Table 1.
ASOs | AAVs/other viruses | Small molecules | DNA/RNA editing | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Risk/toxicity | • Intrathecal/invasive local CNS delivery is necessary. |
• Hepatotoxicity and dorsal root ganglion pathology after systemic delivery (particularly with high doses). • May need intrathecal/invasive local CNS delivery, though intravenous route is feasible. • Insertional mutagenesis. |
• Possible altered splicing/expression of off-target genes (e.g. high dose of SMN2 splicing modulator risdiplam affects FOXM1 splicing, leading to a protein product that blocks cell division). | • Irreversibility of DNA editing • Undesired on-target editing possible (large deletions and chromosomal rearrangements). • Possible immunogenicity from bacterial nucleases (Cas-proteins). |
Off-target effects | Binding to off-target mRNA due to complete or partial complementarity. | Ectopic expression in peripheral tissues after systemic delivery. | Non-specific binding to off-target mRNA possible. | Binding to off-target site due to homologous sequence or mismatch tolerance. |
Persistence of intervention | • Repeated administration necessary for persistent RNA modulation. | • Long-term transgene expression of AAV in postmitotic cells. • Long-term transgene expression of lentivirus in mitotically active and inactive cells. • Pre-existing neutralizing antibodies may reduce efficacy. • Immunogenicity of viral capsids and transgene products may affect long-term gene expression and repeated treatments. |
• Repeated oral administration necessary, typically low brain availability. | • Persistent genome manipulation by DNA-editing tools. |