Skip to main content
. 2021 Aug 1;11(8):507. doi: 10.3390/metabo11080507

Table 3.

Top 30 spectral regions and their contributing metabolites identified by both sets of ML analysis given in descending order of importance along with their statistical analysis.

Group 1: Glioma vs Control
ML Analysis Statistical Validation
Feature Importance Corresponding metabolite p-value log2(FC)
Model: Logistics Regression
1.47 1.0 Alanine <0.0001 –3.7744
Model: Extra Tree Classifier
2.55 0.0642 β-Alanine <0.0001 −2.5717
2.12 0.0524 Methionine <0.0001 −3.3458
3.1 0.0491 Phenylalanine <0.0001 −7.3967
3.07 0.0415 X <0.0001 −2.5445
2.69 0.0405 NAA <0.0001 −4.7668
1.47 0.0383 Alanine <0.0001 −3.7744
0.98 0.0299 Valine <0.0001 −2.7959
1.71 0.028 Leucine <0.0001 −3.5926
3.13 0.025 Glutathione 0.0013 −5.7592
2.45 0.0222 Glutamine <0.0001 −3.0169
1.88 0.022 GABA 0.0028 −1.1886
3.95 0.0204 Serine 0.0003 −2.4757
3.16 0.0182 Alanine <0.0001 −5.5148
3.69 0.0179 α-glucose <0.0001 −1.3382
1.44 0.0175 Deoxycholic acid <0.0001 10.114
3.18 0.0168 Taurocholic acid <0.0001 −4.2704
4.11 0.0161 Lactate <0.0001 2.7555
1.72 0.0157 Arginine 0.0003 −2.6918
3.58 0.0149 Threonine <0.0001 −6.6301
2.35 0.0148 Glutamate 0.0022 −1.4198
3.94 0.0143 Serine <0.0001 −2.3249
3.14 0.014 Spermidine 0.0119 −4.8047
3.88 0.014 Aspartic acid <0.0001 1.5565
2.09 0.0133 Glutamate <0.0001 −1.859
3.21 0.0126 N-Acetylcholine 0.0004 −4.3221
1.04 0.0126 Valine <0.0001 −1.8092
1.01 0.0124 Isoleucine 0.0002 3.8182
1.89 0.0121 GABA 0.001 −2.2659
3.68 0.0118 α-glucose <0.0001 4.8319
1.99 0.0117 Isoleucine 0.0006 −1.2174
Model: Random Forest
2.12 0.0491 Methionine <0.0001 −3.3458
0.98 0.0488 Valine <0.0001 −2.7959
3.16 0.0438 Alanine <0.0001 −5.5148
4.11 0.0344 Lactate <0.0001 2.7555
1.47 0.0316 Alanine <0.0001 −3.7744
3.53 0.03 Myoinositol 0.0003 1.0134
1.45 0.025 Isoleucine 0.0002 2.9475
1.44 0.0209 Deoxycholic acid <0.0001 10.114
1.99 0.0195 Isoleucine 0.0006 −1.2174
2.69 0.019 NAA <0.0001 −4.7668
2.32 0.0172 Glutamate 0.0003 2.1726
2.13 0.0172 Glutamine <0.0001 −3.4879
2.45 0.0165 Glutamine <0.0001 −3.0169
3.66 0.0157 Isoleucine 0.0050 4.9598
3.72 0.015 β-glucose 0.3716 NA
1.3 0.0146 Fatty acids <0.0001 −1.3971
3.94 0.0144 Serine <0.0001 −2.3249
3.69 0.0142 α-glucose <0.0001 −1.3382
1.01 0.0142 Isoleucine 0.0002 3.8182
0.92 0.0139 Isoleucine 0.0002 2.3071
2.09 0.0133 Glutamate <0.0001 −1.859
3.88 0.0117 Aspartate <0.0001 1.5565
3.59 0.0114 L-Valine 0.001‘ −6.9614
Age 0.0107 NA NA NA
1.17 0.0105 X 0.006 −2.41
1.88 0.0105 GABA 0.0028 −1.1886
3.46 0.0097 β-glucose 0.0178 NA
3.22 0.0093 Arginine 0.0191 NA
3.58 0.0091 Threonine <0.0001 −6.6301
3.47 0.0084 β-glucose 0.7007 NA
Group 2: LGG vs HGG
ML Analysis Statistical Validation
Feature Importance Corresponding metabolite p-value log2(FC)
Model: Logistics Regression
3.51 0.2059 Choline 0.030 NA
2.01 0.1116 NAA 0.041 1.239
3.2 0.0719 P-Choline 0.127 NA
