Skip to main content
. 2021 Mar 11;121(16):10142–10186. doi: 10.1021/acs.chemrev.0c01111

Table 1. Overview of Different Topics and Applications of ML-FFs Discussed in This Sectiona.

category ref ML-FF max. Natoms reference theory
electronic effects Sauceda et al.70 sGDML 21 CCSD(T), CCSD
Sauceda et al.214 sGDML 21 CCSD(T), CCSD
Sauceda et al.69 sGDML 21 PBE, CCSD(T), CCSD
thermodynamics Morawietz et al.260 BP-NNP 6912 RPBE, BLYP
Andrade et al.261 DeepMD 426 SCAN
Deringer et al.262 GAP 1000 LDA
Behler et al.263 BP-NNP 64 LDA
Bartok et al.264 GAP 23 496 PW91
Deringer et al.265 GAP 4096 PW91
Bonati et al.266 DeepMD 680 SCAN
Brickel et al.213 PhysNet 6 MP2
reactions Unke et al.267 RKHS 3 UCCSD(T)
Denis et al.268 RKHS 3 UCCSD(T)-F12a
Lu et al.269 PIP-NN 7 UCCSD(T)-F12a
Sweeny et al.270 PhysNet 7 MP2
Käser et al.271 PhysNet 7 MP2
Rivero et al.272 PhysNet 19 M06-2X
Liu et al.273 BP-NNP 38 RPBE
nuclear quantum effects Chmiela et al.105 GDML 21 PBE
Chmiela et al.69 sGDML 21 CCSD, CCSD(T)
Schütt et al.274 SchNet 20 PBE
Sauceda et al.161 sGDML 21 CCSD, CCSD(T)
Hellström et al.275 BP-NNP 1700 RPBE
excited states Chen et al.276 HDNN 5 CASSCF
Westermayr et al.277 NN 6 MR-CISD
Westermayr et al.278 SchNet 6 MR-CISD, CASSCF
spectroscopy Gastegger et al.71 BP-NNP 209 BLYP, BP86, B2PLYP
Yao et al.195 BP-NNP 60 ωB97X-D
Raimbault et al.279 SOAP 80 PBE
Sommers et al.280 DeepMD 512 SCAN
a

In all cases, the type of employed ML-FF is given along with the number of atoms of the largest system used to study the respective phenomenon. The basic level of reference theory (neglecting basis sets and dispersion corrections for clarity) is also reported.