USA |
Intervention duration: 10 weeks Mode/frequency/duration therapist contact: weekly telephone contact, ca. 15-30 min. Contact between patients was possible via biweekly scheduled chats, a discussion board, and a secured messaging system. |
Counselor with master's degree, trained in cognitive-behavioral therapy. | 9 months after treatment |
Friesen et al., 2017 Fibromyalgia Percentage female: 95% |
Internet-based cognitive-behavioral therapy, 30 Waiting list, 30 |
Intervention 5 (17%) Measurement 8 (14%) Intervention follow-up 13 (44%) Measurement follow-up 16 (27%) |
Canada |
Intervention duration: 8 weeks Mode/frequency/duration therapist contact: contact via telephone or secured messaging. Weekly 5-10 min telephone contact. |
Doctorate-level graduate student in clinical psychology. | No follow-up for the waiting list condition; 1 month follow-up after treatment for the internet-based cognitive-behavioral therapy condition. |
Lorig et al., 2008 Rheumatoid arthritis 28%; osteoarthritis 64%; fibromyalgia 52%; other arthritic conditions 14% Percentage female (total sample): 90% |
Internet-based cognitive-behavioral therapy, 433 Care-as-usual, 422 |
Intervention 123 (29%) Measurement 214 (25%) Intervention follow-up 126 (29%) Measurement follow-up 204 (24%) |
USA |
Intervention duration: 6 weeks Mode/frequency/duration therapist contact: online bulletin board and e-mail reminders; frequency and duration of contact unclear. |
Peer moderators. | 12 months after entry to treatment |
Ferwerda et al., 2017 Rheumatoid arthritis Percentage female: 64% |
Internet-based cognitive-behavioral therapy (care-as-usual + tailored internet-based cognitive-behavioral therapy), 62 Care-as-usual, 71 |
Intervention 17 (28%) Measurement 32 (24%) Intervention follow-up 33 (54%) Measurement follow-up 64 (49%) |
The Netherlands |
Intervention duration: 9–65 weeks (M = 26.07, SD = 12.22) 25% completed intervention in 17 weeks, 75% completed it in 32 weeks Mode/frequency/duration therapist contact: weekly or biweekly email contact. |
Psychologists with master's degree, under supervision of senior psychologist. | 3, 6, 9, 12 months after treatment |
Vallejo et al., 2015 Fibromyalgia Percentage female: 100% |
Internet-based cognitive-behavioral therapy, 20 Cognitive-behavioral therapy, 20 Waiting list, 20 |
Intervention 0 (0%) Measurement 0 (0%) Intervention follow-up 3 (15%) Measurement follow-up 7 (12%) |
Spain |
Intervention duration: 10 weeks Mode/frequency/duration therapist contact: internet-based cognitive-behavioral therapy: contact via online messaging. Frequency and duration of contact unclear. Cognitive-behavioral therapy: face-to-face group contact: 10 weekly sessions, each lasting 120 min. |
Internet-based cognitive-behavioral therapy: junior therapist under supervision of senior therapist. Cognitive-behavioral therapy: doctoral-level therapist. |
No follow-up for the waiting list condition; 3 follow-up assessments at 3, 6, and 12 months after treatment for the internet-based cognitive-behavioral therapy and cognitive-behavioral therapy conditions. |
Peters et al., 2017 Fibromyalgia 67%; other musculoskeletal pain 33% Percentage female (total sample): 85% |
Internet-based cognitive-behavioral therapy, 116 Positive Psychology intervention (PPI), 117 Waiting list, 51 |
Intervention 36 (31%) Measurement 78 (28%) Intervention follow-up 61 (53%) Measurement follow-up 135 (48%) |
The Netherlands/Belgium |
Intervention duration: 9 weeks Mode/frequency/duration therapist contact: both ICBT and PPI: Telephone (weeks 1, 3, 5, and 7) and e-mail (weeks 2, 4, 6, and 8) support. Average duration of telephone contact was 15-20 min. |
Both conditions: graduate or recently graduated psychologists. | No follow-up for the waiting list condition; 6 months follow-up after treatment for the Internet-based cognitive-behavioral therapy and positive psychology intervention. |
Simister et al., 2018 Fibromyalgia Percentage female: 95% |
Online acceptance and commitment therapy + care-as-usual, 33 Care-as-usual, 34 |
Intervention 6 (19%) Measurement 9 (14%) Intervention follow-up 8 (25%) Measurement follow-up 17 (26%) |
Canada |
Intervention duration: 2 months Mode/frequency/duration therapist contact: e-mail reminders on a weekly basis and feedback messages. |
Registered psychologist. | 3 months after treatment. |
Hedman-Lagerlöf et al., 2018 Fibromyalgia Percentage female: 98% |
Internet-delivered exposure therapy, 70 Waiting list, 70 |
Intervention 2 (3%) Measurement 2 (2%) Intervention follow-up 4 (6%) Measurement follow-up 4 (3%) |
Sweden |
Intervention duration: 10 weeks Mode/frequency/duration therapist contact: about 1 to 3 times/week coaching via asynchronous text messages. Reminders via text message or phone if a participant had been inactive for 4 days. In total, the average time therapists spent per participant was 2.9 h (SD = 2.1; median = 2.6; IQR = 2.6). |
Licensed psychologists or graduate psychology students. Weekly supervision by a licensed psychologist with experience in treating fibromyalgia. | No follow-up for the waiting list condition, 3 months and 6 months follow-up after treatment for the internet-delivered exposure therapy. |
See materials and methods.