1.02 0.0531 Valine 0.040 NA
3.48 0.0523 β-Glucose 0.040 NA
2.39 0.0442 Succinate/Malate 0.040 −1.1293
1.68 0.0441 L-Arginine 0.227 1.678
1.82 0.0435 X 0.015 1.4804
2.4 0.0416 Succinate 0.092 NA
2.31 0.0386 X 0.207 −1.647
3.5 0.0324 NAA 0.133 −2.3824
2.3 0.0311 GABA 0.133 −3.0367
1.84 0.026 X 0.054 1.6947
3.53 0.026 Myoinositol 0.871 NA
1.26 0.0236 Isoleucine 0.064 −2.4499
1.99 0.0171 Isoleucine 0.039 NA
2.45 0.0156 L-Glutamine 0.195 NA
0.88 0.015 Fatty acid 0.239 −2.0748
3.91 0.0149 Creatine 0.054 1.2722
1.21 0.0125 X 0.054 3.6568
2.25 0.0122 Fatty acid 0.206 2.6199
0.9 0.012 Fatty acid 0.041 1.6497
3.26 0.0028 Taurine 0.009 1.1339
1.83 0 X 0.388 −1.791
1.63 0 X 0.195 NA
1.86 0 GABA 0.206 1.9942
1.97 0 Isoleucine 0.182 1.679
1.47 0 Alanine 0.640 3.2255
1.87 0 GABA 0.195 NA
1.88 0 GABA 0.195 NA
Model: Extra Tree Classifier
3.6 0.0637 Valine 0.015 1.5337
1.82 0.0352 X 0.015 1.4804
2.5 0.0265 NAA 0.015 1.3842
1.4 0.0254 X 0.071 1.5535
2.4 0.0254 Succinate 0.092 1.1227
1.97 0.0247 Isoleucine 0.182 1.679
2.04 0.0244 Glutamate 0.030 1.4984
0.99 0.0237 Isoleucine 0.104 1.2242
2.53 0.0232 X 0.015 2.0478
3.26 0.0232 Taurine 0.009 1.1339
2.08 0.0211 Glutamate 0.036 NA
3.59 0.0207 Threonine 0.053 NA
0.91 0.0186 Fatty acids 0.011 1.6453
0.98 0.017 Valine 0.249 1.7767
1.99 0.0167 Isoleucine 0.039 1.429
0.9 0.0167 Fatty acids 0.041 1.6497
3.33 0.0164 Scyllo inositol 0.015 1.5207
2.43 0.0162 Glutamine 0.222 NA
1.22 0.016 X 0.103 NA
3.91 0.0159 Creatine 0.054 1.2722
2.72 0.0154 NAA 0.136 2.2715
2.84 0.0149 X 0.054 1.2673
3.51 0.0144 Choline 0.030
0.85 0.0143 Tauro-cholicacid 0.726 −1.0208
1.68 0.0137 Leucine 0.227 1.678
3.54 0.0131 Glycine 0.050 1.1865
1.36 0.0127 Fatty acids 0.519 NA
3.42 0.0124 Taurine/Proline 0.031 NA
1.05 0.0123 Valine 0.097 1.5722
2.32 0.0119 Glutamate 0.026 NA
Model: Random Forest
3.6 0.0637 Valine 0.015 1.5337
1.82 0.0352 X 0.015 1.4804
2.5 0.0265 NAA 0.015 1.3842
1.4 0.0254 X 0.071 1.5535
2.4 0.0254 Succinate 0.092 1.1227
1.97 0.0247 Isoleucine 0.182 1.679
2.04 0.0244 Glutamate 0.030 1.4984
0.99 0.0237 Isoleucine 0.104 1.2242
2.53 0.0232 X 0.015 2.0478
3.26 0.0232 Taurine 0.009 1.1339
2.08 0.0211 Glutamate 0.036 NA
3.59 0.0207 Threonine 0.053 NA
0.91 0.0186 Fatty acids 0.011 1.6453
0.98 0.017 Valine 0.249 1.7767
1.99 0.0167 Isoleucine 0.039 1.429
0.9 0.0167 Fatty acids 0.041 NA
3.33 0.0164 scyllo inositol 0.015 1.5207
2.43 0.0162 Glutamine 0.222 NA
1.22 0.016 X 0.103 NA
3.91 0.0159 Creatine 0.054 1.2722
2.72 0.0154 NAAG 0.136 2.2715
2.84 0.0149 X 0.054 1.2673
3.51 0.0144 Choline 0.030 NA
0.85 0.0143 Tauro-cholicacid 0.726 −1.0208
1.68 0.0137 Leucine 0.227 1.678
3.54 0.0131 Glycine 0.050 1.1865
1.36 0.0127 Fatty acids 0.519 NA
3.42 0.0124 Taurine/Proline 0.031 NA
1.05 0.0123 Valine 0.097 1.5722
2.32 0.0119 Glutamate 0.026 NA

Key used: NAA = N-Acetylaspartate; X = Unknown metabolite; NA = Not available.