Skip to main content
. 2021 Aug 16;2021(8):CD014963. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD014963

Dequin 2020.

Study characteristics
Methods Trial design: multicenter, double‐blind randomised trial
Type of publication: journal publication
Setting: inpatient
Recruitment dates: 7 March‐1 June 2020
Country: France
Language: English
Number of centres: 9
Trial registration number: NCT02517489
Date first posted: 7 August 2015
Participants Age: 
  • median age 63.1 years (IQR 51.5‐70.8) in the intervention group

  • median age 66.3 years (IQR 53.5‐72.7) in the control group


Gender: 
  • 54 male (71.1%) and 22 female (28.9%) in the intervention group

  • 50 male (68.5%) and 23 female (31.5%) in the control group


Proportion of PCR‐confirmed infections
  • Positive: 94.7% intervention arm, 98.8% control arm

  • Negative: not reported

  • Unclear: not reported


Ethnicity: not reported
Number of participants (recruited/allocated/evaluated): 
  • recruited: 40

  • allocated: 76 intervention group and 73 control group

  • evaluated: 76 in intervention group and 73 in the control group


Severity of condition according to study definition
  • Mechanical ventilation (included noninvasive ventilation):

    • 81.6% in the intervention group

    • 59% in the control group

  • High‐flow oxygen therapy:

    • 13.2% in the intervention group

    • 12.3% in the control group

  • Nonrebreathing mask with reservoir bag:

    • 5.3%% in the intervention group

    • 6.8% in the control group


Severity of condition according to WHO score: moderate to severe ≥ 5
Co‐morbidities: diabetes, COPD/asthma, immunosuppression
Inclusion criteria
  • Admitted to 1 of the 9 participating French ICUs for acute respiratory failure

  • At least 18 years of age

  • Biologically confirmed (RT‐PCR) or suspected (suggestive chest CT scan result in the absence of any other cause of pneumonia) COVID‐19

  • 1 of 4 severity criteria had to be present:

    • Need for mechanical ventilation with a PEEP of ≥ 5 cm H2O

    • A ratio of PaO2 to FIo2 < 300 on high‐flow oxygen therapy with an FIO2 value of at least 50%

    • For participants receiving oxygen through a reservoir mask, a PaO2:FIO2 ratio < 300, estimated using prespecified charts;

    • Or a Pulmonary Severity Index > 130


Exclusion criteria
  • Unable to meet inclusion deadlines

  • Included in another interventional trial

  • Septic shock

  • Long‐term corticosteroid therapy

  • Did not meet severity criteria

  • Transferred to another ICU

  • Medical team declined enrolment

  • Under judicial protection

  • Do‐not‐intubate order

  • Moribund

  • Declined to participate

  • Required hydrocortisone for other medical condition

  • Miscellaneous

  • Previous treatments (e.g. experimental drug therapies, oxygen therapy, ventilation): yes

Interventions Treatment details of intervention group (e.g dose, route of administration, number of doses):
  • Type of corticosteroid: hydrocortisone

  • Dose: 200 mg/day until day 7, then 100 mg/day for 4 days and 50mg/day for 3 days, for a total of 14 days

  • Route of administration: IV


Treatment details of control group (e.g dose, route of administration, number of doses): Placebo
Concomitant therapy (e.g description of standard care): not reported
Duration of follow‐up: last follow‐up on 29 June 2020
Treatment cross‐overs: no
Compliance with assigned treatment: yes
Outcomes Primary study outcome: treatment failure on day 21 (death or persistent dependence of mechanical ventilation or high‐flow oxygen therapy)
Review outcomes:
Inpatient setting:
  • All‐cause mortality at day 21, or longest observation period: reported

  • Improvement of clinical status during observation period:

    • Liberation from IMV in participants i.e. transition to WHO ≤ 6 if ≥ 7 at baseline (see Figure 1). If liberation was not available directly, death was used as a proxy for assumed non‐liberation counted together with participants alive and ventilated: not reported

    • Ventilator‐free days and alive:  not reported

  • Worsening of clinical status during observation period:

    • New need for IMV i.e. transition to WHO 7‐9 if ≤ 6 at baseline (see Figure 1):  not reported

  • Need for dialysis (at up to 28 days): not reported

  • Quality of life, including fatigue and neurological status, assessed with standardised scales (e.g. WHOQOL‐100) at longest follow‐up available: not reported

  • Viral clearance, assessed with RT‐PCR test for SARS‐CoV‐2 at baseline, up to 3, 7, and 15 days: not reported

  • SAEs: reported

  • AEs (any grade): reported

  • Hospital‐acquired infections: reported


Additional study outcomes: endotracheal intubation (for patients noninvasively ventilated at inclusion), prone position, ECMO, inhaled nitric oxide
Identification  
Notes Date of publication: 6 October 2020
Sponsor/funding: University Hospital, Tours