Table 1.
Characteristics of Included Case Reports and Case Series
| Study ID | Country | No. of Fentanyl-Analogue Death Cases Reported | Study Design | Source of Death | Inferred Route of Administration | Cause of Death | Nature of Death |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brockbals et al 201927 | Switzerland | n=1 ● Male ● Age: 39 |
Case report | Cyclopropylfentanyl | Inhalation | Combined intoxication with ethanol and cyclopropylfentanyl | Unspecified |
| Butler et al 201728 | USA | n=3 ● Male: 3 ● Age range: 23–43 |
Case report | Acrylfentanyl Furanylfentanyl |
Intravenous (n=3) | Acrylfentanyl toxicity (n=1) Toxic effects of acryfentanyl and hydrocodone (n=1) Acryfentanyl and furanylfentanyl toxicity (n=1) |
Accidental (n=3) |
| Castellino et al 202029 | USA | n=2 ● Male: 2 ● Age range: 24–25 ● Caucasian |
Case report | Cyclopropylfentanyl | Not specified | Cyclopropylfentanyl overdose (n=1) Mixed drug toxicity (n=1) |
Accidental (n=2) |
| Corsi et al 201930 | USA | n=17 ● Male: 15 Female: 2 ● Age range: 21–51 ● Caucasian: 15 ● African-American: 2 |
Case series | Carfentanil | Intravenous (n=5) Undetermined (n=12) |
Drug abuse (n=10) Drug intoxication (n=6) Drug overdose (n=1) |
Suicide by overdose (n=1) Undetermined (n=17) |
| Daniulaityte et al 201731 | USA | n=281 ● Male: 181 Female: 100 ● Age range: ● White, non-Hispanic: 257 ● Black or other: 24 |
Case series | Fentanyl Norfentanyl Acrylfentanyl Furanylfentanyl Carfentanil |
Unspecified | Drug overdose (n=281) | Accidental (n=281) |
| Elliott et al 201832 | UK | n=7 ● Male: 5 Female: 2 ● Age range: 29–44 |
Case series | Carfentanil | Intravenous (n=1) Not specified (n=6) |
Mixed drug toxicity (n=7). | Undetermined but hinted to be accidental |
| Fagiola et al 201833 | USA | n=5 ● Male: 4 Female: 1 ● Age ranges: 19–49 ● White: 5 |
Case report | Cyclopropylfentanyl | Intravenous (n=1) Inhalation (n=1) Unspecified (n=3) |
Mixed drug toxicity (n=5) | Accidental (n=5) |
| Gaulier et al 201934 | France | n=1 ● Male ● Age: 41 |
Case report | Carfentanil | Intralingual | Mixed drug toxicity | Accidental |
| Hikin et al 201835 | UK | n=25 ● Male: 22 Female: 3 ● Age range: 21–54 |
Case series | Carfentanil Butyryl fentanyl 4F-butyryl fentanyl Furanyl fentanyl |
Unspecified | Mixed drug toxicity (n=25) | Unspecified |
| Krotulski et al 201736 | USA | n=1 ● Male ● Age: 31 ● White |
Case report | Tetrahydrofuranyl-fentanyl | Intravenous | Mixed drug toxicity | Accidental |
| Moss et al 201937 | Western Australia | n=1 ● Male ● Age: 24 |
Case report | Acetylfentanyl | Intravenous | Acetylfentanyl toxicity | Accidental |
| O’Donnell et al 201724 | USA | n=720 ● Male: 520 Female: 200 ● Age range: <15 – >65 ● White, non-Hispanic: 602 ● Black, non-Hispanic: 75 ● Other, non-Hispanic: 9 ● Hispanic: 20 |
Case series | Carfentanil Furanylfentanyl Acetylfentanyl |
Intravenous (n=303) Inhalation (n=95) Ingestion (n=41) Smoking (n=25) Unspecified (n=279) |
● Fentanyl analogue toxicity ● Mixed drug/polydrug toxicity ● Specific numbers unclear |
Unspecified |
| Shanks et al 201738 | USA | n=13 ● Male: 8 Female: 5 ● Age range: 25–62 |
Case report | Carfentanil | Intravenous (n=3) Unspecified (n=10) |
Carfentanil drug toxicity (n=7) Mixed carfentanil and fentanyl toxicity (n=2) Mixed drug intoxication (n=4) |
Accidental (n=13) |
| Swanson et al 201739 | USA | n=2 ● Male: 2 ● Age range: 25–34 ● White: 2 |
Case report | Carfentanil Furanylfentanyl |
Intravenous (n=1) Unspecified (n=1) |
Mixed drug toxicity (n=1) Carfentanil overdose (n=1) |
Accidental (n=2) |